Skip to main content

Best selling products: Best Milani Matte Paraben-Free Eye Shadow Products

BestsellingTop Rated
Too Faced Natural Eyes Eyeshadow Palette - Shimmery/Matte
Rank 1
Too Faced Natural Eyes Eyeshadow Palette - Shimmery/Matte
(21)
$29.99 New
No used products available
Too Faced Born This Way The Natural Nudes Eyeshadow Palette - 16 Colors
Rank 2
Too Faced Born This Way The Natural Nudes Eyeshadow Palette - 16 Colors
(17)
$24.95 New
No used products available
MAKEUP BY MARIO Ethereal Eyes Moonlight Eyeshadow Palette 12 x 0.04oz
Rank 3
MAKEUP BY MARIO Ethereal Eyes Moonlight Eyeshadow Palette 12 x 0.04oz
$39.49 New
No used products available
Mac Dazzleshadow Shade I Like 2 Watch 1g
Rank 4
Mac Dazzleshadow Shade I Like 2 Watch 1g
(8)
$11.66 New
No used products available
Urban Decay Naked3 Eye Shadow Palette - 12 Colors (2 Palettes)
Rank 5
Urban Decay Naked3 Eye Shadow Palette - 12 Colors (2 Palettes)
(101)
$37.70 New
No used products available
Urban Decay NAKED2 Eyeshadow Palette
Rank 6
Urban Decay NAKED2 Eyeshadow Palette
$92.94 New
No used products available
Tarte Tartelette Energy Amazonian Clay Palette 12 Shades Expirtn 11/2026 Box
Rank 7
Tarte Tartelette Energy Amazonian Clay Palette 12 Shades Expirtn 11/2026 Box
(7)
$21.95 New
No used products available
Bobbi Brown Eye Shadow Bone 2 Full Sized
Rank 8
Bobbi Brown Eye Shadow Bone 2 Full Sized
(5)
$84.99 New
No used products available
Urban Decay Naked Heat 12 Shades Eyeshadow Palette
Rank 9
Urban Decay Naked Heat 12 Shades Eyeshadow Palette
(33)
$24.45 New
No used products available
Photo Edit Eyeshadow Trio by Smashbox Nudie Pic (medium)
Rank 10
Photo Edit Eyeshadow Trio by Smashbox Nudie Pic (medium)
(4)
$33.95 New
No used products available
bareMinerals Mineralist 6 Colors Eyeshadow Palette Ultranatural
Rank 11
bareMinerals Mineralist 6 Colors Eyeshadow Palette Ultranatural
(1)
$15.99 New
No used products available
Tarte Glamazon Amazonian Clay Eyeshadow Palette 10 Shades With Brush
Rank 12
Tarte Glamazon Amazonian Clay Eyeshadow Palette 10 Shades With Brush
$13.56 New
No used products available
Violet Voss Olive You Forever Eyeshadow Palette (VS02)
Rank 13
Violet Voss Olive You Forever Eyeshadow Palette (VS02)
(15)
$13.00 New
No used products available
NARS Ignited 1350 Eyeshadow Palette X12 100 Authentic
Rank 14
NARS Ignited 1350 Eyeshadow Palette X12 100 Authentic
(8)
$24.26 New
No used products available
COVERGIRL Eye Enhancers Eyeshadow French Vanilla 700 B11
Rank 15
COVERGIRL Eye Enhancers Eyeshadow French Vanilla 700 B11
(14)
$12.50 New
No used products available
Clinique All About Shadow Quad 10 Going Steady eyeshadow .16oz Eye Shadow BOXED
Rank 16
Clinique All About Shadow Quad 10 Going Steady eyeshadow .16oz Eye Shadow BOXED
$20.99 New
No used products available
Lancome Color Design Sensational Effects Eye Shadow Smooth Hold
Rank 17
Lancome Color Design Sensational Effects Eye Shadow Smooth Hold
(12)
$34.19 New
No used products available
MAC Bougie Pro Longwear Paint Pot
Rank 18
MAC Bougie Pro Longwear Paint Pot
(5)
$16.14 New
No used products available
COVERGIRL Eye Enhancers 1 Kit Shadow Sterling Blue 600
