1.2K items sold
46 followers
Contact

New Cards added daily!

Shop our baseball cards, we ship daily!

New Cards added daily!

All items

Latico Leather Toiletry Bag

$59.99

Cthulhu Necronomicon A5 Journal Notebook Brand New

$14.9925% offSave up to 20% when you buy more

Goth Winter SKELETON HAND BONE GLOVES Black/White Stretch Knit ADULT Unisex

$12.99Save up to 20% when you buy more

Stan Getz/Charlie Byrd - Jazz Samba Verve V6-8432 LP Vinyl Record USED TESTED

$14.9925% off

Fingerless Skeleton Gloves Black and Green Brand News

$10.99

Metropolitan Opera Season 1984-1985 Second Century Program

$11.9925% off

Vintage Knight Shoe HornPlastic Made in Japan Used

$14.9925% off

Nike Force Mike Trout 9 Keystone Baseball Cleats Pre-Owned Size 2Y Pre-Owned

$18.7425% off

Batman Logo Purse Wristlet Pocketbook LootCrate Bioworld

$18.7425% off

Pokemon Houndoom 133/197 Sv03: Obsidian Flames Regular

$0.99

Pokemon Altaria 160/197 Sv03: Obsidian Flames Regular

$0.99

MARVEL Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 Star Lord Walkman Mini MP3 Player Boombox

$74.99

Highlights From Tosca By Puccini Used Vinyl Fully Tested

$11.2425% off

Pokemon Carvanha 046/197 Sv03: Obsidian Flames Regular

$0.99

Quagsire - New 2025 McDonalds Happy Meal Pokémon Dragon Discovery Card 007/015

$3.99

Pokemon Dolliv 020/197 Sv03: Obsidian Flames Regular

$0.99

Pokemon Surskit 006/197 Obsidian Flames Regular

$0.99

Pokemon Numel 031/197 Sv03: Obsidian Flames Regular

$0.99

Pokemon Magnezone 065/197 Sv03: Obsidian Flames Regular

$0.99

Guitar Effect Pedal Footswitch Toppers Set of 10 Green Brand New

$12.99

Jerome Robbins West Side Story Record Album LP Columbia Records Used Tested

$18.7425% off

Pokemon Tympole 050/197 Sv03: Obsidian Flames Regular

$0.99

Greta Van Fleet The Battle At Gardens Gate Target Exclusive Green Vinyl 2LP NEW

$67.4925% off

Pokemon Bronzor 144/197 Sv03: Obsidian Flames Regular Uncommon

$0.99

Pokemon Obsidian Flames Volcarona 041/197 Sv03: Obsidian Flames Regular

$0.99

Beethoven Symphony No. 7 In A Major William Steinberg USED FULLY TESTED

$11.2425% off

Mozart 10 Opera Overtures & Opera for Violin Cassette Tapes USED

$9.7425% off

My Favorite Mozart Volume One Istvan Kertesz Vinyl Used Fully Tested

$17.9940% off

Carmen, (LM-6102) RCA Victor Red Seal 3 LP BOX SET & BOOKLET. 1955 Tested

$23.9940% off

JHS Good Vibrations Chorus Vibrato Pedal

$199.99

Beverly Sills The Three Queens & Scenes and Arias Cassettes Set of 2 USED

$9.7425% off

SAINT-SAENS-SAMSON ET DALILA-ORIGINAL ANGEL RECORDS 3-LP VINYL BOX SET-USED

$17.9940% off

Johnny Winter - Still Alive And Well LP Vinyl Record 1973 Used Fully Tested

$14.9925% off

Richard Rodgers Victory At Sea Vinyl RCA Victor Red Seal Used Fully Tested

$11.2425% off

Brahms Symphony No. 1 Toscanini Vinyl RCA Victor Red Seal Used Fully Tested

$14.9925% off

Pokemon Gloom 002/197 Sv03: Obsidian Flames Regular

$1.50

Opera Series Verdi Il Trovatore 2 Cassette Set USED Leontyne Price

$9.7425% off

Joan Sutherland Kleinhans Music Hall Program January 25, 1977

$11.9925% off

Pokémon Umbreon Promo Card 009/015 2025 McDonald’s Dragon Discovery M24EN

$3.99

Beethoven Symphony 9 Symphony No 8 Grand Prix Du Disque Used Fully Tested

$17.9940% off

Lot of 10 Vintage Opera News Magazines 1959 Lot 99

$18.7425% off

5 Maria Callas Cassette Tapes USED

$14.9925% off

VANS Off The Wall Peanuts 2017 Charlie Brown Snoopy Toddler Shoes Size 6.5 USED

$16.4925% off

Wagner The Ring Of The Nibelung 2LP Opera Box Set Used Fully Tested

$18.7425% off

Gather Hymnal Choir Edition 1988 GIA Hardcover Used

$10.99

JOHNNY WINTER Second Winter COLUMBIA 2 Vinyl Set Used Fully Tested

$16.4925% off

Introduction to Der Ring Des Nibelungen 3 LP Box Set Used Fully Tested

$23.9940% off

Harley Davidson Hat Red With Flames Baseball Cap Adjustable Fit USED

$11.2425% off

About us

Vintage Gotham celebrates the gift of giving for all occasions. Feel free to reach out to us if you are looking for something in particular. It would be our pleasure to help you.
Location: United StatesMember since: Jul 11, 2011Seller: vintagegotham

Detailed seller ratings

Average for the last 12 months
Accurate description
4.9
Reasonable shipping cost
5.0
Shipping speed
4.9
Communication
4.9

Seller feedback (497)

  • l***a (85)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past month
    Verified purchase
    ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ The seller was incredible! He replied to messages promptly, shipped quick and the package arrived 5 days ahead of schedule! He also took time to create a custom listing for the cards our family really wanted! Will definitely buy again, thank you so much!
  • 7***t (19)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    Excellent communications, really super amazing packaging, item just as described, highly recommend this vendor.
  • i***i (246)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    A+++++ seller!! Fantastic item, just as described. The record, even though vintage, is in excellent condition and plays beautifully. Expertly packaged and with a friendly note to boot! I would absolutely buy from this seller again. Buy or bid with confidence!!
  • s***n (448)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past month
    Verified purchase
    AAA+ eBay seller with great prices & fast shipping
  • o***s (1100)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past month
    Verified purchase
    Excelente mercancía buena calidad ajusto perfectamente, exactamente como lo describió, buen precio, rápido envío, muy feliz con la compra
  • a***e (10)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    The items were in really good condition, exactly what I was hoping for. The package arrived before I was supposed to get it, and it was wrapped nicely with an handwritten thank you note! I can’t say enough good things about this seller!