Featured categories
Auctions ending soon
See allAll items

MTG 5000 Card Bulk Lot! Rares Foils FREE SHIPPING Star5
$64.0014 bids19m

Ornithopter - The Brothers’ War Retro Frame Artifacts Schematic Serialized Foil
$575.00

Hascon 2017 Promos
$225.00

MTG SDCC 2019 Dragon's Endgame Promos Sealed English NIB BEA FREE SHIPPING
$9.991 bid6d 0h 19m

MTG Win015 Chaos Draft 36 packs +1 Prize Booster FREE SHIPPING
$152.506 bids5d 0h 19m

Prophecy Booster Box
$978.00

Streets of New Capenna Factory Sealed Complete Set English REGULAR FREE SHIPPING
$230.00

MTG 2x Black Lotus Sleeves BGwin WOTC Employee Exclusive Very Rare FREE SHIPPING
$9.991 bid5d 0h 19m

Tropical Island - Foreign Black Bordered GERMAN
$1,725.00

Innistrad: Crimson Vow Factory Sealed Complete Set Regular FREE SHIPPING
$230.00

MTG Dragons of Tarkir KOREAN Set with #WOTCStaff Exclusives Star FREE SHIPPING
$99.001 bid6d 0h 19m

Stoneforge Mystic FOIL - Worldwake
$69.00

Plateau - Beta
$2,875.00

MTG 1x Elvish Promenade Lorwyn Regular LP FREE SHIPPING
$6.00

MTG Commander 2015 Set of 5 Decks Factory Sealed English Bea FREE SHIPPING
$42.008 bids5d 0h 19m

Mirage Booster Display
$2,760.00

Underground Sea - Foreign Black Bordered Italian
$2,070.00

Zendikar Booster Box
$1,093.00

Commander 2016 Sealed Case (Set of 5)
$1,035.00

Taiga - Revised Foreign Black Bordered GERMAN
$920.00

Commander 2014 Sealed Case (Set of 5)
$518.00

MTG 4x End the Festivities Innistrad: Crimson Vow Regular LP FREE SHIPPING
$6.00

The Ozolith - Promo Pack FOIL
$41.00

Throne of Eldraine Factory Sealed Complete Set REGULAR
$322.00

Candelabra of Tawnos - Antiquities
$920.00

Urza's Destiny Booster Box
$5,164.00

Ravnica: City of Guilds Booster Box
$1,150.00

Phoenix Heart - WOTC Employee Exclusive
$57,500.00

Magic "White Back" Blank Card
$12.00

Worldwake Fat Pack/Bundle
$460.00

Urza's Legacy Booster Box
$6,900.00

The Abyss - Italian Legends
$575.00

Commander Collection Green PREMIUM
$75.00

Orcish Oriflamme - Alpha
$403.00

Secret Lair Drop The Astrology Lands Scorpio
$46.00

Alara Reborn Booster Display
$575.00

Magic 2013 Core Set Booster Battle Pack
$288.00

MTG 4x Dawn Charm Planar Chaos Regular LP FREE SHIPPING
$6.00

MTG 4x Gemhide Sliver Time Spiral Regular LP FREE SHIPPING
$6.00

Wheel of Fortune - 30th Anniversary Edition
$920.00

Invasion Booster Box
$1,150.00

Planechase Anthology
$368.00

Shards of Alara Booster Box
$759.00

Questing Phelddagrif- Planeshift Prerelease Promo
$12.00

Nytkthos, Shrine to Nyx - Pro Tour Promo FOIL
$115.00

City of Brass - Arabian Nights
$564.00

Scrubland - Revised GERMAN Black Bordered
$690.00

MTG 1x Freed from the Real Masters 25 Regular LP FREE SHIPPING
$6.00
About us
Making Mythic is a gaming collectibles company selling primarily Magic: The Gathering and Dungeons & Dragons collectibles. We are owned and founded by former Wizards of the Coast staff. Most of our items come directly from former employees and their authenticity is guaranteed. (Please note: Making Mythic LLC is NOT affiliated with Wizards of the Coast.)
Seller feedback (1,526)
- o***o (19)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseTLDR - Wanted a NEO sealed set and that is exactly what I got. Next time I pick one up, I'll check here first. Postage as expected, Packaging no problems, and original wizards shrink wrap as you'd expect. As described: yes, will happily buy sealed sets from this company again Value: if you're looking at this you already know you're willing to spend this much money, don't lie to the review.
- p***o (154)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseA+++++ seller! Fast shipping, very good packaging. Item was new as described. Good communication & I will be glad to buy from him again.
- s***e (362)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseMy favorite store to shop and I love the sellers great customer service 🙌 shipping was fast! Item was packaged perfectly! As described! Great deal and value! Good quality great condition and everything appears as described!
- 1***1 (1)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseExactly as described. Exactly as expected. Great condition. Fast shipping. Packaged well. Got it cheaper than it’s listed everywhere else & it is a great value for the product. Will be return customers.
- 4***4 (27)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseThe boxes came in perfect condition and packaged very carefully. There was a huge price spike during shipping and seller still honored our agreement when they didn't have to. They've definitely earned my repeat business for as long as I'm collecting MTG.
- c***n (270)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseAlways a pleasure doing business with this seller. Items always come as advertised and packaged very nicely. Highly recommended seller!!