Skip to main content
Keepsake Keyholders

Keepsake Keyholders

3.3K items sold
267 followers
Contact

Featured categories

Newly Listed

See all

  • AEROSMITH Rocks "QUADRAPHONIC" PCQ-34165 VG+/NM- VINYL LP RARE

    $71.9920% off

  • Lot of 12 Vintage Fiction Books Some Comedy/Humor Short Stories Novels READ DES.

    $108.7920% off

  • Rawlings Fuel USA Youth Baseball Bat, 28 inch (-8)

    $9.5920% off

  • E.T. The Extra Terrestrial Plush Universal Studios 11" Alien Embroidered Eyes

    $20.7920% off

  • HOMCO Cocker Spaniel Dog Statue Figurine Large 8" x 14" Resin Vintage 1986

    $22.3920% off

  • Conspiracy Theory Trivia Board Game by Neddy Games Brand New

    $14.3920% off

All items

Vintage Disney World Postcard/Photo Lot 15 Early 70's Mickey Mouse Disney Parade

$11.9920% off

Lot Of 4 Rush Vinyl Record LPs Moving Pictures World Stage Grace Under Pressure

$31.9920% off

Lot Of 70+ American Girl Our Generation OG Accessories Glasses Food Cookout

$52.7920% off

VINTAGE The Golden Dawn Tarot Robert Wang Israel Regardie 1978 + INSTRUCTIONS

$47.1920% off

Lot Of 25 90s Comedies Laserdiscs Mermaids Funny Bones Dazed Confused Spinal Tap

$51.9920% off

XULTUN TAROT Maya Deck Vintage 1976 Peter Balin Arcana Publishing Rare

$54.3920% off

Rare & Retired American Girl Doll Christmas Tree & Trimmings & Perfect Presents

$71.9920% off

Decorative Faux Books Storage Boxes Wood Felt Lined Hollow Book Hide Lot Of 3

$36.7920% off

Lot 12 Vintage Christian Theology Books, Bible Study, Prayer, Atlas, Commentary

$47.9920% off

Lot Of 14 Horror Sci Fi Laserdiscs Lifeforce Jaws Poltergeist Psycho Snatchers +

$119.9920% off

American Girl 2008 Pleasant Company Nellie O'Malley Doll Short Hair Freckles 18"

