Skip to main content

Best selling products: Best 3-4 Years Garfield Retired Original Beanie Babies

BestsellingTop Rated
Ty Beanie Babies Princess Bear Toy
Rank 1
Ty Beanie Babies Princess Bear Toy
(64)
$5.02 New
$3.00 Used
Ty Beanie Baby The End 1999 Y2k Millennium Teddy Bear SG_B00002CFB8_US
Rank 2
Ty Beanie Baby The End 1999 Y2k Millennium Teddy Bear SG_B00002CFB8_US
(16)
$3.00 New
No used products available
Ty Batty Brown the Bat Plush Toy
Rank 3
Ty Batty Brown the Bat Plush Toy
(54)
$9.99 New
$5.00 Used
Ty Scorch the Dragon Plush Toy
Rank 4
Ty Scorch the Dragon Plush Toy
(17)
$8.99 New
$2.49 Used
Ty Beanie Baby: Peace Bear 1996 - Multicolor
Rank 5
Ty Beanie Baby: Peace Bear 1996 - Multicolor
(67)
$7.05 New
$2.00 Used
Haunt 2001 Ty Beanie Babie 8in Black Halloween Bear 3up Boys Girls 4377
Rank 6
Haunt 2001 Ty Beanie Babie 8in Black Halloween Bear 3up Boys Girls 4377
(4)
$7.99 New
No used products available
Ty Beanie Baby Erin The Bear 1997 Retired Plush Toy
Rank 7
Ty Beanie Baby Erin The Bear 1997 Retired Plush Toy
(32)
$6.17 New
$4.00 Used
Ty Beanie Babies Claude the Crab
Rank 8
Ty Beanie Babies Claude the Crab
(24)
$4.94 New
$1.50 Used
Ty Beanie Buddy Snort the Bull Plush Toy - 4002
Rank 9
Ty Beanie Buddy Snort the Bull Plush Toy - 4002
(23)
$8.08 New
$3.00 Used
Ty Beanie Praying Baby Hope - 4213
Rank 10
Ty Beanie Praying Baby Hope - 4213
(27)
$9.00 New
$5.24 Used
Ty Beanie Babies Pugsly Plush Toy - 4106
Rank 11
Ty Beanie Babies Pugsly Plush Toy - 4106
(21)
$7.60 New
$2.89 Used
Ty Beanie Babies - Swirly the Snail Plush Toy - (0008421042494)
Rank 12
Ty Beanie Babies - Swirly the Snail Plush Toy - (0008421042494)
(29)
$3.50 New
No used products available
Ty Retired Beanie Baby Pumkin Pumpkin Halloween 1998 MINT
Rank 13
Ty Retired Beanie Baby Pumkin Pumpkin Halloween 1998 MINT
(7)
$4.94 New
No used products available
Ty Beanie Babies Halo the Angel Bear Toy
Rank 14
Ty Beanie Babies Halo the Angel Bear Toy
(29)
$7.12 New
$5.70 Used
Ty Amber Orange Tabby Cat Striped Tiger Beanie Baby 1999 Retired 3
Rank 15
Ty Amber Orange Tabby Cat Striped Tiger Beanie Baby 1999 Retired 3
(15)
$10.99 New
$9.99 Used
Nanook Retired 1996 Ty Beanie Babie 8in Husky Dog 3up Boys Girls 4104
Rank 16
Nanook Retired 1996 Ty Beanie Babie 8in Husky Dog 3up Boys Girls 4104
(18)
$8.89 New
$1.29 Used
Beanie Baby Ty Plush Animal Roxie Doe Reindeer Lashes Antlers December 1 2000
Rank 17
Beanie Baby Ty Plush Animal Roxie Doe Reindeer Lashes Antlers December 1 2000
(15)
$7.68 New
$4.49 Used
TY Beanie Baby CHIP the Calico Cat
Rank 18
TY Beanie Baby CHIP the Calico Cat
(28)
$6.99 New
$2.89 Used
Ty Queen Elizabeth II Beanie Baby Bear - 008421412891
Rank 19
Ty Queen Elizabeth II Beanie Baby Bear - 008421412891
(13)
$7.41 New
No used products available
Ty Beanie Babies Weenie The Dachshund Dog Toy
Rank 20