Rank 19
COVERGIRL Eye Enhancers 1 Kit Shadow Sterling Blue 600
(17)
$7.99 New
No used products available
Mally Mallywood Eyeshadow Palette ️ 100 Authentic -
Rank 20
Mally Mallywood Eyeshadow Palette ️ 100 Authentic -
(2)
$6.09 New
No used products available
Revlon Colorstay Creme Eye Shadow Licorice 755 0.18 Oz
Rank 21
Revlon Colorstay Creme Eye Shadow Licorice 755 0.18 Oz
(8)
$6.99 New
No used products available
Mac eyeshadow single - Marsh 0.05oz/1.5g
Rank 22
Mac eyeshadow single - Marsh 0.05oz/1.5g
$13.87 New
No used products available
Julep Beauty Eyeshadow 101 Stick Lilac Matte Cream to Powder 0.04oz/1.4g
Rank 23
Julep Beauty Eyeshadow 101 Stick Lilac Matte Cream to Powder 0.04oz/1.4g
$8.99 New
No used products available
It Cosmetics Superhero Eye Shadow Stick Silk Armor HTF
Rank 24
It Cosmetics Superhero Eye Shadow Stick Silk Armor HTF
(5)
$7.87 New
No used products available
Urban Decay Naked Honey Eyeshadow Palette - Assorted (12 Pack)
Rank 25
Urban Decay Naked Honey Eyeshadow Palette - Assorted (12 Pack)
(16)
$27.99 New
No used products available
Smashbox Always On Moodboard Eyeshadow Palette - Cozy Vibes
Rank 26
Smashbox Always On Moodboard Eyeshadow Palette - Cozy Vibes
$10.80 New
No used products available
MAC Eye Shadow - CLUB - 0.05oz Full Size / BOXED
Rank 27
MAC Eye Shadow - CLUB - 0.05oz Full Size / BOXED
(3)
$21.88 New
No used products available
ELF Liquid Glitter Eyeshadow 24k Gold
Rank 28
ELF Liquid Glitter Eyeshadow 24k Gold
$9.99 New
No used products available
Burberry Eye Colour Wet & Dry Silk Shadow # 101 Stone 2015
Rank 29
Burberry Eye Colour Wet & Dry Silk Shadow # 101 Stone 2015
(3)
$13.88 New
No used products available
(2) Essence Welcome To Marrakesh Eyeshadow Palette 0.46 oz Each
Rank 30
(2) Essence Welcome To Marrakesh Eyeshadow Palette 0.46 oz Each
$3.75 New
No used products available
Laura Mercier Caviar Stick Eye Color- Cashmere
Rank 31
Laura Mercier Caviar Stick Eye Color- Cashmere
$21.62 New
No used products available
Mac Eye Shadow Lidschatten Sketch Velvet 1 3g
Rank 32
Mac Eye Shadow Lidschatten Sketch Velvet 1 3g
(1)
$16.79 New
No used products available
Tom Ford Beauty Eye Color Quad 23 African Violet
Rank 33
Tom Ford Beauty Eye Color Quad 23 African Violet
$58.88 New
No used products available
Pure Cosmetics Stripped Collection Eyeshadow Palette 12 Colors
Rank 34
Pure Cosmetics Stripped Collection Eyeshadow Palette 12 Colors
(11)
$9.99 New
No used products available
B9 Stila Shimmer & Glow Liquid Eye Shadow Jezebel
Rank 35
B9 Stila Shimmer & Glow Liquid Eye Shadow Jezebel
(2)
$15.70 New
No used products available
BORGHESE SATIN MILANO EYE SHADOW TRIO - "Romantico Brown" -
Rank 36
BORGHESE SATIN MILANO EYE SHADOW TRIO - "Romantico Brown" -
(3)
$13.99 New
No used products available
Too Faced Ladies Natural Lust Assorted Eyeshadow Palette 90747
Rank 37
Too Faced Ladies Natural Lust Assorted Eyeshadow Palette 90747
(7)
$66.00 New
No used products available
L.a. Girl Fanatic Eyeshadow Palette Get Feverish 1 Oz
Rank 38
L.a. Girl Fanatic Eyeshadow Palette Get Feverish 1 Oz
(2)
$7.25 New
No used products available
