Skip to main content
vintagemagicthegathering

vintagemagicthegathering

13K items sold
2.7K followers
Contact

All items

Signed MTG Magic Alpha/Beta/Unlimited Time Walk Print Giclee, POWER 9 Artwork

$225.00

PAINTED, FOIL Emrakul, the Aeons Torn Artist Proof Modern Masters 2015 MTG/Magic

$3,000.00

LIMITED EDITION Signed MTG/Magic Mercadian Masques Rishadan Port Print/Giclee

$225.00

MINT BGS 9 Blue Hurricane ~ Summer Magic/MTG ~ .5 From 9.5 ~ NONE GRADED HIGHER

$22,500.00

CGC 8.5 Beta Artist Proof Rod of Ruin ~ Vintage MTG/Magic ~ 1/50 Worldwide

$500.00

ONE OF ONE ***1/1*** GEM MINT BGS 9.5 Summer Magic/MTG Bayou

$41,500.00

1/1 Eric Klug Alter on Unlimited Black Lotus ~ ICONIC Vintage MTG/Magic History

$88,888.88

1/1 PSA AUTO 10 Beta Time Walk MTG Artist Proof w/Painted Art by Amy Weber

$88,888.88

GEM MINT BGS 9.5 Summer Magic/MTG Underground Sea, ULTRA RARE!!!

$27,500.00

MINT BGS 9 Summer Magic/MTG Serendib Efreet, W/2x 9.5 SUBGRADES ~ ULTRA RARE!!

$17,750.00

CGC 8.5 Beta Artist Proof Forest {EYES} ~ Vintage MTG/Magic ~ RARER than ALPHA!!

$500.00

QUAD ~ GEM MINT BGS 9.5 Summer Magic/MTG Birds Of Paradise ~ ULTRA RARE!!!

$21,000.00

MINT BGS 9 Summer Magic/MTG Regrowth ~ ULTRA RARE!!!

$5,000.00

1/1 PSA AUTO 10 Beta Timetwister MTG Artist Proof w/Painted Art by Mark Tedin

$88,888.88

***1 Of 3*** GEM MINT BGS 9.5 Summer Magic/MTG Counterspell ~ ULTRA RARE!!!

$7,500.00

QUAD ~ GEM MINT BGS 9.5 Summer Magic/MTG Mana Vault ~ ULTRA RARE!!!

$12,500.00

GEM MINT BGS 9.5 Summer Magic/MTG Swords To Plowshares ~ ULTRA RARE!!!

$3,000.00

MINT BGS 9 Summer Magic/MTG Volcanic Island, W/2x 9.5 SUBGRADES!!!

$16,000.00

PAINTED & Signed Magic {M30} Retro Frame Volcanic Island Artist Proof by Snoddy

$5,000.00

GEM MINT BGS 9.5 Summer Magic/MTG Demonic Tutor ~ ULTRA RARE!!!

$5,000.00

"CRIMPED" Beta Birds of Paradise ~ Vintage MTG/Magic ~ ULTRA RARE Collectible!!!

$4,500.00

CGC 8 Beta Artist Proof Black Lotus ~ Vintage MTG/Magic ~ 1/50 in the WORLD!!!

$148,888.88

GEM MINT BGS 9.5 JAPANESE Future Sight Tarmogoyf, MTG/Magic QUAD+10!!!

$5,000.00

GEM MINT BGS 9.5 Summer Magic/MTG Wheel Of Fortune ~ ULTRA RARE!!!

$11,000.00

PAINTED & Signed Magic {M30} Retro Frame Psychic Venom Artist Proof by Snoddy

$1,750.00

1/1 PSA AUTO 10 Beta Ancestral Recall MTG Artist Proof w/Painted Art by Poole

$88,888.88

CGC 8.5 Beta Artist Proof Forest {PATH} ~ Vintage MTG/Magic ~ RARER than ALPHA!!