Ty Beanie Babies Weenie The Dachshund Dog Toy
(26)
$8.99 New
$4.59 Used
Ty Beanie Babies Daisy The Cow Toy
Rank 21
Ty Beanie Babies Daisy The Cow Toy
(6)
$6.65 New
$2.89 Used
Ty Beanie Babies Doby the Doberman
Rank 22
Ty Beanie Babies Doby the Doberman
(9)
$6.17 New
$2.89 Used
TY Beanie Baby Inch the Inchworm Toy
Rank 23
TY Beanie Baby Inch the Inchworm Toy
(14)
$7.36 New
$2.89 Used
Ty Beanie Baby - FLEECIE the Lamb 6" MWMTs Plush Stuffed Animal Toy
Rank 24
Ty Beanie Baby - FLEECIE the Lamb 6" MWMTs Plush Stuffed Animal Toy
(3)
$9.89 New
$7.00 Used
Ty Beanie Baby Babies Seaweed The Otter With Tags Style - 4080
Rank 25
Ty Beanie Baby Babies Seaweed The Otter With Tags Style - 4080
(22)
$6.90 New
$4.00 Used
Hamlet RARE Retired 2003 Ty Beanie Babie 7in Pink Plush Pig Boys Girls 3up 40016
Rank 26
Hamlet RARE Retired 2003 Ty Beanie Babie 7in Pink Plush Pig Boys Girls 3up 40016
(6)
$10.89 New
$10.34 Used
Ty Beanie Babies Curly The Bear Plush Toy - 4052
Rank 27
Ty Beanie Babies Curly The Bear Plush Toy - 4052
(26)
$6.99 New
$1.12 Used
Swampy Ty Beanie Baby Alligator Birthdate January 24 2000
Rank 28
Swampy Ty Beanie Baby Alligator Birthdate January 24 2000
(4)
$3.95 New
$3.55 Used
Ty Beanie Baby Collection - Luke Black Dog DOB June 15 1998
Rank 29
Ty Beanie Baby Collection - Luke Black Dog DOB June 15 1998
(21)
$9.89 New
$8.88 Used
Ty Beanie Baby Germania Bear
Rank 30
Ty Beanie Baby Germania Bear
(7)
$8.55 New
$2.89 Used
Ty Beanie Baby Eleanor Alvin and the Chipmunks Plush Toy - 40830
Rank 31
Ty Beanie Baby Eleanor Alvin and the Chipmunks Plush Toy - 40830
(9)
$73.89 New
$66.49 Used
Ty Beanie Baby Bruno Chocolate Brown Bull Terrier Dog 9" 1997 Boys Girls 3
Rank 32
Ty Beanie Baby Bruno Chocolate Brown Bull Terrier Dog 9" 1997 Boys Girls 3
(7)
$6.58 New
$1.50 Used
Set of 4 Sherbet Ty Beanie Baby Teddy Bears 2002 Pink Yellow Green 03 Blue MWMT
Rank 33
Set of 4 Sherbet Ty Beanie Baby Teddy Bears 2002 Pink Yellow Green 03 Blue MWMT
(11)
$8.89 New
$5.87 Used
Ty Beanie Babies RESCUE the Dog 2001 Plush Stuffed Animal Toy With Tag
Rank 34
Ty Beanie Babies RESCUE the Dog 2001 Plush Stuffed Animal Toy With Tag
(5)
$7.50 New
$4.99 Used
Ty Beanie Babies Freckles the Spotted Leopard Plush Toy - 4066
Rank 35
Ty Beanie Babies Freckles the Spotted Leopard Plush Toy - 4066
(11)
$6.82 New
$2.20 Used
2000 TY Beanie Babies India The Orange Bengal Tiger
Rank 36
2000 TY Beanie Babies India The Orange Bengal Tiger
(11)
$11.89 New
$6.00 Used
Ty Bernie the St. Bernard Dog Baby Toy
Rank 37
Ty Bernie the St. Bernard Dog Baby Toy
(16)
$6.49 New
$1.29 Used
Prance 1997 Ty Beanie Babie Grey Stripe 8in Cat Kitten 3up Boys Girls 4123
Rank 38
Prance 1997 Ty Beanie Babie Grey Stripe 8in Cat Kitten 3up Boys Girls 4123
(28)
$9.88 New
No used products available
Ty Beanie Baby May 2002 Birthday Bear Green W/Party Hat 4556 (10”) W/Tag
Rank 39