$119.9920% off

Vintage 1983 Tarot Of Transition Egyptian Tarot Cards Complete Deck + Booklet

$47.9920% off

Lot of 6 Kid Galaxy Poseable Dragon Figures Medieval Fantasy Dragons Action

$13.5920% off

Lot of 30 Rubber Stamps Christmas Santa Claus Holiday Winter Snowman Wood

$36.7920% off

Lot Of 4 Alternative Cassettes Korn Life Of Agony Gas Huffer Woodstock

$39.9920% off

Lot Of 9 Southern Rock Vinyl LPs Buffalo Springfield Outlaws Lynyrd Skynyrd

$51.9920% off

Lot Of 22 80s Comedies Laserdisc Miss Right Party Inc Miracles Raising Arizona

$79.9920% off

Lot Of 8 Time Life Rock 'N' Roll Era LPs - Double Vinyl Box Sets Excellent

$38.3920% off

NOS Vintage Neumann Tackified Receiver Football Gloves Pair Mens XL Gray KOREA

$71.9920% off

Lot Of 20 Empty Cassette Cases Pennywise Cypress Hill Offspring Sepultura

$23.9920% off

Lot Of 20 Instrumental & Classical & Opera CDs Mozart Bocelli Bernstein Giovanni

$11.9920% off

Family Blu Ray lot Of 9 Movies Pixar Disney Despicable Me Night At The Museum

$15.1920% off

Lady Gaga The Fame slotMusic Slot Music SanDisk microSD REALLY RARE PLS READ

$144.7920% off

ROMANS Volumes I II III IV (1-4) DONALD GREY BARNHOUSE EERDMANS 1977 Reprint HC

$58.3920% off

Lot of Classical Baroque Renaissance Posters Museum Quality Prints LARGE READ

$72.7920% off

Lot Of 50+ Fisher Price Doll House Barbie Littlest Pet Shop Disney Accessories

$20.7920% off

10 Yes Kansas Jethro Tull ELP Records Vinyl LPs Lot Classic Rock Aqualung

$79.9920% off

Lot Of 24 Pro Wrestling DVDs And Blu Ray WWE Indy Classic Backyard Sealed & Used

$52.7920% off

Nautica Argyle Sweater Mens Small Navy Golf Cable Knit Vintage

$18.3920% off

Vintage 90s Chalk Line NFL Tampa Bay Buccaneers Orange BUCS Jacket Adult XL

$139.9920% off

Playstation 2 PS2 Fat GT3 Box - BOX ONLY

$45.5920% off

VTG 3" METROPOLITAN MUSEUM OF ART MMA-SMI TWO PIECE CERAMIC CAT MAGNETS, ITALY

$10.3920% off

LOT 20 45s MICHAEL JACKSON/Jackson 5 4 W/ PICTURE SLEEVES PYT Beat It Thriller

$79.9920% off

Lot Of 2 Slayer Cassettes Divine Intervention Rain Of Blood Original

$43.9920% off

AMERICAN GIRL Doll Marie-Grace’s Nightgown/Slippers-Released 2011/Retired 2014

$31.9920% off

A Smart Girls Guide By American Girl 8 Book Lot Feelings Care & Keeping of You +

$23.9920% off

Black Extreme Ralph Lauren Polo Men's Gift Set Shower Gel Cologne & Travel Size

$22.3920% off

VTG Victoria Jones Womens Halloween Ugly Sweater Vest Orange Black Cats M READ

$25.5920% off

12 Classic Rock Records Vinyl LPs Bloodrock Thin Lizzy Spirit Kingfish

$57.5920% off

Space Jam Throw 1996 Blanket Trim Tapestry Fringe Movie Michael Jordan Excellent

$33.5920% off

Lot Of 2 Appalachian Cabbage Patch Baby Doll 1978-1982 Florida Pammy Koosas Lion

$31.9920% off

Lot of 7 Allman Brothers Band LP Vinyl Records Gregg Allman Marshall Tucker Band

$51.9920% off

Lot of 7 Books Dean Koontz, Paperback And Hardback: Brother Odd,Skygger,Velocity

$9.5920% off

Lot Of 10 Classic Rock Vinyl LPs Wyman Zevon Loggins Dudek REO Speedwagon

$47.9920% off

7 Cream Led Zeppelin Robert Plant Jimi Hendrix Rock Records Vinyl LPs Lots

$59.9920% off

Cuendet Music Box Fruit Stand / Tray Schwalb Swiss Folk Songs Wooden Vintage

$15.1920% off

Lot Of 14 Records Classical Country Easy Listening 33 LP Vinyl

$7.9920% off

Vintage Supermarine Spitfire MK5 Belt Buckle Belt Buckle Bergamot Brass Works

$20.7920% off
Items Per Page
See All

About us

We're passionate about finding and sharing unique treasures. Every item in our store, from vintage gems to contemporary finds, is handpicked with love for its unique story and charm, curated in the hope of finding each piece a cherished new home.
At Keepsake Keyholders, we're not just selling items; we're connecting hearts to the past and future with keepsakes that tell a story.

Join our adventure on YouTube, Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook as we navigate through our meticulously curated collection, where every item’s singular history and charm await your discovery!

Thank you for exploring with us. Your next treasure awaits.
Location: United StatesMember since: Nov 26, 2022Seller: keepsakekeyholders1
Top Rated SellerKeepsake Keyholders is one of eBay's most reputable sellers. Consistently delivers outstanding customer service Learn more

Feedback ratings

Last 12 months

Positive941- positive feedback in last 12 months
Neutral10- neutral feedback in last 12 months
Negative1- negative feedback in last 12 months

Detailed seller ratings

Average for the last 12 months
Accurate description
4.9
Reasonable shipping cost
4.8
Shipping speed
5.0
Communication
5.0

Seller feedback (1,184)

  • s***f (404)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    The item was exactly as described, and difintly a fair price, super fast delivery and well packaged, great communication, I would deal with U again, recommended seller A+++
  • d***u (2808)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    awesome 5-star service!!! lightning-fast shipping, great communication & troll exactly as pictured & packaged well! highly recommended!!!
  • e***n (436)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    My item pleasures came fast. It was very well packaged securely and Ln the exact description of the perfume. Very kind seller who will work with you. With a very special great pricefor my daughter and myself 5 🌟 🌟 🌟 🌟 🌟 thank you again. I will be purchasing from this seller again. Top notch
  • e***e (456)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past month
    Verified purchase
    Received earlier than expected, items were received with no damage, packaging was well done. Items received as expected and better. No price gouging for Shipping. Highly recommend seller to anyone. Thank you.
  • 4***e (1363)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    Saga "On the Loose" (1981) 45 rpm "PROMO" Record is in "MINT Excellent" Condition ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Label conditions on both sides in "Excellent" Condition ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Record Sleeve in "Excellent" condition ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐All as Described and Advertised ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Safe and Secure Packaging with FAST Shipment ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Excellent 5 Star Ebay Seller! 👌
  • o***j (1293)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past month
    Verified purchase
    Wow! This camera is in amazing condition! The seller was quick to answer questions, honest in their description. The item came quick and packaged perfectly. Thank you so much for passing this onto us; my son is going to love it!
See all feedback