Featured categories
Featured items
Newly Listed
See allAll items

2025 Topps Paul Skenes #OTC-11 Oversized SP Costco Exclusive 8"x5.75" Pirates 🔥
$35.00

Lorcana Azurite Sea Singles All Rarities COLD FOIL You Pick
$1.00 to $12.00

2023-24 Upper Deck Ice - Ice Premieres Autographs Connor Bedard #IPA-CB /199 RC
$1,100.00

Disney Lorcana Shimmering Skies Legendary Non-Foil You Pick Card
$3.00 to $6.00

ROB GRONKOWSKI 2010 Score Hot Rookies #26 Rookie Card RC
$5.00

2023 Topps Allen & Ginter - Framed Mini Printing Plate Magenta #253 Sean Murphy
$40.00

2022-23 UD Artifacts U-PICK Base Team Sets!!!!!
$1.00 to $3.00

2023-24 UD SPX Black Rookies of A Nation RPA Jakob Pelletier Canada /99 !!!!
$50.00

2021-22 Upper Deck Artifacts Silver Spectrum Sidney Crosby #116 Penguins /299
$5.00

2019 Score Game Worn Material Relics You choose. Complete your set.
$3.00 to $5.00

2021-22 Artifacts Autofacts Signature RHETT GARDNER #AF-RG Auto
$5.00

2023-24 Upper Deck Artifacts Base Material Gold Relics #25 Pavel Buchnevich /249
$8.00

Goose Gossage "HOF 2008" Authentic Signed Grey Pro Jersey Beckett Certified
$90.00

2025Topps Series 1 Bo Jackson 35th Anniversary gold SP #T90-62 46/50
$35.00

Lane Hutson RC 2024-25 Upper Deck SPx Base #139 Montreal Canadiens
$15.00

2024 onathan Taylor Absolute Burner patch card
$3.00

Stitch - Alien Buccaneer - PROMO HOLOFOIL - (Stitch Collector's Gift Set Promo)
$10.00

2021-22 Upper Deck Artifacts - Brent Burns Autograph Black #122 1/5 !!!! POP 1
$180.00

2024 Panini Luminance - Rookies #179 Michael Penix Jr. (RC)
$1.00

2022-23 Upper Deck Artifacts - Stars #113 Jordan Kyrou INDIGO #5/10 PSA 10 POP 1
$50.00

2021-22 Upper Deck Artifacts Alexandre Texier Autofacts Autograph Auto #AF-TE
$8.00

2021 Donruss NFL Optic Trey Lance RC Rated Rookie Silver Holo SSP #203 49ers QB
$10.00

2021 UD Artifacts Elias Lindholm Flames Tri-Color Patch Emerald 01/65 PSA 10 #56
$50.00

2021-22 Upper Deck Artifacts - Gold Material Relics Ondrej Palat /249 Dual Patch
$5.00

2021-22 Artifacts 2005-06 Clear Cut Retro Rookies #CC05-1 Auston Matthews
$30.00

2024 Panini Absolute BO Nix RC #112
$2.00

2022-23 UD Trilogy Generations GREEN Brady Tkachuk /75 #TG-1B
$5.00

2020-21 Upper Deck Artifacts - Material Orange #54 Kevin Fiala /15 (MEM)
$10.00

2023 Artifacts 2022-23 Update Clear Cut Rookies 2023-24 Upper Deck Kaiden Guhle
$8.00

Ricky Williams Autographed 8x10 1998 Heisman
$90.00

2023-24 UD Artifacts Ruby Rookie #181 Akito Hirose /299- Vancouver Canucks
$6.00

Chris Olave 2022 Donruss Optic First Year Fresh Saints Rookie Prizm Patch RC
$5.00

2023-24 OPC Marquee Rookie Platinum Orange Checker Marc Del Gaizo /25!!!
$25.00

2021-22 Upper Deck Artifacts Stars #101 Connor McDavid /599
$5.00

Disney Lorcana Shimmering Skies - Super Rare (Cold Foil) You Pick/Choose
$1.00 to $4.00

2023 Topps Series 2 - #491 Ji Hwan Bae (RC) Purple refractor /799
$4.00

2023 Bowman Platinum - Top Prospects #TOP-37 Jimmy Crooks III (RC) /199
$5.00

2021-22 UD Artifacts Material Relic Parallel John Gibson - Anaheim Ducks /249
$5.00

2021/22 Upper Deck Artifacts Net Gear Carey Price
$5.00

2023 Topps Series 2 - #458 Dakota Hudson
$2.00

2023-24 UD Ice Exquisite Collection Rookie #R28 Henry Thrun! #237/999
$6.00

2023 Topps Series 2 - #379 Dansby Swanson
$2.00

2022-23 Artifacts NHL Remnants Jersey #NR-OB Oliver Bjorkstrand
$5.00

2023 Topps Series 2 - #495 Martin Maldonado
$2.00

2022 LEAF PRO SET METAL CHRIS OLAVE ROOKIE/RC AUTO #7/25 *PURPLE WAVE*
$50.00

2024 Score Men of Canton First Down #5 Deion Sanders #5/10. Prime Time!!
$40.00

2021 Upper Deck Artifacts 2005-06 Retro Rookies Lucas Raymond #’d 891/999 #1 RC
$5.00

2022-23 Upper Deck Artifacts Legends /599 Wayne Gretzky #170 HOF
$8.00
About us
Welcome to BargainBay Collectables, your ultimate destination for treasure hunting! Dive into a world where nostalgia meets excitement, offering an extensive selection of unique collectibles that are sure to delight enthusiasts of all ages. Explore our top categories, featuring a vast array of sports memorabilia that celebrates your favorite teams and athletes, alongside a dedicated Cards & Fan Shop that caters to passionate collectors and fans alike. Don’t forget to check out our Toys & Hobbies section, where imagination meets adventure, providing endless fun for kids and collectors at heart. At BargainBay Collectables, every visit promises a new discovery, so come find your next prized possession today!
Store policies
Shipping
Seller feedback (48)
- p***4 (161)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseFast shipping, item as described, great packaging, excellent seller! A+++
- o***s (23)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseTop notch seller! Great communication. Even sent extra pictures on the chat upon request. Great packaging and even included a few extra cards for my PC. Thank you!!!
- l***3 (262)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseCard arrived well packaged and in great condition. A+++++. Highly recommend seller.
- h***e (419)- Feedback left by buyer.Past yearVerified purchaseSuper fast shipping and packed with care. Recommended seller, buy with ease. A++++
- _***_ (291)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseGreat packaging, card as described. Thank you.
- w***p (12004)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseSuper ebay seller the best period A++++and fast shipping!!!!