Ty Beanie Baby May 2002 Birthday Bear Green W/Party Hat 4556 (10”) W/Tag
(7)
$12.00 New
$11.99 Used
Ty Righty 2000 Political Elephant Stars Stripes 6 Beanie Baby MWMT
Rank 40
Ty Righty 2000 Political Elephant Stars Stripes 6 Beanie Baby MWMT
(15)
$9.85 New
$1.69 Used
RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY NOVEMBER TOPAZ HAPPY BIRTHDAY TEDDY BEAR WITH HAT 8"
Rank 41
RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY NOVEMBER TOPAZ HAPPY BIRTHDAY TEDDY BEAR WITH HAT 8"
(7)
$9.89 New
$6.94 Used
Ty Beanie Baby Quivers Ghost Beanbag Plush 11th Gen Tag 2003 PE 40018
Rank 42
Ty Beanie Baby Quivers Ghost Beanbag Plush 11th Gen Tag 2003 PE 40018
(5)
$5.99 New
No used products available
Ty Beanie Babie Green and Yellow 8in smoochy Frog - 4039
Rank 43
Ty Beanie Babie Green and Yellow 8in smoochy Frog - 4039
(13)
$8.00 New
$2.99 Used
Ty Beanie Baby Collection 1997 6th Generation Iggy Seen With Hang Tag 5g
Rank 44
Ty Beanie Baby Collection 1997 6th Generation Iggy Seen With Hang Tag 5g
(16)
$6.39 New
No used products available
Ty Beanie Babie 7 inch Slippery the Seal Toy
Rank 45
Ty Beanie Babie 7 inch Slippery the Seal Toy
(2)
$5.99 New
No used products available
Seamore White Seal Pup 3rd Hang 2nd Tush Tag Generation Ty Beanie Baby 1993
Rank 46
Seamore White Seal Pup 3rd Hang 2nd Tush Tag Generation Ty Beanie Baby 1993
(3)
$9.89 New
$6.29 Used
Ty Beanie Babies Banjo The Puppy Dog 2004
Rank 47
Ty Beanie Babies Banjo The Puppy Dog 2004
(3)
$21.89 New
$20.00 Used
Ty Spot The Dog Wi/spot Beanie Baby Retired 1993 PVC Pellet 4th Gen
Rank 48
Ty Spot The Dog Wi/spot Beanie Baby Retired 1993 PVC Pellet 4th Gen
(13)
$8.79 New
$6.00 Used
Ty Signature Bear Beanie Babies - TY042289
Rank 49
Ty Signature Bear Beanie Babies - TY042289
(9)
$5.94 New
$5.00 Used
Ty Beanie Baby RARE Eggbert Chick in Egg With Gasport Hang Tag 1998 1999
Rank 50
Ty Beanie Baby RARE Eggbert Chick in Egg With Gasport Hang Tag 1998 1999
(9)
$6.58 New
$5.96 Used
TY Beanie Baby Lucky The Ladybug with Spots Plush Toy
Rank 51
TY Beanie Baby Lucky The Ladybug with Spots Plush Toy
(15)
$7.79 New
$6.99 Used
Ty Beanie Baby - BOOTIES The Black & White Cat March 26 2002
Rank 52
Ty Beanie Baby - BOOTIES The Black & White Cat March 26 2002
(7)
$14.99 New
$7.95 Used
☆ STING ☆ 1995 Ty Beanie Babies Blue Tie-Dye STINGRAY 4th/3rd Gen Tags *MWMT*
Rank 53
☆ STING ☆ 1995 Ty Beanie Babies Blue Tie-Dye STINGRAY 4th/3rd Gen Tags *MWMT*
(6)
$25.89 New
$20.00 Used
Ty Beanie Babies Puffer The Puffin Bird
Rank 54
Ty Beanie Babies Puffer The Puffin Bird
(3)
$3.00 New
$0.99 Used
TY Beanie Baby -2001 Courage the Sept 11th NYPD Dog 6" s
Rank 55
TY Beanie Baby -2001 Courage the Sept 11th NYPD Dog 6" s
(6)
$6.65 New
$4.99 Used
Sarge Ty Beanie Baby German Shepherd Puppy Dog MWMT Birthday February 14 2000
Rank 56
Sarge Ty Beanie Baby German Shepherd Puppy Dog MWMT Birthday February 14 2000
