Skip to main content

Keepsake Keyholders

2.2K items sold


Vintage Halloween Black Cat Jack O Lantern Place Mats Woven Tapestry Set Of 4


Halloween Suncatcher Lot Of 3 Plastic Bat Cat Pumpkin Jack O Lantern Vintage


Disney Parks Lantern Halloween Spooky Goth Haunted Mickey Mouse Exclusive Donald


Winter on the Beach 16" Santa Blue Fluffy White Flip Flops Pacific Ocean


Vintage Garfield The Cat Plush Lot of 3 1981 DAKIN INC Plush Christmas Festive


Nativity Crochet Kit NEW in BOC




Hand Crafted Christmas Nutcracker Winn Dixie 15” Wooden Excellent Axe


Hand Crafted Christmas Nutcracker Winn Dixie 15” Wooden READ


Vintage Halloween Empire Blow Mold Jack-O-Lantern Scarecrow 1995


Vans Women's Tie Dye Slip On Shoes Size 6.5 Excellent Used Condition


Beagle Bonez Dog Skeleton Halloween Prop Decoration Spooky Village Scary Canine


Halloween Village Decorations 30 + Piece Set Pumpkin House Trees Some Duplicate


Konst Smide Christmas Lights 885 7 Faux Candles Sweden Tested Electrical W/ Box


Dan Dee Singing Plush Collector's Choice Reindeer Christmas Holiday Decor TESTED


Vintage Color Drip Candles (2 Pack) Halloween Color Changing


Disney Store Halloween Mickey Minnie Mouse Bat Spider Plush 15" Stuffed Toy New


Spirit Halloween ZOMBIE SQUIRREL Blow Mold Prop Decoration Poison Acorn USED


Vintage Fontanini Nativity Figurine - Mary #2 - 4" Scale - Replacement Figurine


Hand Crafted Christmas Nutcracker Winn Dixie 15” Wooden Excellent Sword


Instead Of Gifts I'm Giving Everyone My Opinion Ugly Christmas Sweatshirt Large


Beistle Halloween Witch Paper Diecut Cutout Vintage 1986 26"


Beistle Halloween Die Cut Decorations Lot Of 2 Vintage Textured Cutouts


Vampire Mask Rubie's Halloween Costume Fangs Pointy Ears 2010 Bald Tusks Scary


Zombie Ghostface Mask Scream 4 2010 Fun World


Fright Light Flashlight -Sound Effects Light Show W/Color Filters 2005 New


Halloween 10" Ceramic Stacked Totem JOL Pumpkin Multicolor Lighted Vampire Mummy


Lot of 12 Vintage Christmas Die Cut Decorations Eureka Trend Laminated


Team Pride Seattle Seahawks Inflatable Jack-O-Helmet Halloween Brand New


Devil Halloween Costume Mask by Seasons Chinless Horns Satan Lucifer Fangs READ


Christmas Advent Calendar 3D Vintage Denmark GEMO Santa Elves Animals


Classic Christmas VHS Movies: Scrooge & It's A Wonderful Life Boxed Set Sealed




Christmas Towel Lot of 3 Hand Washcloth Dogs Grandma Santa Claus XMAS


Vintage Christmas Cloth Napkins set 4 Holly Bells Decorative Linens Red Festive


Halloween Costume Mask Blinking Pumpkin Jack O Lantern 1996 PAPER MAGIC GROUP


Halloween Lighted Ghost Spooky Decoration 15.5x15.5" 2014


Resin/Cast Iron Stocking Holder/Hanger Santa/Elf w/Presents on Chimney Vintage


Christmas Ornament Big Bad Wolf? in Victorian Garb Outfit Hat Ruffles Sparkles


Gorham North Pole Express 5 3/4" Santa and Trees Candy Bowl Vintage Christmas


Vintage Mickey Mouse Halloween Candy Pail Bucket Pumpkin Jack O'Lantern


Halloween Bags Decorations Pad Luminaries Lot Vintage All Sealed New


Vintage Christmas Frog King & Jester Prince Harlequin Plush Shelf Sitter Dolls


Vintage Halloween Decorations Lot Cutouts & Window Clings Witch Spider Pumpkin


Hand-Painted Papier Mache Nativity Camel Laying Christmas Figurine Vintage ITALY


Department 56 Frankensteins Lab Spider Taper Candles Halloween Decor Arachnid


Ceramic Christmas Tree Filled Candle 6.3 OZ Holiday Spice Scented 7" NEW SEALED


Vintage Godinger Silver Art Co. Wrapped Presents Salt & Pepper Shakers Christmas


About us

We're passionate about finding and sharing unique treasures. Every item in our store, from vintage gems to contemporary finds, is handpicked with love for its unique story and charm, curated in the hope of finding each piece a cherished new home.
At Keepsake Keyholders, we're not just selling items; we're connecting hearts to the past and future with keepsakes that tell a story.

Join our adventure on YouTube, Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook as we navigate through our meticulously curated collection, where every item’s singular history and charm await your discovery!

Thank you for exploring with us. Your next treasure awaits.
Location: United StatesMember since: Nov 26, 2022Seller: keepsakekeyholders1
Top Rated SellerKeepsake Keyholders is one of eBay's most reputable sellers. Consistently delivers outstanding customer service Learn more

Detailed seller ratings

Average for the last 12 months

Accurate description
Reasonable shipping cost
Shipping speed

Seller feedback (780)

o***h (779)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past month
Verified purchase
Great price, condition as described, fast delivery, securely packaged, great customer service. I would buy from them again.
o***y (250)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past month
Verified purchase
Perfect! Vinyl was well packed, promptly shipped, quickly delivered, and arrived exactly as described — quite a large collection at a great price, all safe and accounted for. Thanks very much!
o***h (779)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past month
Verified purchase
Great price, condition as described, quick delivery, securely packaged. I would buy from them again.
g***y (1189)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Accurate description. Fast shipping. Excellent packaging. Good communication. Thank you.
y***l (1362)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Accurate Description, Good Communication, Shipped Quickly & Well Packaged…A+++
Reply from: keepsakekeyholders1- Feedback replied by seller keepsakekeyholders1.- Feedback replied by seller keepsakekeyholders1.
Thank you so very much for your review!
2***t (143)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Great seller! Item was exactly as described, was packaged well, and was shipped quickly. I would definitely buy from them again.