Featured categories
All items

Grandeur Noel Porcelain Baby Jesus Nativity Replacement 4.5inch Figure N0088 EUC
$32.00

Antique Early 1900s Electric Toaster Drop Sides Ornate Edison 159T33 with cord
$38.00

Longaberger 1999 Medium Berry Basket - New
$27.50

Handcrafted, Standing Santa Claus figure, 2 feet tall Heirloom Santas by DianeI
$70.00

Vintage Williamson Tea England TIN (Empty) Blue Gold Elephant Tea Caddy Tin EUC
$15.00

VTG Navajo Sterling Silver and Abalone Hand Harness Bracelet and Ring Size 8 EUC
$170.00

YO-KAI WATCH HASBRO 2016 Binder w Game Board & 70 gray medals discs 1 green EUC
$57.00

Womens Lambskin Leather Jacket Coat Dk Espresso Brown LARGE Croft & Barrow EUC
$40.00

Aluminum Powder Puff Music Box with Colonial Lovers on Ceramic top Medallion EUC
$23.00

VTG 4 Piece Vanity Set Blue Glass 3 Perfume Bottles and Tray Swirl Pattern NIB
$25.00

Womens Tevu Olowahu Flip Flops. Size 8 US, NWT
$27.10

Set of 2 VTG Troll Doll Caveman and Cavewoman dressed 6.50 in tall GUC
$35.00

2 Black Metal Wall Candle Sconces 11 inch Scroll shape glass candle holder cups
$25.00

Vintage Ironstone Delaware State Round Wall Plate Souvenir 10 inches
$11.00

Set of 4 w Lids 1960s Retro Nesting Canisters cream & pink with black 1 flaw EUC
$92.00

Vintage Pair of .75 in Crystal Bells with Gold Bow Decor Under Glass Cloche EUC
$20.00

Levi Strauss and Co. boyfriend Jeans Mid rise tapered leg NWT Size16
$30.55

VTG 95 Set of 2 Mini Framed Art Prints Kathy Seek Butterflies on flowers 4 inch
$16.00

Washington REDSKINS #85 Plush Doll Dino (The Flintstones) Mascot Stuffed Animal
$22.00

Mixed Box Lot Sewing Notions weighs 10 oz. List in description GUC
$12.00

Vintage Elsa Williams "Oriental Tribute" Crewel Long Stitch Embroidery
$38.12

H By Halston Womens 'Brynn Suede Loafers
$21.68

1984 Oldsmobile Delta 88 & Custom Cruiser Models Owners Manual & Supplements EUC
$30.00

Vintage Victorian Style Piano Baby Porcelain Bisque Figurine Girl in Bonnet VGUC
$22.00

Eden Paddington Bear Made Exclusively for Macy's 15 inch Red Coat Green Hat Tags
$21.00

ThirstyStone Set of 4 Absorbent Stone Drink Coasters Wine and Fruit Design NIB
$18.00

VTG Santa Fe Railroad Messenger Bag w hand and shoulder straps blue white nylon
$75.00

MCM Set of 5 Heavy Wood 11 inch Round Dinner Plates Teak or Rosewood? VGUC
$52.80

Women's North Style 3/4 sleeves Top 2XL multi Geo Print NWOT
$19.36

VTG 1965 Texaco Touring Atlas by Rand McNally Maps of These United States GUC
$25.00

Trades of Hope Cloth Embroidered Colorful Purse Backpack 10x12x5 inches EUC
$36.00

VTG Brass Long Handled Skimmer Sifter Hearth Roaster Decor apx 20" x 9" EUC
$35.00

Lot of Two (2) Double Rolls Sunworthy brand Vinyl Wallcovering / Wallpaper.
$35.89

Set of 2 Hand Blown Icicles ornaments multi color w applied blue rigaree EUC
$11.00

222 Fifth Mug/Cup, Coffee/Tea. Pretty, fine china mug in the Gabrielle pattern
$16.16

Natural Amethyst Geode Quartz Cluster Crystal Specimen 2 lbs 3.4 oz.
$40.00

Longaberger basket 8in tall round Botanical Fields liner Blueberry medallion EUC
$40.00

VTG Set of 2 Oval Handmade Christmas hanging Ornaments Pearls, gold lace, VGUC
$30.00

Pair of Handcrafted Wood Rudolph Reindeer googly eye pompom nose jingle bell EUC
$18.00

VTG Set of 2 Blow Mold Candle Sticks w Holly and Red White Stripes 38 in GUC
$125.00

Animated 22 inch Mr. & Mrs. Claus 1990 Telco / Santas Best Motion-ettes candles
$100.00

VTG Italian Wall Art 3D Cherub Angel with Harp by A. Giannelli Apx 6 inches EUC
$21.00

White crochet blanket / afghan, white with 3D red roses
$55.50

VTG Giant Wooden Fork & Spoon Wall Decor 40 inches long Tiki Totem Handles EUC
$70.00

Giani Bernini Red Leather Crossbody Bag Purse 6.5" X 8.5" GUC FLAW GUC
$25.00

Luxury Oxblood Brown Leather Double Wine Bottle Carrier 15 inches tall EUC
$65.00

Women's Style & Co. Petite size Lg Brown Genuine Suede Blazer Jacket lapels NWT
$50.00

LEGO Constructed 5 Firetrucks Pieces & accessories AS SHOWN Apx 3 lbs. EUC
$80.00
About us
Thanks for visiting Sentimental Caterpillar (formerly Sue's Sellables). In our store you will find vintage items from clothing to home décor. We rescue unappreciated vintage glassware, pottery, artwork, clothing and a variety of odds and ends that just seemed interesting enough to add to our collection. We spend countless hours searching for items in need of rescue and do our best to repurpose, recycle or rehome. We hope you find something that interests you and hope you stop by often. We will be posting new items weekly.
We're All Mad Here!!!
...... And Remember What the Doormouse says.........."Feed Your Head".
We're All Mad Here!!!
...... And Remember What the Doormouse says.........."Feed Your Head".
Seller feedback (361)
- s***o (392)- Feedback left by buyer.Past yearVerified purchaseThis bracelet is soooooo BEAUTIFUL!!!! It's better than described. I can't believe I got it for the price I did. Pictures did not do this beauty justice. Shipping was quick and packaged so cute. Not just that but the packaging was seriously protected. I am beyond happy with this purchase and seller. THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU!!!
- o***o (1726)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseItem arrived, well packaged, as described and in great condition for its age. Shipping was reasonable. A good value. Thank you!
- u***e (294)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseA lovely pitcher and shipping was fast. The item was exactly as described and is a good value. The pitcher was skillfully packaged. I would highly recommend this seller. Thank you.
- o***. (12)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchasePackaging was good. The Dark Brown Aigner purse was a perfect color and in very good condition. Pictures presented very clearly detailed the description, making selection easy. Appreciated a discounted pricing ,to entice a quick sale and I would purchase other items in the future from this seller.
- 5***r (15)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseFast shipping. Just as described. My mother passed away on April 4th. She loves the same and honey collection. I had a sam in my closet and my daughter has been hugging sam but had asked for Honey. When she saw this she asked me to purchase jn honor of her Nana passing. She was so happy when Honey arrived. She's sleeping with both of them now as we speak. Thank you.. was in packaging sealed.
- m***b (0)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseItem was very carefully packaged and arrived as described, quickly, and better than I’d pictured! Thank you so much!