Featured categories
Best Sellers
Newly Listed
See allAll items

Mario Tennis Open (Nintendo 3DS, 2012) CIB! W/ Manual! Works! Ships FREE!
$14.95

PING EYE Orange Dot Iron Set 5-PW True Temper Graphite Senior Flex READ!
$69.95

LEGO Pirates of the Caribbean: The Video Game (Nintendo Wii) CIB! W/ Manual!
$9.95

Avatar: The Last Airbender (Nintendo GameCube, 2006) CIB! W/ Manual! MINT!
$14.29

PING PAL 2 Putter Karsten Mfg Corp Phoenix Box 85068 Original RH Steel 35.5” ⛳️
$37.95

Phineas and Ferb: Quest for Cool Stuff (Nintendo Wii, 2013) CIB! W/ Manual! 🔥
$9.79

Nintendo Wii U Mario Kart 8 Deluxe 32GB Handheld System W/ Box! NICE!
$179.95

PING i3 Blade 3-PW,SW,LW (No 4i) IRON SET Blue Dot JZ Stiff Flex Steel RH VGC+
$179.95

Hello Kitty: Big City Dreams (Nintendo DS) CIB! W/ Manual! Works Great! Fun Game
$19.95

NIKE Method Core MC 12w Putter Excellent! 33.5” RH Rare! Super Stroke Grip!
$99.95

Xbox One 500 GB Black Console Bundle OEM Controller HDMI Power Works!
$99.95

How to Train Your Dragon 2 (Nintendo Wii, 2014) CIB! W/ Manual! MINT Disc! Works
$12.79

WWE SmackDown vs. Raw 2010 Featuring ECW (Nintendo DS, 2009) CIB!
$12.79

Street Fighter IV (Microsoft Xbox 360, 2009) No Manual Works! Ships FREE! 🎮
$7.00

NBA Live 2005 (Sony PlayStation 2, 2004) PS2 Disc Only! Black Label! Works
$6.79

Nike “ Blue Chip” Putter BC 002 34.5” Original Shaft & Grip RH VGC! 🔥⛳️
$48.95

Sony PlayStation 3 (PS3) Backwards Compatible 80GB Controller Cables WORKS!
$329.95

Mortal Kombat: Deception (Microsoft Xbox, 2004) Disc Only! Works! Fun!!
$11.29

Mattel Intellivision Console Bundle With Games RESTORED TESTED WORKING
$119.95

Lot of 37 Sony PS2 PlayStation 2 DualShock Controllers for Repair - OEM
$129.95

The Sims 4 Plus Star Wars Journey to Batuu Bundle (Microsoft Xbox One) CIB! Nice
$7.00

Rock Band Wireless Fender Guitar Sony Playstation 3 Stratocaster W/ Strap Works!
$42.95

Remote Control (Nintendo Entertainment System, 1990) NES Works!
$8.79

Evil Dead: The Game (Sony PlayStation 4, PS4) Factory SEALED! Brand New! MINT!
$17.95

Barbie: Jet, Set & Style (Nintendo Wii, 2011) CIB! W/ Manual! MINT Disc! Works!
$8.49

Sony PlayStation 1 PS1 Slim PSone Console W/ OEM Controller Power Works!
$79.95

James Bond 007 in Agent Under Fire (Sony PlayStation 2, 2002) PA2 CIB! 🔥
$7.79

Nintendo DS Lot Disney Kid Friendly 14 Games All CIB Excellent Condition Free 📦
$89.95

Tiger Woods PGA Tour 06 (Nintendo GameCube, 2005) CIB! W/ Manual! Works! Fun!!
$9.49

Karsten PING Cushin Putter Bronze / Copper Sound Slot Phoenix 85029 RH Steel
$36.95

Sonic & Sega All-Stars Racing With Banjo-Kazooie (Microsoft Xbox 360) SEALED!
$24.79

Rayman Raving Rabbids (Nintendo Wii, 2006) CIB! W/ Manual! MINT Disc! Works!
$9.49

TaylorMade SuperSteel Burner Iron Set 3-5i S-90 Bubble Shaft VGC++ Excellent!
$49.95

New Super Luigi U (Nintendo Wii U, 2013) Disc Only! Works Great! Fun Game! 🔥
$12.79

Sunset Overdrive -- Day One Edition (Microsoft Xbox One, 2014) Works Great!
$8.29

