Featured categories
Newly Listed
See allAll items

Build a Bear Smallfrys Hello Kitty Pink Polka Dots 7" Plush 2012
$29.99

Jellycat Bashful Puppy Soother Security Blanket Baby Lovey Plush Black Cream
$14.99

Merrythought Teddy Bear 8" Embroidered Eyes Plush Made in England Small
$29.99

Tykes Carters Blue Puppy Dog Baby Lovey Teether Toy Mirror 2002
$14.99

Folksy Foresters FOX Corduroy Plush Stuffed Animal Manhattan Toy Company 14"
$17.99

Carters Pink Elephant Security Blanket Baby Lovey Love Me
$12.99

Baby Gund Teddy Bear Mini Meadow Briar Blue Gingham Shorts 4040396 Small Plush
$17.99

Pickles Lamb Security Blanket Baby Lovey Cream White Plush
$46.497% off

Tadpoles Teddy Bear Security Blanket Baby Lovey Minky Raised Dots Cream
$14.99

Bobblehead Cat Cowboy Christmas Ornament Ceramic Kitsch
$14.99

Pottery Barn Kids Lamb Plush Stuffed Animal Lovey 12"
$14.99

Mary Meyer Unicorn Security Blanket Baby Lovey Floral Pink Green Twilight
$14.99

Dutch Bros Rare Sticker Mother’s Day Mom May 2023 Heart Arrow Roses Tatoo
$9.99

Passover Needlepoint Canvas Judaica Jewish Art Made in Austria Vintage
$18.597% off

Kids Preferred Blue Plush Puppy Dog Small Baby Rattle Lovey Thank Heaven 9"
$14.99

Dakin Teddy Bear 1990 Brown Plush Small 6" Vintage
$19.99

Baby Starters Puppy Security Blanket Dream Big Little One Lovey Rattle Blue Tan
$14.99

Playtex Baby Teddy Bear Plush Lovey Vibrating Stroller Toy Ball
$14.99

Minky Couture Baby Blanket Pink White Chevron Rosettes Plush
$37.197% off

Just One Year Sweet Baby Boy Bear Security Blanket Lovey Carters Blue Star
$24.99

Just One Year Doll Baby Lovey Plush Pink Dress 3 Flowers Brown Hair Carters
$18.597% off

Playing Cards Outdoor Adventure National Parks On Every Game Card Deck Of 52 New
$9.99

CCA&B Elf on the Shelf Boy Doll Red Plush Stuffed Christmas Toy 14"
$15.99

The Tweenies Bella Doll BBC Hasbro Blue Red Yellow Small 8" Toy
$26.037% off

Vintage Rubber Squeak Squeeze Toy Pink Bunny Rabbit 4.75"
$17.99

Fisher Price Little People Monkey Tan Waving New
$10.99

Magic Years Unicorn Security Blanket Baby Lovey Believe Rainbow Pink White
$12.99

Olli Ella Dinkums Doll Patty Pear Green Small 9" Baby Lovey Plush Fruity Cuties
$25.107% off

Little Giraffe Pink Luxe Faux Fur Plush Baby Blanket 28x34
$41.847% off

Gund Teddy Bear with Puppy Dog Thinking of You For My Best Friend Plush 60399
$18.597% off

Pottery Barn Kids Lamb Plush Baby Ring Rattle Small
$12.99

The Three Weavers Vintage Acrylic Baby Blanket Yellow Satin Trim Embroidered
$39.99

Grawe & Hill Cutlers Stainless Flatware Lot of 5 Knife Forks Spoons 18/10
$27.897% off

Zangeen Beanie Plush Lamb Sheep 2004 White Black Face Small 8"
$23.247% off

Baberoo Cow Security Blanket Baby Lovey Plush White Gray Black
$14.99

Ikea Bunny Rabbit Plush Vandring Hare Stuffed Animal Toy Gray
$19.99

Goodnight Moon Bunny Security Blanket Baby Lovey Knots Blue Yellow Patch Plush
$16.99

Vintage Lullaby Club Baby's First Toys Cat Terrycloth Lamb Duck Rattle Lovey Set
$51.147% off

Carters Fox Security Blanket Baby Lovey Pink Salmon 2016
$18.597% off

Ty Pluffies Whiffer Puppy Dog Brown White Plush Baby Lovey 2002 Plushie TyLux
$21.387% off

Baby Starters Lamb Little Dreamer Security Blanket Baby Lovey Plush White
$39.99

Cloud Island Floral Field Quilted Baby Blanket Crib Target Pink White
$23.247% off

Carters White Lamb Security Blanket Baby Lovey Plush 2016 Pacifier Loop
$18.597% off

Target Square Floral Security Blanket Baby Lovey Crinkle Toy 6" Small 2022
$14.99

Gund Plush Kitty Cat Beige Tabby Stuffed Animal Plushie 11"
$29.99

Mighty Star Teddy Bear Cub Plush Stuffed Animal Vintage 10" Tan Beige Cream 4504
$23.247% off

Kellytoy Elephant Rattle Stroller Clip Baby Lovey Plush Gray Toy Fluffy KLuxe 9"
$12.99

IKEA Bunny Rabbit Plush 7" Vintage Stuffed Animal Beige Rare Small
$23.247% off
About us
Welcome to The Lost Lovey Store! I'm here to help you find that item your child just can't live without! I offer baby blankets, security blankets, baby loveys, plush toys, and stuffed animals--things that are so important to our little ones. My inventory usually contains vintage baby blankets and plush toys as well, because no matter how old we get, sometimes it's delightful to have a nostalgic piece of our childhood. Can't find what you're looking for? Let me know, and I might be able to help you. Check back often; I add new inventory almost every day!
Store policies
Shipping
Seller feedback (7,436)
- k***t (205)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseQuick and easy transaction. Nicely packaged and shipped quickly. As described and fairly priced. Thank you!
- 2***m (84)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseFast shipping, great packing, secure blanket as described, and great for the value.
- 8***8 (3)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseItem arrived very quickly, great price! Item exactly as described. Packaged carefully.
- l***o (2042)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseGreat seller! Item as shown, quick shipping and very well packaged. Thanks!
- h***- (1)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseThis lamb is very important for my daughter (somone stoled her old one). So, this is worth everything for us, the shipping and the packing was good. This is in good condition as described.
- r***s (179)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseItem as described, fast shipping and great price!