Featured categories
Newly Listed
See allAll items

RED DISGUISE LICENSED Sesame Street Full Plush Elmo Prestige Adult Costume XL
$63.99

Lot of 18 Pre-80's Classic Action Drama Laserdiscs Walking Tall Apocalypse Now +
$97.99

Tales from the Crypt Crypt Keeper Mask Halloween Costume Horror Adult
$54.99

Lot of 20 Drama Action Laserdisc Movies Chinatown Midnight Express Failsafe
$69.99

Dragonsite 2006 DUSK Fairy Riding Raven Figurine Shelia Wolk 8.75 (Need Repair)
$90.99

Bergamot Brass Works Native American Indian Chief Head Belt Buckle Pewter USA
$35.99

Julie Albright 18" American Girl Doll First Edition Retired Meet Outfit Casual
$117.99

Lot of 16 VINTAGE WALT DISNEY PLEASURE ISLAND MARDI GRAS COIN STILL ON CARD
$199.99

Stampin Up Lot Set of 50 Birthday Christmas & More Scrapbook
$162.99

Toy Story Deluxe Cav Laserdisc Ld Movie Like New
$57.99

100 Israel Slides Middle East Holy Land Palestine Christian Judaism Photographs
$36.99

American Girl Doll, 2014 GOTY, Isabelle Palmer PIERCED EARS ACCESSORIES NICE
$157.99

VTG Victoria Jones Womens Halloween Ugly Sweater Vest Orange Black Cats M READ
$28.99

COLLECTIBLE The Enchanted Art of Jessica Galbreth Hekate NIB
$180.99

Godfather Trilogy, The - 1901-1980 (VHS, 1992, 6-Tape Set)
$7.99

43 BOX SET LOT DVD TV Series Lost Nip/Tuck Monk Supernatural House AHS ROME READ
$51.99

Vintage Bibles Prayer Book Distressed Worn Lot of 5 Concordance Paraphrased
$27.99

Action Drama Movie Soundtrack CD lot of 77 Batman Escape From LA Kids Hitchcock
$106.99

Harry Potter Professor McGonagall Deluxe Large Adult Costume Wizard Cosplay
$49.99

Lot of 8 Drama Comedies Laserdisc Movies Risky Business Radioland Murders
$36.99

Mid century Modern Florida House Floor Plans Blue Prints 1977 One Story Original
$81.99

Lot of 16 Drama Action Laserdisc Movies LD Starman GoodFellas Scarface Bugsy +
$69.99

8 Classic Literature Books Moby Dick Washington Irvin Hemingway Hawthorne
$54.99

Lot Of 2 Photo Albums 100 Magnetic Pages Vintage Sealed New
$30.99

Lancome Tresor Perfume, Body Lotion & Foaming Bath Gel 3.4 oz Bottles READ
$85.99

Rand McNally Encyclopaedia & Atlas of the World illustrated 1899 RARE Vol 1-2
$324.99

Rodgers & Hart Song Book Sheet Music Lot 1st Printing 1951
$27.99

Barbie Beachin' It With My BFF Barbie & Teresa Doll Set in Tote Bag 2010 Mattel
$61.99

TOLEDO I.N.I Bayonet ET 85298B Black Green USED Military Fighting Knife EXC
$81.99

Leg Avenue Sexy Vinyl Plunging Lace Up Mini Halter Dress Large NWT New
$31.99

ALLEN DESIGN WALL CLOCK P1654 "BLUE CRAB" CRABE BLEU
$81.99

34 Mainstream Radio & Urban Promo Only CDs Hip Hop Rap Pop 2003-04 2006-7 READ
$162.99

VTG 1953 Roy Rogers Dale Evans Lunchbox & Thermos
$266.99

Leg Avenue Lot White Satin Gloves Fishnet Spandex Thigh Highs & Tights New Sexy
$27.99

Lot of 11 WALT DISNEY WORLD 20 YEARS PLASTIC LUGGAGE TAGS WITH PAPER INSERTS NEW
$110.99

Brass Mouse Receipt Holder Long Tail Vintage
$14.99

Lot 104 Boy Scout Patches Vintage 1960-2005 Camporee Occoneechee Nassau FL 1LB
$216.99

Lot of 4 American History Books Symbols Landmarks & People National Geographic
$13.99

US Military PASGT Army Ballistic Unicor Combat Helmet M-4
$119.99

Leg Avenue Lot 4 Red Nylon Sheer Thigh Highs With Lace Top Size 90-165lb New
$27.99

Macaulay's History of England First Edition 1887 Complete Set Very Good Vol. I-V
$182.99

40+ Pieces Of Costume Jewelry Bracelets Rings Hair Clips Pendants Vintage
$45.99

Lot of 11 john Cleese Monty Python Comedy Laserdiscs Life of Brian Holy Grail +
$90.99

Lot 9 Stand-up TV Comedy Laserdisc George Carlin Ed Sullivan Richard Pryor +
$81.99

Field Mouse Needlepoint Finished Cute 80's Cottagecore Farmhouse Decor
$41.99

Rock Music Song Book Lot Beatles Eagles Springsteen Crosby Stills Golden Sheet
$49.99

Poems of Childhood by Eugene Field-1st Edition 1904 Antique Book
$63.99

George Washington A Biography Douglass Freeman ~ 5 (of 7) volume set ~ HB
$249.99
About us
We're passionate about finding and sharing unique treasures. Every item in our store, from vintage gems to contemporary finds, is handpicked with love for its unique story and charm, curated in the hope of finding each piece a cherished new home.
At Keepsake Keyholders, we're not just selling items; we're connecting hearts to the past and future with keepsakes that tell a story.
Join our adventure on YouTube, Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook as we navigate through our meticulously curated collection, where every item’s singular history and charm await your discovery!
Thank you for exploring with us. Your next treasure awaits.
At Keepsake Keyholders, we're not just selling items; we're connecting hearts to the past and future with keepsakes that tell a story.
Join our adventure on YouTube, Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook as we navigate through our meticulously curated collection, where every item’s singular history and charm await your discovery!
Thank you for exploring with us. Your next treasure awaits.
Seller feedback (1,528)
- 6***2 (67)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseThe way that the stuffed was packaged great and taken of it and it was just as it was described about the cases and such a great price for the cases. The only problem was I had to wait a bit longer then what I was told but the shipping of the stuff was still great.
- 0***a (73)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchasePerfect Packaging! Lightning speed delivery Time. As Described nothing missing even the used ones are clean and packaged. Great Value, Great customer service. cannot give this seller enough stars.A++++++++
- 1***f (325)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchasePROFESSIONAL Seller ---- EXCELLENT Communication - FAST Shipping - Expertly Packed And Arrived UNDAMAGED - Item EXACTLY As Described - VERY SATISFIED Buyer - Thanks! - A+++
- c***d (247)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseArrived as described! Excellent price and value! Amply packed & shipped fast! A+ seller
- a***a (126)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseSuper pleased with purchase. One of my favorite albums of all time and the sound is even better on vinyl. Item arrived quickly and exactly as described l. Very well packaged and I can’t complain about the price either.
- a***o (1398)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseFast shipping, seller mailed out my orders quickly & didn't make me wait forever, my orders were well packed, seller was professional, 5-Star seller!!! 😄