Skip to main content
Pupster Picker

Pupster Picker

2.3K items sold
84 followers
Contact

Featured categories

Featured items

  • Roman Kneeling Santa 8" Manger Nativity Baby Jesus Lamb 2010 RP Gauer Figurine

    $29.99

  • Shot Glass Toothpick Holder 3 Amber Beer Barrel 2.5" Mini Bar Vtg MCM Century

    $11.98

  • LEGO 71005 Bart Simpson & Ned Flanders Minifigure Simpsons Series 1 CMF

    $24.00

  • SILVESTRI Fanciful Flights SANTA CLAUS Ornament Karen Rossi 2000 Christmas

    $21.99

  • Betsey Johnson Pink Faux Pebbled Leather Backpack Jeweled 12" x 12" Zip NWOT

    $49.99

  • Handmade Tote Dog Pet Theme Cotton Fabric Medium 10" Bag Grocery Shopping Red

    $17.99

Best Sellers

  • Nemadji Art Pottery Vase Vtg 6.5" Bottleneck Swirl Clay Blue & Red Original USA

    $36.99

  • Triple 5 Five Soul NYC Crossbody Bag Vtg Blue Orange 7" x 8" Nylon Zip Y2K Logo

    $124.00

  • Sakroots Crossbody Wristlet Artist Circle Peace Smartphone Paisley

    $20.99

  • Gummy Bear Plush 2009 Candy Green 13” Toys R Us Geoffrey Stuffed Street Players

    $29.99

  • 4 Eldreth Redware Pottery EGGS Decorated 2.5" Easter 2000s - Heart 1 Signed

    $120.00

  • Art Pottery Salt Glaze Cobalt Blue Stoneware 5" Floral Pitcher Creamer

    $24.99

Top Picks

  • Ouray Jackson Hole Wyoming Hat Bronco Adjustable StrapBack Burgundy Red Cotton

    $17.99

  • Insane Clown Posse Hatchet Man Flex Fit Hat Cap ICP Juggalo Plaid 2008 Red Beige

