Featured categories
Newly Listed
See allFeatured items
All items

Vtg California Raisins Figures Lot of 6 Applause 1988 Burger King Excellent Toys
$8.99

Vtg Interpur Japan Flatware 47 Pc MCM Stainless Steel Wood Handle Royal Elegance
$89.99

12 Pack - SHOWA Atlas 370 Black Work Gloves - Large New Old Stock Nitrile Palm
$34.99

Vintage 1991 Hardees The Flintstones Glasses The First 30 Years Mixed 5 Pc GUC
$19.99

Microsoft Zune Digital Media MP3 Player (1091) - Brown - PARTS ONLY Untested
$49.99

Vintage 1985 GI Joe Mauler M.B.T. Military Tank Original Box Incomplete Works
$325.00

Vintage Spongebob Squarepants Animated Sing 2002 Gemmy Viacom New Old Stock
$21.99

BATTLE RAM CHARIOT SKELETOR MASTERS OF THE UNIVERSE MOTU 2001 MATTEL 02 GIFT SET
$99.00

Fangoria #45 June 1985 Elvira, Fright Night, Friday The 13th A New Beginning
$29.99

90’s Vintage Starter Graffiti Michigan Wolverines Wool Snapback Hat GUC
$35.99

Vtg VIKING ORANGE AMBERINA MCM DRAPE THREE TOE PERSIMMON SWUNG GLASS VASE 24.5"
$269.99

Five AUTHENTIC CATERPILLAR TRACTOR DECALS 6.5”x1.5” NOS NEW Neeg2001
$7.99

Little People Lot Of 8 Figures Fisher Price Farmer Tech Kids Mixed GUC Variety
$9.99

New SQUARE D MO8 Multi Breaker 115A 15 amp 120 volt single pole Ad On Unit
$15.99

Transformers G1 Insecticon Shrapnel Complete Vintage 1985 Hasbro Takara GUC BB1
$14.99

Aurora T-jet Vibrator White Convertible Jaguar XK 140 1541 HO Slot Car Vtg 60s
$54.99

Vintage 1970s GRAIS Angel Skin Cabretta Leather Jacket Coat Blazer Brown Size 44
$37.99

1994 TMNT MINI MUTANT LEONARDO SEWER PLAYSET Master Splinter Chair Incomplete
$54.99

Vintage PAL USA RH-50 Stacked Leather Handle Hunting Knife 8 1/2” Length WWII
$34.99

Wild Bill Hickok No. 28 Kong Of The THIEVES 10 CENT COVER GOLD AGE HH1 GUC
$34.99

US AIR FORCE VETERAN/RETIRED HAT OR LAPEL PIN USAF Blue Silver Wing
$8.99

7 Wonders Duel Board Game NEW Sealed - REPOS Production Military Strategy Cards
$19.99

VINTAGE Nauticalia No. 97668 BRASS POCKET SEXTANT MARITIME NAUTICAL INSTRUMENT
$79.99

Safariland Model P 25 Holster, Colt, Black, Leather, Left Hand, 4" Colt Revolver
$19.99

Vintage Duck Pen Holder Paperweight Floating Beads Water Filled Mallard Desk
$15.99

Vintage Companio C557MP Hand Plane Smooth Bottom, Red , Wood Handles Made in USA
$23.99

NEW VERY RARE MARVEL SPIDERMAN 2004 INTERCHANGEABLE FACE DIALS WATCH SPIDER MAN
$19.99

Vintage The Land Before Time Plush Ducky in Cracked Dino Egg GUC Toy Mini
$19.99

1991 Hallmark Keepsake Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol - 5 Piece Set GUC
$29.99

Johnson 50/50 Pure Solder 11 GA - 1 lb Vintage Patinad Old Estate Find As Seen
$12.99

Kobalt Standard & Metric 3/8 Drive Mechanics Tool/socket & Ratchet Set, 24 Piece
$21.99

Vintage 1970s Crown Badminton Rackets Set of 4 Wooden Tan White Shuttlecocks Box
$29.99

Official 2023 149th Kentucky Derby Horseshoe Hat Women's Strapback Hat White
$15.99

Mythical Pokemon Collection - Shaymin Pin GUC Official Pin G16 2016 OD2
$9.99

Playmates Jim Lee's WildCats Accessories Lot 1994 Vtg 6" Action Figure Weapons
$9.99

Vintage 1984 Avon Dragonfly Blue/Green Wings Dangle Bead Chain Body Lapel Pin
$9.99

Renwal Dollhouse Furniture Lot Playground Kiddie Tricycle Baby Dolls Variety
$29.99

Vintage ILLINOIS Pom Cuff Beanie Blue Orange Winter Hat Cap Fighting Illini GUC
$8.99

