Skip to main content
Play Like a Girl/X Marks The Spot

Play Like a Girl/X Marks The Spot

838 items sold
194 followers
Contact

Featured categories

Newly Listed

See all

  • Vintage 1984 Care Bears 13" Stuffed Plush Bright Heart Raccoon Cousin Kenner

    $24.99

  • Vintage 1983 Kenner 6" LOVE-A-LOT CARE BEAR Plush American Greetings Heart Pink

    $19.99

  • BEDTIME BEAR Vintage Kenner Care Bears Mini Plush 6” 1983 Sleepy Moon And Star

    $19.99

  • Care Bears Wish Bear Blue Stuffed Plush Bear Kenner 1983 Vintage 13 Inch 80s Toy

    $24.99

  • Vintage Care Bears Lotsa Heart Elephant 1984 Kenner Care Bear Cousins Plush 13"

    $24.99

  • NEW Vintage Trendmasters Kaleidoscope Starcastle Garden Locket NIB Star Castle

    $64.99

New Items!

Jem Dolls Added!

Shop now
New Items!

All items

NEW Strawberry Shortcake Doll Blueberry Muffin 1980 VTG Kenner in Opened Box

$99.99

Monster High Doll Draculaura Snow Bite Scarily Ever After in Box Mattel NIB NRFB

$209.99

Vintage 1980 Strawberry Shortcake Apple Dumplin Doll Tea Time Turtle New in Box

$69.99

1980 Kenner Strawberry Shortcake Purple Pieman Doll Berry Bird Pie Man New w Box

$94.99

Vtg Purrtenders Purr Tenders Romp Purr Dog Mask Original Box 1989 Fisher Price

$84.99

1996 Vintage Trendmasters Starcastle Bubble Coach Swan Set NEW Star Castle

$44.99

Mattel Magic Nursery Pets Orange Plush NEW NRFB Clothes 11 Inch 1990 Stuffed Toy

$199.99

Party Popples Pink and Purple Plush Stuffed Toy Vintage Popples 1985 Clean Soft

$49.99

Vintage My Buddy Doll 1980's Hasbro Original Red Overalls Replacement No Doll

$14.99

Vintage Moon Dreamers Sparky Hasbro 1986 with Glasses Stand & Comb

$89.99

Vintage 80s Popples Cartoon Kid Sleeping Bag 1986 American Greetings Blue Zip Up

$49.99

Vtg 1993 Kenner Fairy Winkles Flower Pot With 3 Fairies Peek N Petals Posy

$24.99

Vintage 1986 Prize Popples Pink, Blue & White Stuffed Animal Plush Doll Mattel

$54.99

Vtg 1989 Polly Pocket Bridesmaid Wedding Day Chapel Yellow Round Compact Only

$19.99

Vintage Polly Pocket Beach House Yellow Bridge 1989 Bluebird Compact No Dolls

$19.99

Vintage 80’s My Little Pony Blossom Purple Hasbro Softies Toy Plush 9” w/ Tag

$39.99

Vintage Fisher Price Little People Play Family Nursery School Complete W/Box 929

$149.99

Jem and the Holograms Hasbro Rio Doll Original Clothing Vintage 1986 Collectible

$34.99

Vintage 1986 Kenner Sea Wees Shimmers Butterfly Dolls Skylite & Baby Glider Comb

$34.99

Vintage 1986 Hasbro Moon Dreamers - Bitsy Doll and Roary Lion with Doll Stand

$79.99

Vintage 1979 Kenner Strawberry Shortcake Doll Apricot Original Outfit Hat Socks

$24.99

Vintage 1984 Galoob Golden Girls Ogra Action Figure with Complete Accessories

$129.99

Vintage 1985 Care Bears Sticker Trading Card 93 -102 Panini Set 10 Stickers

$11.99

Rare HTF NIB 1984 Walt Disney Wuzzles Butterbear Hasbro Softies Plush & Book

$179.99

Vintage 1995 Trendmasters Starcastle Pink Jewelry Castle Set w/ Accessories

$24.99

1986 My Little Pony - Sugarberry Vintage MLP Hasbro Twice as Fancy Sealed NEW G1

$299.99

Vintage 1993 Princess of the Flowers Baby Puppies NEW in Package YES! Purple

$29.99

Vintage Strawberry Shortcake Butterfly Flitter-Bit Wings Toy 1981 No Seats

$14.99

Fisher-Price Loving Family Fun at the Beach Set Dollhouse 1997 Sandcastle Vtg

$64.99

Vintage Rainbow Brite Pillows Star Table Color Cottage Furniture Accessories

$24.99

Vintage 1970s Topper Dawn Doll Original Angie In Red Mini Dancing Dress #1032

$29.99

KINGSLEY + Original Comb Ribbon Pony Lion Friend Vintage G1 My Little Pony 1987

$29.99

Monster High Doll Lagoona Blue Dot Dead Gorgeous in Box Mattel 2011 NIB NRFB