    $24.99

  • Chicago Bulls Snapback Hat NBA Basketball Cap AJD Vtg Black Red 90s

    $19.99

  • Miami Heat Adidas Basketball NBA Logo Men's Flex Fit Fitted Cap Hat Size S/M

    $15.99

  • New ERA Chicago Cubs Hat Baseball MLB Size M/L Official Cap Dad

    $14.99

  • Peter Grimm Pura Vida Hat Fergie Brim Bucket Granny Square Rafia Beach Sun

    $39.99

Popular

  • Tyco Kitty Kitty Kittens Purring Cat Vtg 1993 Gray White Plush Stuffed Collar

    $79.99

  • Vtg Sanrio CHOCOCAT Hello Kitty 8" Black Cat Plush Stuffed 8" Nakajima 2004

    $89.00

  • Powerpuff Girls Blossom & Buttercup 8" Plush Puff Pink Green Cartoon Network

    $13.99

  • Ty Brobee Yo Gabba Gabba Plush 7" Green Striped Beanie Stuffed

    $8.99

  • Eden Wind Up Musical Bear Pastel Bow 10" Vtg Plays Deep in the Heart of Texas

    $120.00

  • Care Bears Cousins Perfect PANDA 9" Plush Bear Black & White Stuffed NEW

    $19.99

All items

Disney STEAMBOAT WILLIE Mickey Mouse Bobblehead 2003 Black White Upper Deck

$9.98

Care Bears Cousins Perfect PANDA 9" Plush Bear Black & White Stuffed NEW

$19.99

Triple 5 Five Soul NYC Crossbody Bag Vtg Blue Orange 7" x 8" Nylon Zip Y2K Logo

$124.00

Tyco Kitty Kitty Kittens Purring Cat Vtg 1993 Gray White Plush Stuffed Collar

$79.99

Lug Kickflip SE Crossbody Bag RFID Kelly Green 7.75" x 4" Cards Zip Snap

$39.99

Mexican Turtle & Fish Painted Terra Cotta Mexico 4" Trinket Wide Mouth Yellow

$19.99

Crayola Crayons Ornaments 2 Christmas 90s Drum Organ Piano Bear Binney & Smith

$10.99

Dansko Women’s Ronda Corks Black Sandals Size 9.5 Eu 40

$29.99

Vera Bradley Pink Elephant Paisley Travel 6" x 4" Jewelry Case Inside Zip

$16.99

3 Skeins 100% Wool AuGres Sheep Handspun Cherry Grape 630 yds 2 Ply NEW

$19.99

Sony HF Audio 4 Cassette Tape Lot 60 Minute Blank Recordable NEW Sealed

$8.99

REEF Cushion Strand Cork Flip Flop Sandals Size 11 Women's

$20.00

2 Wet n Wild Mascara Lash Renegade C145A Brazen BLACK Lot SEALED

$10.99

TAMMIS KEEFE Tea Towel Vtg Pride of Kansas Beef Cattle Steer MCM Rare HTF

$129.00

Vtg Zippo Lighter Lucky Strike Lights Slim Line Cigarettes Rare Smoking NOS

$224.00

Applause Rudolph the Red Nosed Reindeer 10" Plush Vtg Stuffed Animal Toy

$10.99

Dan Brechner Santa Mrs. Claus Vtg Plush 7" Dolls Christmas Felt Stuffed Toy RARE

$14.99

Cassette Tape Rock Metal OZZY Osbourne Bark Moon & Night Ranger 1983

$9.98

Vtg Aladdin Red Cup Cap Lid for 60s Thermos with Metal Top - Lamp Logo CUP ONLY

$48.50

Vera Bradley PURPLE PUNCH Bifold Wallet Coin Pocket Zip 4" Quilted Cotton

$12.99

TY Beanie PIROUETTE Ballerina 6" Ballet Bear Tutu Pink Dance Stuffed Animal NEW

$6.99

Twin Six Women Cycling Jersey Size L Grand Prix Black Large 3/4 Zip

$21.99

Scentsy Buddy Star Wars MANDALORIAN 16" w/ Scent Pak Plush Stuffed

$25.99

Charlie Puth NEW Sealed Vinyl LP 2022 Album

$24.99

Vera Bradley Wallet Wristlet LA NEON ROSE Green Black 5.5" x 3.5" Zip Cards

$8.99

Bella Taylor Wallet RFID Zip Around Accordion 7" x 4" Cards Daisy

$15.99

Fossil White Floral Flower Bag Purse Top Handle Snap

$23.99

Pottery Barn Kids Dragon Fire 2 pc Twin Sheet Set Flat & Fitted Cotton Puff

$49.99

Strawberry Shortcake CHILTON Plastic Play Plates Dish Vtg 13 pc Cups Pitcher USA

$16.99

Eternal Idol by RODIN Mouseion 3D Parastone Statue RO14 Love Sculpture Figure

$89.99

Russ Berrie Dog ROCCO Plush Bulldog Brown White 5" Vtg Stuffed Animal Korea

$11.99

3 Disney Store Plush SMALL WORLD Lot Mexico Holland Eskimo Disneyland NEW

$17.99

Twin Six Women Cycling Jersey Size L Masher Pink Black Large 3/4 Zip

$21.99

Ty Beanie Babies LUAU PIG Pink 6" Plush Stuffed Animal NEW Tag

$7.99

Pound Puppy 1985 Large 18” Tonka Chocolate Brown Vtg Plush Dog Red Collar

$12.99

Mattel Vtg Barbie Deluxe Doll 12" Trunk Storage Case Pink 1991

$20.00

Victoria Secret Purse Handbag Floral Stripe Zip Amber Romance Cottage Core

$20.00

Ty Brobee Yo Gabba Gabba Plush 7" Green Striped Beanie Stuffed

$8.99

3 NOBO No Boundaries Yarn 3 Skeins Tangerine Orange Dye Lot 797 50 gm, 65 m

$7.99

Vera Bradley JAVA BLUE Hipster Crossbody Purse 11" x 11" Bag Brown Floral Boho

$22.99

Garfield MEAD Pocket Folders Lot 4 Vtg 90s Y2K Cartoon Orange Cat Jim Davis

$21.99

Ouray Jackson Hole Wyoming Hat Bronco Adjustable StrapBack Burgundy Red Cotton

$17.99

Hasbro Weeble Wobble 2" SCUBA DIVER Vtg Man Figure Yellow Walter 1976

$13.99

Aurora REINDEER Black & White Plaid Hooves 10" Plush Stuffed Soft Baby w/ Tag

$14.99

American Greetings Vtg 1982 Sticker Holly Hobbie Puffy Stickers NOS

$14.99

Fisher Price Puffalump Pink Bunny Rabbit Vtg 1986 w/ Dress #8004 EUC

$29.99

Tonka Maisto Trucks Lil Chuck Friends 6 Diecast Metal 2.5" Hasbro Lot Dump Tow

$12.99

Hallmark Ornaments That Holy Night Nativity Kings Shepard Baby Mary 2004

$8.99
Items Per Page
See All

About us

Pupster Picker is named after my daughter's favorite plush and born out of my passion for thrifting. Hand chosen goods in my store are picked from antique malls, thrift stores and community sales giving a second life to vintage items! I am passionate about reuse and upcycling as a way to protect the environment and promote a sustainable lifestyle. To receive future promotions and sales notifications, please consider following and listing my store as a favorite. I list 4-6 new items in my store daily! My favorite items to source are mid-century glassware and collectibles.
Location: United StatesMember since: Jun 09, 2007Seller: a2c2ttw*
Top Rated SellerPupster Picker is one of eBay's most reputable sellers. Consistently delivers outstanding customer service Learn more

Feedback ratings

Last 12 months

Positive202- positive feedback in last 12 months
Neutral1- neutral feedback in last 12 months
Negative0- negative feedback in last 12 months

Detailed seller ratings

Average for the last 12 months

Accurate description
5.0
Reasonable shipping cost
4.9
Shipping speed
5.0
Communication
5.0

Seller feedback (961)

c***p (2833)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past month
Verified purchase
This Lot of 4 Mattel Enchantimal Dolls arrived in as described "Excellent Used Condition". My granddaughter will be so excited to receive these adorable dolls! They were packaged with care and shipped quickly. I would definitely purchase from this seller again ~ Thank you!
r***q (44)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Item shipped super fast - same day I think! Well packaged, nice note inside. The item was just as described. Would happily purchase from this seller another time.
e***l (3056)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Item as described, packed well, fast shipping, would purchase from again. Thanks. A+++
o***t (186)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Thank you! Trustworthy seller! Item arrived in great condition, as shown, very securely wrapped and packed.
2***4 (1133)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past month
Verified purchase
Awesome s’mores ornament. Well packaged and fast shipping! Great communication. Thank you and God bless.
a***a (191)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past month
Verified purchase
Received package today very happy with purchase, item as described thanks for wrapping item so no damage would occur during shipping.
See all feedback