(5)
$8.25 New
$3.95 Used
Liberty Red Head 2008 Ty Beanie Babie Patriotic 8in Bear 3up Boys Girls 4531
Rank 57
Liberty Red Head 2008 Ty Beanie Babie Patriotic 8in Bear 3up Boys Girls 4531
(5)
$9.16 New
No used products available
Ty Hippity the Green Bunny Plush Toy
Rank 58
Ty Hippity the Green Bunny Plush Toy
(8)
$7.12 New
$3.89 Used
Romance 7in Ty Beanie Babie 2001 Valentines Day Bear 3 up Boys Girls 4396
Rank 59
Romance 7in Ty Beanie Babie 2001 Valentines Day Bear 3 up Boys Girls 4396
(4)
$3.57 New
No used products available
Durango RARE 2004 Ty Beanie Babie 7in Palomino Horse 3up Boys Girls 40087
Rank 60
Durango RARE 2004 Ty Beanie Babie 7in Palomino Horse 3up Boys Girls 40087
(1)
$9.89 New
$8.00 Used
Ty Beanie Baby Hobo The Dog With Tag Retired DOB October 11th 2004
Rank 61
Ty Beanie Baby Hobo The Dog With Tag Retired DOB October 11th 2004
(6)
$9.99 New
$6.00 Used
Ty Spongebob PinkPants 2006 Beanie Baby Never or Played With Sponge Bob
Rank 62
Ty Spongebob PinkPants 2006 Beanie Baby Never or Played With Sponge Bob
(1)
$34.99 New
$34.99 Used
TY Beanie Babie Flitter the Butterfly Plush Toy - Pink/Purple
Rank 63
TY Beanie Babie Flitter the Butterfly Plush Toy - Pink/Purple
(12)
$8.08 New
$1.97 Used
Vines 2010 Ty Beanie Babie 8in Brown Plush Monkey Chimp 3up Boys Girls 42017
Rank 64
Vines 2010 Ty Beanie Babie 8in Brown Plush Monkey Chimp 3up Boys Girls 42017
$23.89 New
$19.95 Used
Ty Beanie Baby Collection Spongebob Tuxedo Pants MINT 2004
Rank 65
Ty Beanie Baby Collection Spongebob Tuxedo Pants MINT 2004
(1)
$24.95 New
$12.50 Used
TY Beanie Babies - Ariel the Bear Plush Toy
Rank 66
TY Beanie Babies - Ariel the Bear Plush Toy
(6)
$6.99 New
$5.96 Used
Ty Beanie Babies Baby Manny Mammoth Ice Age Dinosaur Plush 2009 #40773
Rank 67
Ty Beanie Babies Baby Manny Mammoth Ice Age Dinosaur Plush 2009 #40773
(3)
$36.99 New
$19.99 Used
Vtg TY Beanie Baby Plush Bananas Orangutan Monkey Stuffed Animal Toy 8.5" 2000
Rank 68
Vtg TY Beanie Baby Plush Bananas Orangutan Monkey Stuffed Animal Toy 8.5" 2000
(13)
$7.52 New
$6.00 Used
Pinkerton Saffron Violetta Ty Beanie Babies 2006 Colorful Cat Set of 3 MWMT
Rank 69
Pinkerton Saffron Violetta Ty Beanie Babies 2006 Colorful Cat Set of 3 MWMT
(1)
$14.99 New
No used products available
Ty Beanie Boos Cuddly Polar Bear White Stuffed Animal Soft Plush Toy for Kids
Rank 70
Ty Beanie Boos Cuddly Polar Bear White Stuffed Animal Soft Plush Toy for Kids
(4)
$4.95 New
No used products available
Ty Mini Boos Series Collectibles - Pack of 5
Rank 71
Ty Mini Boos Series Collectibles - Pack of 5
$9.89 New
$3.00 Used
TY Beanie Baby "Kookie" Blue Dog
Rank 72
TY Beanie Baby "Kookie" Blue Dog
(3)
$9.89 New
$5.99 Used
Ty Beanie Baby Candy Canes 2006 15th Generation Hang Tag
Rank 73
Ty Beanie Baby Candy Canes 2006 15th Generation Hang Tag
$15.89 New
$11.99 Used