Featured categories
Newly Listed
See allAll items

US Military PASGT Army Ballistic Unicor Combat Helmet M-4
$108.99

Lot Of 13 Classic Rock Vinyl LPs Ted Nugent Badfinger Bad Company Cheap Trick
$106.99

Chemical Protective Overgarment Pants Trouser Med/L Woodland Hot Weather Camo LG
$49.99

Pewter Dragon Lantern Figure With Wick Serpent Bejeweled Winged Fantasy
$45.99

Toy Story Deluxe Cav Laserdisc Ld Movie Like New
$57.99

Lot Of 50+ Fisher Price Doll House Barbie Littlest Pet Shop Disney Accessories
$21.99

Lot of 74 Yu-Gi-Oh Cards Some foil SLEEVED Lightly Played Condition
$33.99

Lot Of 6 Todd Rundgren Vinyls LP Wizard Back To The Bars Something 33 RPM
$49.99

Lot of 18 Pre-80's Classic Action Drama Laserdiscs Walking Tall Apocalypse Now +
$97.99

Bradford Exchange Hello Kitty Purse Handbag READ
$90.99

VTG 1953 Roy Rogers Dale Evans Lunchbox & Thermos
$240.99

American Girl Doll, 2014 GOTY, Isabelle Palmer PIERCED EARS ACCESSORIES NICE
$157.99

RED DISGUISE LICENSED Sesame Street Full Plush Elmo Prestige Adult Costume XL
$63.99

Lot of 16 VINTAGE WALT DISNEY PLEASURE ISLAND MARDI GRAS COIN STILL ON CARD
$199.99

JAMES BOND 007 MARTINI ROSSI PROMO LICENCE TO KILL POSTER 19x26.5"
$125.99

Vintage Bibles Prayer Book Distressed Worn Lot of 5 Concordance Paraphrased
$25.99

Lot Of 13 Classic Rock Vinyl LPs Guess Who Bachman-Turner Overdrive Mountain
$84.99

Lot 3 Pewter On Banded Agate Dungeons Dragons Crystals Castles Warrior Figurine
$36.99

Harry Potter Professor McGonagall Deluxe Large Adult Costume Wizard Cosplay
$49.99

Build A Bear Workshop Baby Goat Bandana Exclusive 2020 Stuffed Animal 15" Plush
$34.99

Lot Of 15 Classic Rock Vinyl LPs Brampton Walsh Tangerine Dream An Anta Winter
$98.99

TOLEDO I.N.I Bayonet ET 85298B Black Green USED Military Fighting Knife EXC
$81.99

Pewter Dragons Knight Treasure Chest Horse Figurines Lot 4 + bonus dragon charm
$36.99

Lot of 16 Drama Action Laserdisc Movies LD Starman GoodFellas Scarface Bugsy +
$69.99

24 Jackie Gleason Presents Jazz 7" 45 Rpms Lonesome Echo Music Martinis Memories
$49.99

William Barry Coat Men 42 Brown Faux Fur Lined Heavy Corduroy Grandpa VTG 70s
$67.99

VTG IJRA 1ST PLACE IOWA JUNIOR RODEO ROPING CHAMPIONS TROPHY BELT BUCKLE-COWBOY
$72.99

8 New Age Lot Vinyl LPs Shadowfax Ackerman Verdeaux DeGrassi Winston Emerald
$34.99

Mid century Modern Florida House Floor Plans Blue Prints 1977 One Story Original
$81.99

Dragonsite 2006 DUSK Fairy Riding Raven Figurine Shelia Wolk 8.75 (Need Repair)
$90.99

13 Classic Rock Rockabilly Records Vinyl LPs Orbison Frampton Mitch Ryder
$58.99

Dragonsite Nene Thomas Dragon Moon 10" Figurine Retired NT141 Read
$98.99

Magic The Gathering Lot Of 450+ Cards 45 Rare 69 Uncommon See Photos MTG
$55.99

Army Cargo Pants Medium Regular Green Woodland Camo Trouser Combat 32x29 lot 2
$49.99

World War 2 Scrapbook Honolulu July 1940 Dec 1941 USS Raleigh Pearl Harbor WW2
$279.99

George Washington A Biography Douglass Freeman ~ 5 (of 7) volume set ~ HB
$249.99

40 Jazz 45 Rpms 7" George Shearing Kai Winding Hi-los Garner Bill Snyder Promo
$49.99

Tales from the Crypt Crypt Keeper Mask Halloween Costume Horror Adult
$54.99

mcdonalds happy meal box & Bag lot of 13 Animaniacs Sleeping Beauty Hercules
$15.99

Lot of 4 xbox 360 games Assassin's Creed Black Flag Call Of Duty Modern Warfare
$25.99

Bergamot Brass Works Native American Indian Chief Head Belt Buckle Pewter USA
$35.99

Lot Of 10 Ten Inch Records 33 LPs Microgrooves Roy Rogers Show Boat Deep River
$25.99

34 World Music Album Vinyl Records Lps Irish Japanese Chinese Latin Celtic Italy
$44.99

Lot 104 Boy Scout Patches Vintage 1960-2005 Camporee Occoneechee Nassau FL 1LB
$216.99

Progpower USA 3 III CD Symphony X, Blind Guardian, Nemesis Strange Land New Prog
$17.99

Leg Avenue Lot 4 Red Nylon Sheer Thigh Highs With Lace Top Size 90-165lb New
$27.99

40 Jazz 45 Rpms 7" Doris Day Duke Ellington Ramsey Lewis Al Hirt Big Band Promo
$49.99

SLIM WHITMAN AMERICA'S FAVORITE FOLK ARTIST Rare 10 INCH Red Vinyl
$252.99
About us
We're passionate about finding and sharing unique treasures. Every item in our store, from vintage gems to contemporary finds, is handpicked with love for its unique story and charm, curated in the hope of finding each piece a cherished new home.
At Keepsake Keyholders, we're not just selling items; we're connecting hearts to the past and future with keepsakes that tell a story.
Join our adventure on YouTube, Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook as we navigate through our meticulously curated collection, where every item’s singular history and charm await your discovery!
Thank you for exploring with us. Your next treasure awaits.
At Keepsake Keyholders, we're not just selling items; we're connecting hearts to the past and future with keepsakes that tell a story.
Join our adventure on YouTube, Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook as we navigate through our meticulously curated collection, where every item’s singular history and charm await your discovery!
Thank you for exploring with us. Your next treasure awaits.
Seller feedback (1,554)
- 0***a (73)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchasePerfect Packaging! Lightning speed delivery Time. As Described nothing missing even the used ones are clean and packaged. Great Value, Great customer service. cannot give this seller enough stars.A++++++++
- 6***2 (79)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseThe way that the stuffed was packaged great and taken of it and it was just as it was described about the cases and such a great price for the cases. The only problem was I had to wait a bit longer then what I was told but the shipping of the stuff was still great.
- s***p (51)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchasePackage arrived surprisingly quickly. The video tapes’ conditions are as described, as well. Overall, it was a very good value for the amount of tapes. Would recommend seller to others 👍
- 1***f (326)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchasePROFESSIONAL Seller ---- EXCELLENT Communication - FAST Shipping - Expertly Packed And Arrived UNDAMAGED - Item EXACTLY As Described - VERY SATISFIED Buyer - Thanks! - A+++
- c***d (248)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseArrived as described! Excellent price and value! Amply packed & shipped fast! A+ seller
- _***c (3562)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseFast shipping! Safely packaged! As described! Excellent seller!