Skip to main content

Best selling products: Best Elephant 2 Years and Up Plush Baby Toys

BestsellingTop Rated
Cocomelon Musical Bedtime JJ Doll with Plush Tummy and Roto Head
Rank 1
Cocomelon Musical Bedtime JJ Doll with Plush Tummy and Roto Head
(347)
$16.99 New
$10.99 Used
Talking Hamster Repeats What You Say Plush Animal Toy Electronic Mouse for Boys
Rank 2
Talking Hamster Repeats What You Say Plush Animal Toy Electronic Mouse for Boys
(11)
$8.80 New
No used products available
WowWee Pinkfong Baby Shark Bath Squirt Toy - 61078 (4 Pack)
Rank 3
WowWee Pinkfong Baby Shark Bath Squirt Toy - 61078 (4 Pack)
(9)
$19.99 New
No used products available
Carters Just One You Plush Corduroy LION Security Lovey Toy Target #68536
Rank 4
Carters Just One You Plush Corduroy LION Security Lovey Toy Target #68536
$15.29 New
No used products available
Target Gray Elephant Fluffy Cloud Island Stuffed Plush Baby Toy 12 Inch 2017
Rank 5
Target Gray Elephant Fluffy Cloud Island Stuffed Plush Baby Toy 12 Inch 2017
(1)
$24.95 New
$9.00 Used
Baby VERA Plush PLUMPIE Stuffed FLORAL Doll - by Douglas Cuddle Toys - #6528
Rank 6
Baby VERA Plush PLUMPIE Stuffed FLORAL Doll - by Douglas Cuddle Toys - #6528
(2)
$23.45 New
$16.99 Used
Infantino Big Softy Sea Whale Chime Teether Clip On Plush Crinkle Baby Toy
Rank 7
Infantino Big Softy Sea Whale Chime Teether Clip On Plush Crinkle Baby Toy
No new products available
No used products available
Spark Create Imagine Teddy Bear Brown Fur Cream Quilted 14in Rattle Plush
Rank 8
Spark Create Imagine Teddy Bear Brown Fur Cream Quilted 14in Rattle Plush
(1)
$10.29 New
No used products available
Douglas Baby Farrah Fawn Lil Snugglers Lovey Security Blanket Pink White Deer
Rank 9
Douglas Baby Farrah Fawn Lil Snugglers Lovey Security Blanket Pink White Deer
$18.95 New
No used products available
81bc709 SwaddleMe Mommie's Melodies Soother Lamb
Rank 10
81bc709 SwaddleMe Mommie's Melodies Soother Lamb
(6)
$19.99 New
$11.99 Used
Mary Meyer Putty Duckling Soft Toy Plush Stuffed Animal White 8"
Rank 11
Mary Meyer Putty Duckling Soft Toy Plush Stuffed Animal White 8"
$16.95 New
$7.00 Used
Infantino Dr Seuss The Grinch 10" Plush Stuffed Animal Christmas Ages 0
Rank 12
Infantino Dr Seuss The Grinch 10" Plush Stuffed Animal Christmas Ages 0
$8.75 New
No used products available
Carters Plush White DUCK GOOSE Security Lovey Baby Toy Stuffed Animal 68327
Rank 13
Carters Plush White DUCK GOOSE Security Lovey Baby Toy Stuffed Animal 68327
$29.92 New
No used products available
Kellytoy Original 10" Safari Baby Lion Plush Stuffed Animal 2016
Rank 14
Kellytoy Original 10" Safari Baby Lion Plush Stuffed Animal 2016
(1)
$39.99 New
No used products available
BABY HUG Plush PUP Stuffed Doll with Dog Swaddle - by Douglas Cuddle Toys #6057
Rank 15
BABY HUG Plush PUP Stuffed Doll with Dog Swaddle - by Douglas Cuddle Toys #6057
$28.95 New
No used products available
Bunnies by The Bay Puppy Dog Lovey Skipit Knotted Plush Security Blanket
Rank 16
Bunnies by The Bay Puppy Dog Lovey Skipit Knotted Plush Security Blanket
$29.92 New
$16.00 Used
Bedtime Originals 230043E Choo Choo Humphrey Plush Elephant - Gray
Rank 17