theBalm Overshadow The Sexpot Series If You're Rich Im Single
Rank 39
theBalm Overshadow The Sexpot Series If You're Rich Im Single
(2)
$6.75 New
No used products available
Maybelline Color Tattoo up to 24hr Longwear Cream Eyeshadow 55 Risk Maker
Rank 40
Maybelline Color Tattoo up to 24hr Longwear Cream Eyeshadow 55 Risk Maker
(1)
$7.99 New
No used products available
Smashbox Always On Cream Shadow Sepia
Rank 41
Smashbox Always On Cream Shadow Sepia
(2)
$14.99 New
No used products available
Morphe 35c Everyday Chic Eyeshadow Artistry Palette
Rank 42
Morphe 35c Everyday Chic Eyeshadow Artistry Palette
(2)
$25.40 New
No used products available
Too Faced Melted Chocolate Matte Shadow Warm & Fudgy
Rank 43
Too Faced Melted Chocolate Matte Shadow Warm & Fudgy
(2)
$9.26 New
No used products available
1 Smashbox Cover Shot Major Metals Eye Palette 8 Colors of Eyeshadows
Rank 44
1 Smashbox Cover Shot Major Metals Eye Palette 8 Colors of Eyeshadows
(8)
$11.25 New
No used products available
NYX Love in Florence Eyeshadow Palette XOXO Mona Lif03
Rank 45
NYX Love in Florence Eyeshadow Palette XOXO Mona Lif03
(2)
$6.99 New
No used products available
Maybelline Color Tattoo 24hr Eyeshadow 85 Deep Forest
Rank 46
Maybelline Color Tattoo 24hr Eyeshadow 85 Deep Forest
(8)
$9.99 New
No used products available
ILIA Liquid Powder Matte Eye Tint by ILIA .12 oz Eye Tint - Adobe
Rank 47
ILIA Liquid Powder Matte Eye Tint by ILIA .12 oz Eye Tint - Adobe
$19.99 New
No used products available
Maybelline Color Tattoo up to 24hr Longwear Cream Eyeshadow 10 VIP
Rank 48
Maybelline Color Tattoo up to 24hr Longwear Cream Eyeshadow 10 VIP
$7.00 New
No used products available
CLARINS OMBRE 4 EYESHADOWS INTENSE & LONG-LASTING 03 FLAME GRADATION
Rank 49
CLARINS OMBRE 4 EYESHADOWS INTENSE & LONG-LASTING 03 FLAME GRADATION
$9.99 New
No used products available
️ 2x COVERGIRL Exhibitionist Lid Paint 100 Darling 5ml
Rank 50
️ 2x COVERGIRL Exhibitionist Lid Paint 100 Darling 5ml
(3)
$6.98 New
No used products available
Smashbox Suicide Cream Shadow in Blood SPORT Squad Always 0.34 Oz
Rank 51
Smashbox Suicide Cream Shadow in Blood SPORT Squad Always 0.34 Oz
$7.46 New
No used products available
Maybelline The Nudes 24k Eyeshadow Palette - 12 Shades
Rank 52
Maybelline The Nudes 24k Eyeshadow Palette - 12 Shades
(29)
$9.45 New
No used products available
Covergirl 0.05oz. Clean Eye Color Golden Toffee Eyeshadow Stick -
Rank 53
Covergirl 0.05oz. Clean Eye Color Golden Toffee Eyeshadow Stick -
$11.99 New
No used products available
2 Almay Velvet Foil Cream Shadow 24 HR Wear # 010 End Game
Rank 54
2 Almay Velvet Foil Cream Shadow 24 HR Wear # 010 End Game
(3)
$6.06 New
No used products available
Lash Step Matte About You Eyeshadow Palette Vegan Cruelty Clean Beauty
Rank 55
Lash Step Matte About You Eyeshadow Palette Vegan Cruelty Clean Beauty
$8.99 New
No used products available
Tom Ford Shadow Extreme Eye Shadow/0.04 Oz. Sapphire Blue 09 Tfx9
Rank 56
Tom Ford Shadow Extreme Eye Shadow/0.04 Oz. Sapphire Blue 09 Tfx9
$17.99 New
No used products available
Illamasqua Artistry Unveiled Artistry Eye Shadow Palette
Rank 57
Illamasqua Artistry Unveiled Artistry Eye Shadow Palette
