Featured categories
Newly Listed
See allAll items

Trio Cubain Weeno Bravo Gody Son De Loma El Boyero 78 Record Columbia 4623
$61.99

Lot of 3 Willie Nelson LP Records Vinyl LSP-3418 KC-33482 SUM-1138 Tested Clean
$49.99

GREENVILLE HIGH SCHOOL THE NAUTILUS YEARBOOK 1935 SOUTH CAROLINA ANNUAL
$21.99

Saponificio Artigianale Fiorentino ~ Fresh Lemon Bar Soap 10.5 oz New
$17.99

Johnny Lightning lot of 3 the challengers new Sealed Limited Edition
$13.99

2004 Stanley Cup Finals Game 1 Tix Holder Lanyard & Clacker Tampa Bay Lightning
$11.99

Vans Women's Tie Dye Slip On Shoes Size 6.5 Excellent Used Condition
$23.99

Passion Play Postcard Full Set South Dakota Black Hills Lake Whales FL Jesus
$15.99

James Brown Gittin' A Little Hipper Part Two 45 King 45-6275 Excellent
$11.99

DON WILLIAMS "IT MUST BE LOVE" "NOT A CHANCE" VINYL 45 MCA EX
$10.99

Johnny Broderick sitting Cow / I'm teaching my doll to dance dance king 45 EX
$10.99

Madewell 10” High Rise Skinny Jeans size 25 Pre-Owned
$10.99

Vintage Fontanini Nativity Figurine - Mary #2 - 4" Scale - Replacement Figurine
$11.99

Barbie Beachin' It With My BFF Barbie & Teresa Doll Set in Tote Bag 2010 Mattel
$49.5920% off

The Beatles 1967 - 1970 SKBO 3404 Brand New Sealed Gatefold Compilation Mint M M
$85.5920% off

Yvonne Gage Garden of Eve/Tonight RFC Atlantic 12" Vinyl Single 012925WR Promo
$23.9920% off

RED DISGUISE LICENSED Sesame Street Full Plush Elmo Prestige Adult Costume XL
$55.9920% off

American Girl Historical Doll Kit Kittredge 1st Edition Meet Outfit PLS READ
$51.1920% off

12 Electronic EDM Vinyls EPs 12" House Trance Techno Freeform Five Resistence
$39.9920% off

Mattel Apples to Apples Party in a Box Card Game New And Sealed
$11.99

Fabletics - 7" The One Short Men's Size S Black - New NWT Zipper Pocket Shorts
$39.9920% off

US Military PASGT Army Ballistic Unicor Combat Helmet M-4
$95.9920% off

Lot 20 Disney Live Action Laserdisc Shaggy D.A. Pete's Dragon Mary Poppins +
$108.7920% off

Vintage 90s Chalk Line NFL Tampa Bay Buccaneers Orange BUCS Jacket Adult XL
$126.3920% off

Guy Clark Old No 1 vinyl 1975 record lp VG+ condition RCA original Tested
$47.9920% off

Disney cats pin Cheshire Cat Dinah Figaro Marie Duchess O'Malley Si Am HTF RARE
$58.3920% off

George Washington A Biography Douglass Freeman ~ 5 (of 7) volume set ~ HB
$199.9920% off

12 EDM Electronic Vinyls 12" EPs House Trance Techno Evol-D Delicious Music
$39.9920% off

GUY CLARK - Self Titled BSK 3241 Country Folk Blues Lp - EX Tested
$27.9920% off

HERBIE HANCOCK Maiden Voyage LP BLUE NOTE BST 84195 US 1966 NY Freddie Hubbard
$111.9920% off

COLLECTIBLE The Enchanted Art of Jessica Galbreth Hekate NIB
$159.9920% off

Knickerbocker Gorilla 24" Plush Stuffed Vintage Ape Leash Pink Black Rare HTF
$98.3920% off

34 Mainstream Radio & Urban Promo Only CDs Hip Hop Rap Pop 2003-04 2006-7 READ
$130.3920% off

Lot Of 50+ Fisher Price Doll House Barbie Littlest Pet Shop Disney Accessories
$19.1920% off