Bedtime Originals 230043E Choo Choo Humphrey Plush Elephant - Gray
(25)
$11.99 New
$9.99 Used
Nickelodeon WowWee Pinkfong Baby Shark Song Cube Plush
Rank 18
Nickelodeon WowWee Pinkfong Baby Shark Song Cube Plush
(1)
$5.00 New
No used products available
Doudou et Compagnie Dinosaur Soft Plush Security Blanket Dino Teal Stuffed Toy
Rank 19
Doudou et Compagnie Dinosaur Soft Plush Security Blanket Dino Teal Stuffed Toy
$23.95 New
No used products available
Carter's Just One You Dinosaur Triceratops Dino Blue Green Plush Toy 68340
Rank 20
Carter's Just One You Dinosaur Triceratops Dino Blue Green Plush Toy 68340
$23.39 New
$12.86 Used
Carters Plush Gray Elephant White Ribbed Corduroy Ears 9.5" Lovey Baby Toy
Rank 21
Carters Plush Gray Elephant White Ribbed Corduroy Ears 9.5" Lovey Baby Toy
$22.95 New
No used products available
DISNEY BABY THE NIGHTMARE BEFORE CHRISTMAS SOFT BOOK MY FIRST SCARE Ages 0
Rank 22
DISNEY BABY THE NIGHTMARE BEFORE CHRISTMAS SOFT BOOK MY FIRST SCARE Ages 0
$8.49 New
No used products available
Kellytoy K Luxe Baby My 1st Baseball First Sports Ball Rattle White
Rank 23
Kellytoy K Luxe Baby My 1st Baseball First Sports Ball Rattle White
$13.00 New
$8.00 Used
CoComelon CMW0016 Musical Bedtime JJ 10 in Doll with Teddy Soft - Blue
Rank 24
CoComelon CMW0016 Musical Bedtime JJ 10 in Doll with Teddy Soft - Blue
(5)
$17.71 New
$5.00 Used
Tiktok Dancing Cactus Repeat Talking Plush Toy Singing Musical Toy for Babies
Rank 25
Tiktok Dancing Cactus Repeat Talking Plush Toy Singing Musical Toy for Babies
(1)
$14.00 New
No used products available
CoCoMelon JJ 8" stuffed animal/plush-8” JJ Koala Jazwares
Rank 26
CoCoMelon JJ 8" stuffed animal/plush-8” JJ Koala Jazwares
(1)
$8.00 New
$4.99 Used
CARTER'S JUST ONE YOU PINK CORDUROY FOX LOVEY PLUSH STUFFED CIRCA 2023
Rank 27
CARTER'S JUST ONE YOU PINK CORDUROY FOX LOVEY PLUSH STUFFED CIRCA 2023
$26.50 New
$8.00 Used
G5 Kelly Baby Toy My First Bear Gray Plush Satin Accents Rattle 10”
Rank 28
G5 Kelly Baby Toy My First Bear Gray Plush Satin Accents Rattle 10”
(2)
$27.99 New
$16.22 Used
FNAF 4th Of July Firework Freddys Plush Five nights at Fred - Multicolor (71336)
Rank 29
FNAF 4th Of July Firework Freddys Plush Five nights at Fred - Multicolor (71336)
(2)
$10.87 New
No used products available
Fisher Brilliant Basics Baby's 1st First Doll M9528 2013 Rattle
Rank 30
Fisher Brilliant Basics Baby's 1st First Doll M9528 2013 Rattle
(13)
$24.99 New
$19.99 Used
Scholastic Baby Plush Chick Doll Teether Security Toy Duck BPA P40
Rank 31
Scholastic Baby Plush Chick Doll Teether Security Toy Duck BPA P40
(3)
$19.89 New
$14.89 Used
Mary Meyer Putty Nursery 11 Inch Panda
Rank 32
Mary Meyer Putty Nursery 11 Inch Panda
$17.99 New
$9.99 Used
Douglas Cuddle Toys Baby Dragon Sshlumpie #1490 Stuffed Animal Toy
Rank 33
Douglas Cuddle Toys Baby Dragon Sshlumpie #1490 Stuffed Animal Toy
$25.45 New
$15.83 Used
WowWee Pinkfong Baby Shark Chuck's Song Cube Musical Plush SEE LISTING VIDEO
Rank 34
WowWee Pinkfong Baby Shark Chuck's Song Cube Musical Plush SEE LISTING VIDEO
$8.50 New
No used products available
1 Ct Kids Preferred Rudolph The Red Nosed Reindeer Musical Rattle Activity Toy