(3)
$7.50 New
No used products available
Maybelline Expert Wear Eyeshadow Quads 48q Emerald Smokes
Rank 58
Maybelline Expert Wear Eyeshadow Quads 48q Emerald Smokes
(4)
$11.48 New
No used products available
2 Almay Velvet Foil Cream Shadow 24 HR Wear # 070 Astro Girl
Rank 59
2 Almay Velvet Foil Cream Shadow 24 HR Wear # 070 Astro Girl
(2)
$7.65 New
No used products available
2 X Vamp Stamp VIGNETTE I Vavavoom Wing Kitten Stamp VINK Eyeliner Brush
Rank 60
2 X Vamp Stamp VIGNETTE I Vavavoom Wing Kitten Stamp VINK Eyeliner Brush
(1)
$8.96 New
No used products available
Laura Geller Cool Lids Cream Eye Shadow Mermaid Marine
Rank 61
Laura Geller Cool Lids Cream Eye Shadow Mermaid Marine
(1)
$7.99 New
No used products available
Borghese Satin Shadow MILANO Trio Eyeshadow in SPLENDORO Green 04 - Boxed
Rank 62
Borghese Satin Shadow MILANO Trio Eyeshadow in SPLENDORO Green 04 - Boxed
(3)
$13.95 New
No used products available
Disney THE ARISTOCATS - MARIE - 12 Color Eyeshadow Palette - Full size
Rank 63
Disney THE ARISTOCATS - MARIE - 12 Color Eyeshadow Palette - Full size
$13.39 New
No used products available
Mary Kay Signature Eyesicles Island Bronze 032000 Discontinued
Rank 64
Mary Kay Signature Eyesicles Island Bronze 032000 Discontinued
(3)
$8.75 New
No used products available
Milani Shadow Eyez Eyeshadow Pencil in Green Safari 04
Rank 65
Milani Shadow Eyez Eyeshadow Pencil in Green Safari 04
(7)
$18.00 New
No used products available
Almay Eye Shadow Softies Singles Petal 145
Rank 66
Almay Eye Shadow Softies Singles Petal 145
(3)
$7.00 New
No used products available
Mac Glitch in the Matrix Frost Eye Shadow .05 oz
Rank 67
Mac Glitch in the Matrix Frost Eye Shadow .05 oz
$19.88 New
No used products available
Dominique Cosmetics Unconditional Eyeshadow Palette - 6 Shades -
Rank 68
Dominique Cosmetics Unconditional Eyeshadow Palette - 6 Shades -
(1)
$13.88 New
No used products available
tarte sugar rush eye smoothie cream shadow rosy copper
Rank 69
tarte sugar rush eye smoothie cream shadow rosy copper
$13.99 New
No used products available
Bareminerals Barepro Longwear Eyeshadow Stick ICY GRAY
Rank 70
Bareminerals Barepro Longwear Eyeshadow Stick ICY GRAY
$18.50 New
No used products available
Mirabella Eyeshadow Collection 7 Colours Palette - Chroma 7.7g10ml
Rank 71
Mirabella Eyeshadow Collection 7 Colours Palette - Chroma 7.7g10ml
No new products available
No used products available
ILIA Liquid Powder Chromatic Eye Tint 0.12 fl oz - SHEEN -
Rank 72
ILIA Liquid Powder Chromatic Eye Tint 0.12 fl oz - SHEEN -
$22.89 New
No used products available
Drew FLOWER Watercolor Eye Tint Twilight Wash 0.16 Oz 4.65 Ml
Rank 73
Drew FLOWER Watercolor Eye Tint Twilight Wash 0.16 Oz 4.65 Ml
$7.49 New
No used products available
Covergirl Clean Color Eyeshadow Quad Cool Berry # 232 Vegan
Rank 74
Covergirl Clean Color Eyeshadow Quad Cool Berry # 232 Vegan
$6.88 New
No used products available
Vamp Stamp VIGNETTE III Metallic Glitter Paint Conquer The Cut Crease Kit
Rank 75
Vamp Stamp VIGNETTE III Metallic Glitter Paint Conquer The Cut Crease Kit
No new products available
No used products available