MLB 08: The Show (Sony PlayStation 2, 2008) PS2 CIB! W/ Manual! Complete! 🔥
$6.00

Marvel: Ultimate Alliance 2 (Nintendo Wii, 2009) Disc Only! Works Great! MINT!
$9.79

Xbox One Halo 5: Guardians Limited Edition 1TB Console New Laser Tested Works!
$139.95

Grand Theft Auto V (Xbox One, 2014) Disc Only! Works Great! Ships FREE!
$9.95

Air Conflicts Vietnam (Microsoft Xbox 360) No Manual MINT Disc! Works! Fun!
$11.95

PING Karsten I Iron Set 3-SW Black Dot Factory Heel-Toe Balance Steel R-Flex VGC
$119.95

Dr. Mario (Nintendo NES, 1990) Cartridge Only! Tested - WORKS! W/ Case! Free 📦!
$11.29

Xbox One 1TB Forza Limited Edition Console Bundle OEM Controller HDMI Works!
$119.95

Pokemon Stadium (Nintendo 64, 2000) N64 Authentic Tested Free 📦 🎮
$27.95

Callaway Steelhead X-14 8-Iron 8i Constant Weight Steel Regular Flex RH 🔥⛳️
$32.95

FIFA 22 (Microsoft Xbox One, Series X) XB1 Disc Only! MINT! Works Great! 🔥
$7.49

Backyard Football '10 (Nintendo Wii, 2009) Disc Only! Works Great! MINT!
$7.00

SeeMore Si2 Putter 34” Right Handed New Karma Big Softy Grip Excellent! 🔥
$82.95
About us
You never know what you will find and everything I sell ships completely free for the buyer! We specialize in Video Games and Golf Equipment. We are located in North Orange County, California and are an online only marketplace. We do our very best for our customers and always try to provide the best service possible. We try to list new items almost daily.
You just might find your personal NEEDLE IN A HAYSTACK!
You just might find your personal NEEDLE IN A HAYSTACK!
Seller feedback (14,850)
- 1***y (44)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseThe package shipped quickly and arrived on time, and was well packaged to protect the quality of the game and disk. It arrived in good condition as described, and a got it for a bit under market value, too, which is great. I would consider ordering from this store again. 10/10 seller, keep it up!Reply from: haystackthrift- Feedback replied by seller haystackthrift.- Feedback replied by seller haystackthrift.Sincerely appreciate your kind feedback! Thank you for shopping with us at HaystackThrift! ENJOY and have a wonderful day!
- 1***a (386)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseGreat communication, packaged securely, item matched the description, and arrived on time. Not much else to say. Great seller. Highly recommend. I will be buying from them again.Reply from: haystackthrift- Feedback replied by seller haystackthrift.- Feedback replied by seller haystackthrift.Sincerely appreciate your kind feedback! Thank you for shopping with us at HaystackThrift! ENJOY and have a wonderful day!
- n***n (41)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseItem arrived very well packaged and exactly as advertised! Shipped out quickly. Reached out to seller and they responded quickly and helped me out. A+ seller!Reply from: haystackthrift- Feedback replied by seller haystackthrift.- Feedback replied by seller haystackthrift.Sincerely appreciate your kind feedback! Thank you for shopping with us at HaystackThrift! ENJOY and have a wonderful day!
- _***_ (277)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseWow, amazing super-fast lightning shipping!!! Perfect item description. Good packaging and great price. Recommended seller AAA+++!!!Reply from: haystackthrift- Feedback replied by seller haystackthrift.- Feedback replied by seller haystackthrift.Sincerely appreciate your kind feedback! Thank you for shopping with us at HaystackThrift! ENJOY and have a wonderful day!
- 7***7 (1)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchasegreat seller, very responsive, item as promised, and very well packed and with fast shipping. Great pricing and value as wellReply from: haystackthrift- Feedback replied by seller haystackthrift.- Feedback replied by seller haystackthrift.Sincerely appreciate your kind feedback! Thank you for shopping with us at HaystackThrift! ENJOY and have a wonderful day!
- r***r (1535)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseA+ Seller. Item as described. Packaged well, great communication and fast shipping. Thank you!Reply from: haystackthrift- Feedback replied by seller haystackthrift.- Feedback replied by seller haystackthrift.Appreciate the kind feedback and thank you very much for your purchase! We strive to make every customer experience a positive one at Haystack Thrift! Happy New Year! Cheers to 2025!