Skip to main content
Scary Store NYC

Scary Store NYC

1.9K items sold
78 followers
Contact

Shop by category

Scary Store NYC
All categories

Featured categories

Newly Listed

See all

BUY 3, GET 2

Use code BUY3GET2

Shop now

Expires December 31, 2025. Max discount $100. Exclusions apply. T & C's apply

BUY 3, GET 2

All items

Items Per Page
See All

About us

Welcome to Scary Store, where incredible savings meet uncompromising quality! We take pride in offering a wide range of merchandise that's not only easy on the wallet but also exceeds your expectations. Our dedicated team is committed to providing top-notch service, ensuring your shopping experience is smooth, enjoyable, and memorable.
Location: United StatesMember since: Jul 28, 2020Seller: thescaryjerry
Top Rated SellerScary Store NYC is one of eBay's most reputable sellers. Consistently delivers outstanding customer service Learn more

Feedback ratings

Last 12 months

Positive677- positive feedback in last 12 months
Neutral1- neutral feedback in last 12 months
Negative1- negative feedback in last 12 months

Detailed seller ratings

Average for the last 12 months
Accurate description
5.0
Reasonable shipping cost
4.9
Shipping speed
5.0
Communication
5.0

Seller feedback (737)

  • 4***g (71)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past month
    Verified purchase
    Was it just delivered very impressed with packaging the PSA sealed item is protected and sealed in clear wrapping protecting against direct handling and touching directly. Looks brand new and fully intact. Shipping was fast. Item better than described what a value. Excellent collector item with investment potential. Thx!!!!
  • n***a (266)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    I couldn’t be happier with this purchase! The item arrived lightning fast and was extremely well-packaged—clearly handled with care to ensure it arrived safely. The quality is absolutely awesome—even better than expected. It arrived in perfect condition and looks flawless. The appearance is stunning, and exactly as pictured and described in the listing. This was an amazing value for the price. It’s rare to find something this good at such a great deal. Overall, a fantastic buying experience.
  • w***4 (2548)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    Item came as described, Super fast shipping, Quality packed, A+++++++++++++++++++ ebayer, Great communication with the seller, Card came in mint condition, Great Prices, A seller i will buy from again, Great looking card. Thank You.
  • v***a (37)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    Arrived true to photos in NM condition. Was shipped in a penny sleeve and top loader combo.
  • m***m (360)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    Great seller. Item packaged properly to protect the card. Got the item for a great value, item was shipped in the appropriate time. The item is as described.
  • 9***8 (984)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    Item exactly as described and pictured online. Packaged safely and shipped fast. Great value for the quality and condition of the item. Would recommend seller and buy from them again in the future.
See all feedback

About us

Use this space to tell other eBay members about yourself and what you’re passionate about. Give people more reasons to follow you!337/1000