New Vintage Toy Things 1997 Marvel Silver Surfer 36 In. Inflatable Bop Bag
$34.99

War Stories Combat #24 1967-Dell-Sam Glanzman art-WWII-Battle for Leyte Gulf GUC
$14.99

Care Bears Yellow Funshine Bear 8" Teddy Bear Plush STUFFED ANIMAL Toy NEW 2015
$9.99

Vtg Fangoria Magazine #37 - August 1984 - Gremlins / Creepshow Spielberg Horror
$19.99

Frost Cutlery Flying Falcon 2" Stainless Rostfrei Blade Off White Handle EUC
$5.99

Q Billion Nintendo Game Boy Complete CIB Authentic Manual Insert Cart Boxed GUC
$29.99

Vintage Red Man Chewing Tobacco Solid Brass Belt Buckle Made in the USA 1978
$15.99

Fangoria Horror Magazine #38 (Oct 1984) Gremlins, Friday the 13th, Wes Craven
$17.99

Royal Special 420 Stainless Fixed Blade Hunting Knife With Sheath. Japan
$16.99

Funko Pop! Disney Regina Mills With Fireball 382 Once Upon A Time NOB Shelf Wear
$21.99
About us
Welcome to Thrifting Theology!
Everything is valuable in the right hands. Thrifting. Resale. Crafting. Up cycling. All sorts of odds and ends, old and new. But the best gift of all is life through Jesus, trusting in Him.
Thank you for taking the time to check out our store. Stay tuned for new listings daily. Can't find what you're looking for? Let us know what we can keep our eyes out for!
We will offer bundle shipping options on appropriate orders with the same address when its safe and reasonable to ship items together. Please use the cart system when purchasing multiple items as this streamlines the process. A shipping discount will be applied after new shipping rates are acquired when ordering multiple items when applicable.
Store is Currently in process of some maintenance and changes. Please Standby for a more formal format soon.
Please feel free to reach out with any comments and concerns. We'll be happy to get back with you.
Everything is valuable in the right hands. Thrifting. Resale. Crafting. Up cycling. All sorts of odds and ends, old and new. But the best gift of all is life through Jesus, trusting in Him.
Thank you for taking the time to check out our store. Stay tuned for new listings daily. Can't find what you're looking for? Let us know what we can keep our eyes out for!
We will offer bundle shipping options on appropriate orders with the same address when its safe and reasonable to ship items together. Please use the cart system when purchasing multiple items as this streamlines the process. A shipping discount will be applied after new shipping rates are acquired when ordering multiple items when applicable.
Store is Currently in process of some maintenance and changes. Please Standby for a more formal format soon.
Please feel free to reach out with any comments and concerns. We'll be happy to get back with you.
Seller feedback (3,445)
- y***t (307)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseWonderful sign. Spectacular seller. The sign was accurately described and pictured. No surprises. Seller was prompt in responding to questions. Great customer service. Stellar packing to protect the sign during shipping. Seller went the extra mile to make sure there would be no damage . . . and there was none. Wish more sellers were this conscientious. Very, very happy with my sign and buying experience. Recommend this seller in the highest terms.
- a***v (2172)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseExcellent seller!!!! Easy transaction / discounted price / best offer accepted!!!! Good communications!!!! Excellent Value!!!! Very well described, Made in Hong Kong, plastic MAYFLOWER Moving van / Green trailer w / working lights & original box!!!! Excellent photo description also!!!! Excellent packing!!!! Very reasonable shipping!!!! Very quick shipping too!!!! 100 % "Positive !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! AAAAAA ++++++ !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
- z***r (1305)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseSuper quick shipping (only 3 days from day ordered to receipt of package), well packaged. Book arrived exactly as pictured. Great seller. Very clean book despite being old. Highly recommend this seller.
- 5***7 (27)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseExactly as described and great value. Packaged perfectly. Shipping was slow, but not due to the seller. USPS miss shipped the item. A plus plus plus seller.
- a***s (578)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseWonderful vintage Breyer Palomino Western Horse with Saddle! The model is far nicer than pictured and described! Shipping was very fast. The model was in a baggie, bubble wrapped, and nestled in a sturdy box filled with crumpled paper. I am extremely pleased with my purchase and would not hesitate to buy from this seller again. Thanks for an excellent transaction!
- p***p (2168)- Feedback left by buyer.Past yearVerified purchaseThese items arrived in excellent condition, exactly as shown in pictures & as described in the listing. They were packaged very well to make sure there were no issues affecting quality during the shipping process. Price paid for the items & shipping was very fair. The total time from date of purchase until arrival was 5 Days, fast shipping speed. Entire transaction went smoothly, no complaints. Highly satisfied with everything about this purchase, would recommend this seller to others.