$500.00

PAINTED & Signed Magic {M30} Modern Frame Volcanic Island Artist Proof by Snoddy

$3,500.00

CGC 6.5 Beta Artist Proof Granite Gargoyle ~ Vintage MTG/Magic ~ 1/50 Worldwide

$1,500.00

PAINTED & Signed Magic {M30} Modern Frame Spell Blast Artist Proof by Snoddy

$1,250.00

CGC 8.5 Beta Artist Proof Guantlet of Might ~ Vintage MTG/Magic ~ 1/50 Worldwide

$6,000.00

GEM MINT PSA 10 1990 Marvel Universe 1st Series Mr. Fantastic #19

$999.99

BGS 9 Summer Magic/MTG Vesuvan Doppleganger, W/2x 9.5 SUBs ~ RARER Than Alpha!!!

$17,750.00

1/1 PSA AUTO 10 Beta Mox Sapphire MTG Artist Proof w/Painted Art by Dan Frazier

$88,888.88

Vintage Magic | MTG Revised Edition Taiga, NEAR MINT+ Condition!!!

$650.00

GEM MINT BGS 9.5 Summer Magic/MTG Plateau, ULTRA RARE!!!

$12,500.00

BGS 9 Summer Magic/MTG Savannah Lions, QUAD+9.5 SUBs ~ RARER Than Alpha!!!

$3,150.00

***POP 1*** GEM MINT PSA 10 Underground Sea, MTG/Magic Collector's Edition [CE]

$4,500.00

GEM MINT PSA 10 1990 Marvel Universe 1st Edition/Series Sabretooth #57

$600.00

MINT PSA 9 1990 Marvel Universe Series 1 Silver Surfer #MH3, HOLOGRAM!!!

$999.99

NM/MINT+ BGS 8 Summer Magic/MTG Savannah, W/2x 9.5 SUBGRADES!!!

$7,500.00

CGC 9 Beta Artist Proof Mana Flare ~ Vintage MTG/Magic ~ 1/50 in the WORLD!!!

$3,000.00

MINT PSA 9 1990 Marvel Universe Series 1 Magneto #MH2, HOLOGRAM = PACK FRESH!!!

$999.99

GEM MINT BGS 9.5 Summer Magic/MTG Royal Assassin ~ ULTRA RARE!!!

$7,750.00

NM/MINT+ BGS 8.5 Summer Magic/MTG Tropical Island, W/3x 9.5 SUBGRADES!!!

$15,000.00

1/1 PSA AUTO 10 Beta Underground Sea MTG Artist Proof w/Painted Art by Alexander

$88,888.88

FACTORY SEALED FBB MTG/Magic German Revised Booster Pack, Sea/Tundra/Island???

$599.98

GEM MINT BGS 9.5 Summer Magic/MTG Badlands, ULTRA RARE!!!

$12,500.00
Items Per Page
See All

About us

Welcome to VintageMagic.com, LLC the world leader in vintage MTG rarities.Our eBay store offers the widest selection of artwork, sketches, artist proofs, altered & signed cards and graded & ungraded cards.Visit the Vintage Magic store @ www.vintagemagic.com for our complete inventory.
Location: United StatesMember since: Mar 02, 2006Seller: vintagemagicllc

Feedback ratings

Last 12 months

Positive448- positive feedback in last 12 months
Neutral1- neutral feedback in last 12 months
Negative3- negative feedback in last 12 months

Detailed seller ratings

Average for the last 12 months

Accurate description
4.9
Reasonable shipping cost
4.4
Shipping speed
4.9
Communication
4.9

Seller feedback (7,737)

_***b (3)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
My card arrived in just as good of condition as described, packaged very well, and was shipped and delivered in a quick timeframe. Everything was quick and smooth. Great job from the seller.
a***s (181)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Very fast delivery and card was well packaged, arriving just as described in pristine condition. A+++ seller!
a***7 (241)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past year
Verified purchase
Booster box arrived exactly as pictured and mentioned. I have not opened them, but have no concerns about fake. Seller is authentic. Shipping was fast and very secure and safe. Awesome to work with a high rep and honest seller on high value items like this!
o***4 (24)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past year
Verified purchase
Card was completely as described, in pristine condition and packaged perfectly. Shipping was expensive but relatively fast considering location. Positive reviews on this seller’s account are warranted and legitimate despite my personal concerns.
e***1 (4457)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past month
Verified purchase
Item shipped quickly, as described, packaged well, no problems.
a***c (653)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past month
Verified purchase
fast shipping, well packaged, great seller, thanking you!
See all feedback