Dragonsite Nene Thomas Dragon Moon 10" Figurine Retired NT141 Read
$87.1920% off

Lot of 74 Yu-Gi-Oh Cards Some foil SLEEVED Lightly Played Condition
$29.5920% off

The Book of Job Arthur Szyk In our Image KJV Illustrated Biblical Texts HCDJSC
$27.1920% off

Scream Magazine Lot Of 8 Issues 33 47 48 49 50 51 52 59 Dawn Of The Dead Horror
$51.1920% off

40+ Pieces Of Costume Jewelry Bracelets Rings Hair Clips Pendants Vintage
$39.9920% off

Simpsons Bart Vs The Space Mutants Krusty's Fun House Nintendo NES Tested Clean
$31.9920% off

Vintage Bibles Prayer Book Distressed Worn Lot of 5 Concordance Paraphrased
$22.3920% off

237 Paris Italy Slides Europe World's Fair 1958 Vacation
$87.1920% off

12 Electronic EDM 12" Vinyls EPs House Trance Techno Louis Q Trans Motion DJ Q
$39.9920% off

11 Heavy Metal '80s Rock CDs Poison Ozzy Dio Skid Row Metallica Def Leppard Read
$36.7920% off

Formula One: Built to Win (Nintendo Entertainment System, 1990) NES Tested
$47.9920% off

40+ Classic Rock 45s RPM 70s 80s Def Leppard Kiss Styx Queen America Sweet Petty
$55.9920% off

Mid century Modern Florida House Floor Plans Blue Prints 1977 One Story Original
$65.5920% off

Heissner Gnome Terra Cotta Pottery Statue Garden Art West Germany 13” Vintage
$98.3920% off
About us
We're passionate about finding and sharing unique treasures. Every item in our store, from vintage gems to contemporary finds, is handpicked with love for its unique story and charm, curated in the hope of finding each piece a cherished new home.
At Keepsake Keyholders, we're not just selling items; we're connecting hearts to the past and future with keepsakes that tell a story.
Join our adventure on YouTube, Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook as we navigate through our meticulously curated collection, where every item’s singular history and charm await your discovery!
Thank you for exploring with us. Your next treasure awaits.
At Keepsake Keyholders, we're not just selling items; we're connecting hearts to the past and future with keepsakes that tell a story.
Join our adventure on YouTube, Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook as we navigate through our meticulously curated collection, where every item’s singular history and charm await your discovery!
Thank you for exploring with us. Your next treasure awaits.
Seller feedback (1,453)
- s***f (423)- Feedback left by buyer.Past yearVerified purchaseThe item was exactly as described, and difintly a fair price, super fast delivery and well packaged, great communication, I would deal with U again, recommended seller A+++
- 8***k (72)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseI feel like I paid a very fair price for what was in this train lot of misc parts and cars and parts of locomotives. Everything was as described in the pictures! It was labeled fragile on the box but it looks like the whole box was treated roughly on the transport from the seller to me and more stuff was busted up from that and I feel that the delicate items in the box should have been packaged up better than in a plastic bag in a box! For the price of this lot I’m not going to complain
- 6***2 (45)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseThe way that the stuffed was packaged great and taken of it and it was just as it was described about the cases and such a great price for the cases. The only problem was I had to wait a bit longer then what I was told but the shipping of the stuff was still great.
- n***o (98)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseExcellent condition brand new and sealed as listed. Very happy with transaction and arrived safely with no damage to item case. Thank you for the flawless transaction. Very happy with experience. God Bless.
- r***6 (3)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseThe books were as described. Shipping took place in was a reasonable time. I feel very fortunate to find and purchase these volumes in their original packaging box. They are of great value to me!
- 8***3 (84)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchase2019 Heavy Metal Magazine #297 VF Winter Special Cover B. Item was as described in the listing; Like New. Was packed really well and shipping was fast. Good prices as well.