Rank 35
1 Ct Kids Preferred Rudolph The Red Nosed Reindeer Musical Rattle Activity Toy
(2)
$18.04 New
$2.44 Used
Infantino Chime & Go Tag Along Pal Wee Wild Ones For OM Baby Car Toy 201058
Rank 36
Infantino Chime & Go Tag Along Pal Wee Wild Ones For OM Baby Car Toy 201058
$12.79 New
No used products available
Target Baby Bullseye Puppy Dog WubbaNub Lovey Target 10" Soft Toy
Rank 37
Target Baby Bullseye Puppy Dog WubbaNub Lovey Target 10" Soft Toy
$10.39 New
$5.00 Used
WowWee Pinkfong Baby Shark Singing Plush Official Song Cube Toy - Mommy Pink
Rank 38
WowWee Pinkfong Baby Shark Singing Plush Official Song Cube Toy - Mommy Pink
(2)
$11.95 New
$10.00 Used
Playtex Multicolor Baby Dinosaur 🦖 Musical Toy - one size
Rank 39
Playtex Multicolor Baby Dinosaur 🦖 Musical Toy - one size
$10.99 New
No used products available
GUND UR Squared Large Stuffed Animal Toy Nursery Toddler
Rank 40
GUND UR Squared Large Stuffed Animal Toy Nursery Toddler
$4.99 New
No used products available
K Luxe Baby Kellytoy Pink Plush 12" Bunny Rabbit Rattle Crinkle Ears S9
Rank 41
K Luxe Baby Kellytoy Pink Plush 12" Bunny Rabbit Rattle Crinkle Ears S9
$14.50 New
$10.99 Used
in The Night Garden Cuddly Collectable Upsy Daisy Soft Toy 17cm 1639
Rank 42
in The Night Garden Cuddly Collectable Upsy Daisy Soft Toy 17cm 1639
$25.00 New
No used products available
Baby LIA LADYBUG Plush SSHLUMPIE Plush Stuffed Animal Douglas Cuddle Toys #1497
Rank 43
Baby LIA LADYBUG Plush SSHLUMPIE Plush Stuffed Animal Douglas Cuddle Toys #1497
$25.45 New
$14.95 Used
GUND Baby Lamb Winky Plush Stuffed White Soft Animal Ewe Sheep 058133 Rattle
Rank 44
GUND Baby Lamb Winky Plush Stuffed White Soft Animal Ewe Sheep 058133 Rattle
$7.08 New
No used products available
Fisher- Soothe and Glow Seahorse Pink kid toy
Rank 45
Fisher- Soothe and Glow Seahorse Pink kid toy
(14)
$9.99 New
No used products available
Rare Vintage Mattel Angel Bunny Li'l Safe Driver Car Seat Soft Baby Toy 1984
Rank 46
Rare Vintage Mattel Angel Bunny Li'l Safe Driver Car Seat Soft Baby Toy 1984
$44.99 New
No used products available
Kellytoy Kelly Baby Elephant Safari Plush Rattle Stuffed Sitting Toy Gray
Rank 47
Kellytoy Kelly Baby Elephant Safari Plush Rattle Stuffed Sitting Toy Gray
(1)
$14.99 New
$9.86 Used
Douglas Hugs Baby Wolf Hug 10 Inch Plush Figure IN STOCK
Rank 48
Douglas Hugs Baby Wolf Hug 10 Inch Plush Figure IN STOCK
$28.95 New
No used products available
Kelly Baby Kellytoy 20" Plush Unicorn Toy Stuffed Animal Ivory Rattle Pink Girls
Rank 49
Kelly Baby Kellytoy 20" Plush Unicorn Toy Stuffed Animal Ivory Rattle Pink Girls
$36.88 New
$24.99 Used
Kelly Baby Unicorn 10" Plush Rattle Clip on Stuffed Animal Toy Kellybaby
Rank 50
Kelly Baby Unicorn 10" Plush Rattle Clip on Stuffed Animal Toy Kellybaby
$15.99 New
$14.99 Used
Carters Panda Bear Lovey Security Blanket Plush Brown/Blue Baby Boy Shower Gift
Rank 51
Carters Panda Bear Lovey Security Blanket Plush Brown/Blue Baby Boy Shower Gift
$29.92 New
$4.99 Used
Carters Child of Mine Pink White Kitty Cat Musical Plush Standing 2021
Rank 52
Carters Child of Mine Pink White Kitty Cat Musical Plush Standing 2021