$84.99

Vtg 1986 Mattel Popples Puffball White Blue Pink Stuffed Animal Plush Puff Ball

$59.99

Vintage 1985 Care Bears Sticker Trading Card #3, #4, #5 Panini Puzzle Style

$4.99

Melanie’s Mall The Sticker Stop Shop Doll Playset 1996 Vintage w/ Accessories

$19.99

Care Bears Cousin Playful Heart Monkey 8” Plush Beanie 20th Anniversary 2002

$24.99

American Girl Bitty Baby Food and Accessories Bitty O's Bib Plate Cup Spoon Lot

$29.99

Vintage 1989 Polly Pocket Country Cottage Bluebird Complete with Cat and Dog

$69.99

NEW Vintage Trendmasters Kaleidoscope Starcastle Garden Locket NIB Star Castle

$64.99

Vintage Birthday Bear 1983 Care Bears Kenner 6" Plush Yellow Cake Stuffed Animal

$24.99

Vtg Mickey Mouse Donald Duck Stainless Steel Kid Fork Spoon Walt Disney by Bonny

$29.99

Care Bears Wish Bear Blue Stuffed Plush Bear Kenner 1983 Vintage 13 Inch 80s Toy

$24.99

Vintage 1997 HEATHCLIFF Cartoon Comics NANCO Plush Stuffed Animal Orange Cat

$29.99

Vintage Polly Pocket Starbright Dinner Party NIB Light-Up Bluebird Playset 1994

$299.99

Vintage 1993 Princess of the Flowers Baby Kittens NEW in Package YES! Purple

$29.99

Vintage Moon Dreamers Whimzee Doll 1986 Hasbro with Stand Comb Hair Clip Glows

$74.99

American Girls Collection Samantha's Pastimes Cook Craft Book Paper Doll Theater

$34.99
Items Per Page
See All

About us

Welcome to Play Like A Girl Retro Toys ebay store! Formerly named X Marks the Spot, we sell all kinds of vintage and retro toys/items! While we do focus mostly on girl toys, our Ebay store does offer a combination of nostalgic items for both guys and girls!

We have a retro girl toy store in Gettysburg, PA so if you are in the area stop on by:
777 Baltimore St, Suite 104 - Gettysburg, PA 17325.
Location: United StatesMember since: Oct 29, 2017Seller: playlikeagirlretrotoys
Top Rated SellerPlay Like a Girl/X Marks The Spot is one of eBay's most reputable sellers. Consistently delivers outstanding customer service Learn more

Feedback ratings

Last 12 months

Positive119- positive feedback in last 12 months
Neutral0- neutral feedback in last 12 months
Negative0- negative feedback in last 12 months

Detailed seller ratings

Average for the last 12 months

Accurate description
5.0
Reasonable shipping cost
4.9
Shipping speed
5.0
Communication
5.0

Seller feedback (367)

1***o (60)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
A+++ experience! Insanely fast shipping, packaged so adorably with pink ribbons, I loved that detail and will use those ribbons in my hair. Items as described, will definitely do business with again. Thank you!!
e***2 (110)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Wonderful experience! Everything came on time and exactly as described. Would highly recommend this seller. Communicated well with me through the whole process. 10/10 experience!
1***o (60)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
A+ experience, very fast shipping, adorable packaging. Item as described, would do business with again. This was one of my favorite childhood toys, and I’m so happy to have it again so my daughter can play with it! Thank you.
b***g (70)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Amazing customer service! All pieces shown were in the set. Packed with care and super fast shipping. Thank you!
b***g (70)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Very happy with this seller! Received all items shown in awesome condition. Packed well and shipped so fast! Thank you!
f***7 (271)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past month
Verified purchase
Item as described, package securely, very happy with the quality. Thank you.
See all feedback