Featured categories
Newly Listed
See allFeatured items
All items

Funny Quirky T-Shirt for Stress Relief, Unisex Tee "I Work Well Under Pressure"
$19.99 to $25.99

Scholastic Kindergarten Phonics Fun and Grade 1 Super Sentences Flash Cards
$6.99

I'd Rather Be Working Relaxed Unisex T-Shirt for Casual Everyday Wear
$19.99 to $25.99

Women's Lightly Lined Strapless Bra Auden™ Soft Beige
$7.99

Kids' 2pk Outdoor Over the Calf Knee High Socks All in Motion™ Navy Blue M
$8.99

1997 Time Warner 18 Rock Hard Hits CD
$6.99

2010 Strawberry Shortcake 30th Anniversary Set 3 Vintage Style Original Dolls
$299.99

Perfect Husband: The Laci Petersen Story (DVD, 2004)
$6.99

Boys' Short Sleeve Performance Uniform Polo Shirt Cat & Jack™ Light Blue
$5.99

Wild Fable Black Flare Pants Size XL NWT
$11.99

My Friends Tigger Pooh: Friendly Tails (DVD, 2008)
$6.99

Blue's Clues Blue's Big Musical Movie (DVD, 2000, Sensormatic) Disc ONLY
$6.99

Women's Mock Turtleneck Tiny Tank Top Wild Fable™ Green Size M
$7.99

My First Craftsman Racing Set
$27.99

1996 The Horse Whisperer Paperback Book Nicholas Evans
$6.99

Dark Horse Comics #11 Conan The God In The Bowl Comic Book
$5.99

My Sweet Love Sweet Baby 4 Pieces Cuddly Plush Pal Gray Kitty BNIB
$14.95

Stumble Guys 5 Pack Collectible Figures Exclusive Stumbler NEW
$8.95

Funny Procrastination Prevention T-Shirt, Gift for Students, Unisex Tee, College
$19.99 to $29.43

Matchbox MBX Ocean Rescue Vehicle Playset
$28.99

High School Musical 3: Senior Year (CD, Oct-2008, Walt Disney Records)
$6.99

Beginner Books(R) Ser.: Busy Street by Edward Miller (2022, Hardcover)
$9.85

Stained Glass Autumn Pumpkin Latte Tough Phone Case for Galaxy, Pixel, IPhone
$29.99

1972 CBS Records Poco A Good Feeling to Know CD
$6.99

Garfield's Pet Force 3D DVD 2010
$6.99

Best of Rock Ballads Audio CD By Various Artists CD 2006
$6.99

Kenny Chesney Everywhere We Go Cassette Tape
$6.99

Short Sleeve Fitted T-Shirt Wild Fable™ Pink Striped Size M
$6.95

2010 Hasbro Transformers Dark of the Moon Mechtech Autobot Roadbuster Figure 6"
$18.99

Celtic Thunder X 10 Year Celebration (CD, 2018)
$6.99

The Live Kinks (CD)
$8.99

DC Imaginext Black Bat & Ninja Batman Action Figures 2-Pack
$9.99

2015 Thomas & Friends Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure Universal Studios DVD
$6.99

Women's Short Sleeve V-Neck T-Shirt a New Day™ White
$5.99

A New Day Silver Collection Sterling Silver 16" Necklace
$7.95

The Jubilee Collection Christmas Relaxation Specially Arranged for Panflute CD
$6.99

Women's Cozy Light Support Cami Sports Bra All In Motion Heathered Beige XS NWT
$7.99

The Tiger's Fang Paul Twitchell Paperback Book 1967
$7.99

Tiara Indiana Ponderosa Pine Cone Clear Footed Juice Glass Set of 4 Glasses VTG
$16.99

Woochie Latex Appliance Grand Opening
$11.99

Finding Nemo (DVD, 2003, 2-Disc Set)
$6.99

2018 Barbie National Geographic Photo Journalist Doll with Accessories MOC
$34.95

Carter's Just One You® Baby Girls' Floral Top & Bottom Set with Headband Size 6M
$7.99

Women's Sprint Free Racerback Tank Top All in Motion™ Black XXL
$9.99

Miami Sound Machine Machine Primitive Love Cassette Tape 1985
$6.99

DC Super Friends Batman Plush w/Cape Stuffed Toy Factory 13" Comics
$9.95

Exercise TV Presents Incredible Abs Volume 2 DVD
$6.99

Suit Yourself Bleeding Machete 21" Halloween Costume Accessory NEW
$11.99
About us
Madcap Toys Plus is a vibrant and imaginative toy shop that offers not only a whimsical escape for children and collectors alike, but also offers clothing, shoes and much more! Located in the heart of Spencer, this charming toy barn features an extensive selection of both classic and contemporary toys. From retro action figures to dolls and bears, clothing and pallet items, Madcap Toys Plus has something for everyone.
Store policies
Shipping
Returns
Seller feedback (195)
- 0***7 (919)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseItem as described and securely packaged. The trident survived the USPS misdirecting and crushing the box. I would definitely purchase from this seller again. They were very responsive with excellent communication. They clearly care about customer service. Super seller. A+++ Perfect for my costume. Thank you for the deal- great value.Reply from: madcaptoysplus- Feedback replied by seller madcaptoysplus.- Feedback replied by seller madcaptoysplus.You have been the BEST throughout all of this! So sorry USPS mishandled the box and shipped it way past its time. So glad that the trident will make your costume PERFECT! Welcome back anytime!
- n***t (119)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseThe 1990-1998 Cadillac Deville/Eldorado Chilton's Repair Manual was exactly as ordered, expertly packaged, shipped and arrived in a most timely manner. Thanks again Madcap Toys Plus for another great E-Bay online shopping experience and will recommend your store to other Cadillac owners without hesitation!Reply from: madcaptoysplus- Feedback replied by seller madcaptoysplus.- Feedback replied by seller madcaptoysplus.Thank you for the wonderful feedback and you are welcome back anytime!
- t***a (93)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseSeller has good communication, order is as described, good packaging, affordable price, fast shipping.Reply from: madcaptoysplus- Feedback replied by seller madcaptoysplus.- Feedback replied by seller madcaptoysplus.It was wonderful working with you! Thank you so much and come back soon!
- 1***2 (1150)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseA pleasure to do business with! Shipped quickly and packaged well, as described and an excellent value!!Reply from: madcaptoysplus- Feedback replied by seller madcaptoysplus.- Feedback replied by seller madcaptoysplus.Thank you for your wonderful feedback and for shopping with us!
- i***t (124)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseShipped on time, great packaging, items were as described. All in all, a great value. Thanks! AAAA++++Reply from: madcaptoysplus- Feedback replied by seller madcaptoysplus.- Feedback replied by seller madcaptoysplus.Thank you so much for shopping with us! Welcome back anytime!
- a***a (23)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseFast shipping ,item as described in picture and value close to cost in the store. Nice packaging too. I would order from this seller again thanks.Reply from: madcaptoysplus- Feedback replied by seller madcaptoysplus.- Feedback replied by seller madcaptoysplus.I'm so glad you love them! Thanks for shopping with us!