$15.29 New
$13.00 Used
Baby Infant Toy Gund Tuck-Away Lovey Emory FOX Renard Lil Luvs PLUSH 6064123
Rank 53
Baby Infant Toy Gund Tuck-Away Lovey Emory FOX Renard Lil Luvs PLUSH 6064123
$14.15 New
No used products available
Snuggle N' Hug Arctic Friends Plush in Bunny Talking Shivering Light up
Rank 54
Snuggle N' Hug Arctic Friends Plush in Bunny Talking Shivering Light up
(1)
$22.40 New
No used products available
KINREX Elephant Plush Measures 9 Inches Grey Stuffed Animal Baby Toy Other Toys
Rank 55
KINREX Elephant Plush Measures 9 Inches Grey Stuffed Animal Baby Toy Other Toys
(2)
No new products available
No used products available
Carters 9” Musical Unicorn Baby Plush Lovey Wind Up Stuffed Animal Toy 67456
Rank 56
Carters 9” Musical Unicorn Baby Plush Lovey Wind Up Stuffed Animal Toy 67456
$29.88 New
No used products available
Disney Baby Lovey Miss Piggy Security Blanket Rattle Embroidered Satin Trim
Rank 57
Disney Baby Lovey Miss Piggy Security Blanket Rattle Embroidered Satin Trim
$7.14 New
No used products available
Mud Pie E0 Baby Boutique Girl 16in Linen Ballet Tutu Unicorn Doll Toy 2112350
Rank 58
Mud Pie E0 Baby Boutique Girl 16in Linen Ballet Tutu Unicorn Doll Toy 2112350
No new products available
No used products available
Vera Bradley Lovey Bunny Lilli Bell 2012 Crib Toy Mini Security Blanket
Rank 59
Vera Bradley Lovey Bunny Lilli Bell 2012 Crib Toy Mini Security Blanket
(5)
No new products available
No used products available
DouDou et Compagnie Paris Cat Kitten Kitty Petals Plush Lovey Blanket Pink
Rank 60
DouDou et Compagnie Paris Cat Kitten Kitty Petals Plush Lovey Blanket Pink
No new products available
No used products available
Steiff 064982 Soft Cuddly Friends Ella Elephant Grey
Rank 61
Steiff 064982 Soft Cuddly Friends Ella Elephant Grey
$19.81 New
No used products available
Officially Licensed Disney Goofy Plush Toy Stuffed Doll 11"
Rank 62
Officially Licensed Disney Goofy Plush Toy Stuffed Doll 11"
$10.99 New
$10.32 Used
Animal Adventure Brown Monkey Plush Knit Rattle Soft Stuffed Baby Toy
Rank 63
Animal Adventure Brown Monkey Plush Knit Rattle Soft Stuffed Baby Toy
No new products available
No used products available
HABA USA 2618 Snug-up Doll Lui
Rank 64
HABA USA 2618 Snug-up Doll Lui
(3)
$17.99 New
$5.99 Used
Carter's Just One You Pink White 10” Fox Plush Stuffed Animal Baby Lovey #68023
Rank 65
Carter's Just One You Pink White 10” Fox Plush Stuffed Animal Baby Lovey #68023
$64.95 New
No used products available
Nanco Weasel Cute Blue & Pink Soft Cotton Candy Color Fur Plush Over 30 In
Rank 66
Nanco Weasel Cute Blue & Pink Soft Cotton Candy Color Fur Plush Over 30 In
$14.98 New
No used products available
11" Kelly Baby Unicorn Lovey & Rattle Clip on Pink Tan Corduroy Kellytoy B73
Rank 67
11" Kelly Baby Unicorn Lovey & Rattle Clip on Pink Tan Corduroy Kellytoy B73
(2)
$14.99 New
$4.99 Used
Rinco 10'' Cute Yellow Giraffe Plush Bubble Pet Jungle Stuff Animal Toy
Rank 68
Rinco 10'' Cute Yellow Giraffe Plush Bubble Pet Jungle Stuff Animal Toy
(1)
No new products available
No used products available
Spark Create Imagine Fur Pals Elephant Dog and Fox Ages 0
Rank 69
