Skip to main content

OldManMTG

4.0K items sold
537 followers
Contact

All items

MTG WINTER ORB (x4) Revised (OldManMTG 009-274)

$39.00

HAVIC THE BOTHERING starter deck sealed (OldManMTG 008-554)

$59.75

MTG ICE AGE Starter Deck (OldManMTG 008-845)

$102.75

MTG TRANSMUTE ARTIFACT Antiquities (OldManMTG 009-239)

$395.00

MTG HYPNOTIC SPECTER (German) 4th Edition FBB (OldManMTG 008-575)

$19.50

MTG ISLAND Alpha (OldManMTG 008-365)

$29.75

MTG PHYREXIAN ALTAR Invasion (OldManMTG 005-565)

$32.50

MTG LEGENDS (Italian) Booster Pack Sealed (OldManMTG 009-275)

$195.00

MTG MAGICAL HACK Unlimited (OldManMTG 007-305)

$11.50

MTG SHANODIN DRYADS Alpha (OldManMTG 008-462)

$18.50

MTG SOL RING (French) Revised FBB (OldManMTG 008-886)

$88.50

MTG SWAMP Alpha (OldManMTG 008-493)

$28.75

MTG HOLY ARMOR (x 4) Beta (OldManMTG 006-705)

$27.50

MTG WALL OF WOOD Alpha (OldManMTG 008-523)

$15.95

MTG ICE AGE Booster Pack Sealed (OldManMTG 008-713)

$32.75

MTG VESUVAN DOPPELGANGER Revised (OldManMTG 009-271)

$18.00

MTG FROZEN SHADE Alpha (OldManMTG 008-315)

$19.95

MTG RED ELEMENTAL BLAST Beta (OldManMTG 004-943)

$44.50

MTG FROZEN SHADE Alpha (OldManMTG 008-313)

$19.95

MTG URZA'S TOWER, POWER PLANT, MINE Antiquities (OldManMTG 009-077)

$127.50

MTG UNGLUED Complete Set NM 94 cards (OldManMTG 007-464)

$287.75

MTG 4th EDITION Starter Deck Sealed (OldManMTG 008-831)

$148.50

MTG ICE AGE Starter Deck (OldManMTG 008-833)

$92.50

MTG HYPNOTIC SPECTER (German) 4th Edition FBB (OldManMTG 008-577)

$19.50

MTG HYPNOTIC SPECTER (French) 4th Edition FBB (OldManMTG 008-579)

$19.50

MTG RED ELEMENTAL BLAST Alpha (OldManMTG 008-432)

$63.50

MTG SERRA ANGEL (Italian) Revised FBB (OldManMTG 009-006)

$19.95

MTG VESUVAN DOPPELGANGER Unlimited (OldManMTG 005-092)

$109.50

MTG ROYAL ASSASSIN (Italian) Revised FBB (OldManMTG 008-929)

$38.75

MTG FELLWAR STONE 4th Edition (Japanese) FBB (OldManMTG 005-376)

$10.00

MTG URZA'S POWER PLANT, MINE, TOWER Antiquities (OldManMTG 009-075)

$127.50

MTG HYPNOTIC SPECTER (x4) Unlimited (OldManMTG 008-570)

$99.50

MTG WRATH OF GOD Unlimited (OldManMTG 007-380)

$95.75

MTG MOUNTAIN (Foil) Arena Promo (OldManMTG 009-195)

$14.00

MTG DURESS (Foil) Arena Promo (OldManMTG 007-896)

$58.50

MTG MINOR DEMON Citadel Gaming Token Unlimited (OldManMTG 008-605)

$19.50

MTG BLACK LOTUS PUZZLE PIECE (2 of 9) (OldManMTG 009-090)

$29.95

MTG BLACK LOTUS PUZZLE PIECE (1 of 9) (OldManMTG 009-096)

$29.95

MTG SERRA ANGEL (French) Revised FBB (OldManMTG 009-005)

$19.95

MTG CHAOS ORB PUZZLE PIECE (6 of 9) (OldManMTG 009-109)

$24.95

MTG NORTHERN PALADIN Unlimited (OldManMTG 007-323)

$32.75

MTG SEDGE TROLL (German) Revised FBB (OldManMTG 008-969)

$39.75

MTG COPY ARTIFACT Revised (OldManMTG 009-234)

$55.00

MTG TSUNAMI Beta (OldManMTG 006-946)

$19.75

MTG GLASSES OF URZA Beta (OldManMTG 006-672)

$31.75

MTG SWAMP Alpha (OldManMTG 008-490)

$39.75

MTG SWAMP Alpha (OldManMTG 008-489)

$39.75

MTG ISLAND (Foil) Arena Promo No Symbol Mis-print (OldManMTG 009-199)

$85.00

About us

OldManMTG is a seller of quality vintage Magic: the Gathering cards on eBay. All of these cards are from my personal collection acquired over the past twenty-five years.
Location: United StatesMember since: Oct 20, 1998Seller: oldmanmtg
Top Rated SellerOldManMTG is one of eBay's most reputable sellers. Consistently delivers outstanding customer service Learn more

Detailed seller ratings

Average for the last 12 months

Accurate description
5.0
Reasonable shipping cost
4.9
Shipping speed
5.0
Communication
5.0

Seller feedback (1,843)

s***e (320)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
OldManMTG has some of the coolest collection of vintage cards and great prices!! One of my favorite sellers! Card arrived in mint condition! Packaging was well planned and shipping came on early then expected! Highly recommend this buyer! Save him to your favorites! God bless you OldManMTG! 😃
r***w (230)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Very happy with my order, packed and shipped extremely well, great communication, would highly recommend this seller.
x***s (4)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Card was is perfect condition, just as described. Shipping was fast, and the card was packaged well. 10/10 would buy from this seller again.
s***r (498)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
great seller, fast shipping, safe packaging, item as described a+++ ty
0***_ (203)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
wow! expertly packed, fast shipping, items as described - happy customer
c***8 (8)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Item shipped in a timely manner and packaged very well. Card arrived exactly as pictured and described. Very good experience, definitely would shop with again!