Spark Create Imagine Fur Pals Elephant Dog and Fox Ages 0
$12.18 New
$7.00 Used
Carters Lion Plush Security Lovey Baby Toy Safari Unisex #68258
Rank 70
Carters Lion Plush Security Lovey Baby Toy Safari Unisex #68258
$39.92 New
No used products available
Baby Nova Owl 9" Plush with Chime by Douglas Baby Cuddle Toys #6570
Rank 71
Baby Nova Owl 9" Plush with Chime by Douglas Baby Cuddle Toys #6570
No new products available
No used products available
Baby Starters Annette Doll Pink Rosette Skirt 11"
Rank 72
Baby Starters Annette Doll Pink Rosette Skirt 11"
No new products available
No used products available
Bunnies by The Bay Wee Plush Rutabaga 604111
Rank 73
Bunnies by The Bay Wee Plush Rutabaga 604111
(2)
$14.95 New
No used products available
Carters Dinosaur Plush Blue White Yellow Stuffed Baby Dino Lovey Toy 68172
Rank 74
Carters Dinosaur Plush Blue White Yellow Stuffed Baby Dino Lovey Toy 68172
$24.95 New
No used products available
Kellytoy Tan White Puppy Dog Plush Rattle Teether Lovey Stuffed Animal Baby Toy
Rank 75
Kellytoy Tan White Puppy Dog Plush Rattle Teether Lovey Stuffed Animal Baby Toy
$19.88 New
$14.50 Used
Kelly Baby 12" Cuddle Plush Rattle Crinkle Lovey Pram Toy Green Dinosaur
Rank 76
Kelly Baby 12" Cuddle Plush Rattle Crinkle Lovey Pram Toy Green Dinosaur
$11.69 New
$8.00 Used
Ingenuity Nate Teddy Bear Premium Soft Plush Soothing Bean Bag Lovey Security
Rank 77
Ingenuity Nate Teddy Bear Premium Soft Plush Soothing Bean Bag Lovey Security
$14.44 New
$7.00 Used
Carters White Cat Turn Key Motion Musical Baby Nursery Rhyme Wind Up Plush Kitty
Rank 78
Carters White Cat Turn Key Motion Musical Baby Nursery Rhyme Wind Up Plush Kitty
$19.99 New
$16.99 Used
Baby GEORGIE GIRAFFE Plush SNUGGLER Stuffed Toy - by Douglas Cuddle Toys - #1373
Rank 79
Baby GEORGIE GIRAFFE Plush SNUGGLER Stuffed Toy - by Douglas Cuddle Toys - #1373
$18.95 New
No used products available
Kellytoy Kellybaby Green Dinosaur Plush Stuffed Dino Baby Lovey With Rattle
Rank 80
Kellytoy Kellybaby Green Dinosaur Plush Stuffed Dino Baby Lovey With Rattle
$19.92 New
$10.50 Used
Carters Plush KNIT PUPPY Dog Security Blanket Yellow Tan Stripes Lovey
Rank 81
Carters Plush KNIT PUPPY Dog Security Blanket Yellow Tan Stripes Lovey
$17.99 New
No used products available
Carters Plush GRAY ELEPHANT Toy Security Lovey #68091 Grey Boy Girl
Rank 82
Carters Plush GRAY ELEPHANT Toy Security Lovey #68091 Grey Boy Girl
$19.92 New
No used products available
Kellytoy Baby Pig Plush Pink Rattle Crinkle Ears Stuffed Toy Animal 12" Sensory
Rank 83
Kellytoy Baby Pig Plush Pink Rattle Crinkle Ears Stuffed Toy Animal 12" Sensory
$19.99 New
$12.95 Used
Infantino Go gaga wrist foot rattles owl very cute
Rank 84
Infantino Go gaga wrist foot rattles owl very cute
$6.99 New
$5.21 Used
Plush Mary Had a Little Lamb Puppet Fabric Story Time Nat & Jules 5004700458
Rank 85
Plush Mary Had a Little Lamb Puppet Fabric Story Time Nat & Jules 5004700458
(1)
$16.14 New
$7.00 Used
Kelly Baby Plush Elephant W/ Rattle Clip on Pink Crinkle Shower Girls L30 MP
Rank 86
Kelly Baby Plush Elephant W/ Rattle Clip on Pink Crinkle Shower Girls L30 MP
(1)
$9.99 New
$9.49 Used