Skip to main content
Cooperstown Legends

Cooperstown Legends

2.6K items sold
169 followers
Contact

Featured categories

Auctions ending soon

See all

  • 1966 Topps #288 1966 Rookie Stars Don Sutton/ Bill Singer Dodgers. HOF ROOKIE!!!

    $4.254 bids3d 6h 43m

  • 1989 Topps John Smoltz autographed card Dual PSA Graded 8/9. HOF

    $16.505 bids3d 6h 46m

  • 1979 Topps #586 Bob Horner Signed Rookie Card PSA Authenticated & Graded 10 ROY

    $20.103 bids3d 6h 49m

  • 1988 Pacific Legends #53 Frank Torre Autographed Card Dual PSA 9/10 POP 1. RARE

    $9.990 bids6d 7h 3m

  • Autographed 2006 Topps #23 Wade Boggs Dual PSA Graded 9/10 retro Rookie card

    $11.502 bids6d 7h 3m

  • 1990 Pacific Legends #21 Bobby Doerr Autographed Card Dual PSA 9/9 POP 1. RARE

    $9.990 bids6d 7h 3m

Featured items

  • Derek Jeter HOF 2021 Topps NOW Induction Day Card 23 of 49. Dual PSA 9/9. POP 1

    $899.00

  • Whitey Ford Signed Living Legends Ron Lewis 8x10 with JSA

    $75.00

Top Picks

  • Pete Alonso Signed Topps NOW 772C Dual PSA Graded card 10/10. RARE!! POP 1

    $650.00

  • 2000 Fleer Greats Retrospection autographed Brooks Robinson Dual PSA 10/10 POP 1

    $275.00

  • Robin Roberts Signed 1950 Phillies M&N STAT Jersey. 1950 WHIZ KIDs. HOF. PSA

    $1,300.00

Check out the Bargain Bin!!

All PSA Graded Items under $10.

Shop now
Check out the Bargain Bin!!

All items

1966 Topps #288 1966 Rookie Stars Don Sutton/ Bill Singer Dodgers. HOF ROOKIE!!!

$4.254 bids3d 6h 43m

1988 Pacific Legends #53 Frank Torre Autographed Card Dual PSA 9/10 POP 1. RARE

$9.990 bids6d 7h 3m

1970 Philadelphia Philles Old Timer's Game Program Signed by 38 with 3 HOFers

$199.99

1989 Topps John Smoltz autographed card Dual PSA Graded 8/9. HOF

$16.505 bids3d 6h 46m

Autographed 2006 Topps #23 Wade Boggs Dual PSA Graded 9/10 retro Rookie card

$11.502 bids6d 7h 3m

1979 Topps #586 Bob Horner Signed Rookie Card PSA Authenticated & Graded 10 ROY

$20.103 bids3d 6h 49m

1983 Sports Illustrated Magazine signed by Tom Seaver. PSA

$199.99

1990 Pacific Legends #21 Bobby Doerr Autographed Card Dual PSA 9/9 POP 1. RARE

$9.990 bids6d 7h 3m

1982 Topps Lee Smith Dual PSA Graded 8/9 Rookie card. LOW POP!

$75.00

1969 Topps #587 Joe Rudi Autographed Rookie Card PSA Authenticated 10. LOW POP

$85.00

1983 Sports Illustrated Magazine signed by Steve Carlton."HOF 94"

$99.99

1995 Utica Blue Sox Program signed by Richie Ashburn. HOF

$69.99

1972 Topps #198 Charlie Hough Autographed Rookie Card Dual PSA Graded 5/10 RARE

$100.00

Autographed 1983 Topps #280 Bert Blyleven card Dual PSA 10/10 Gem Mint. POP 1

$275.00

1983 Jimmy Fund Program signed by HOF Greats Mantle DiMaggio Williams Mays JSA

$999.99

1985 HOF Induction Brock, Wilhelm, Slaughter signed program JSA

$85.00

1953 "Sport" Magazine signed by Bobby Shantz. 8x Gold Glove. 1952 AL MVP

$49.99

1989 Topps #654 Autographed Whitey Herzog Card. NM+ HOF

$15.50

1998 HOF Induction Sutton, McPhail & Doby signed program JSA

$100.00

1982 HOF Induction F. Robinson & Joe DiMaggio signed program

$150.00

1980 Baseball Immortals #144 Whitey Ford Autographed Card PSA . HOF

$125.00

1979 Topps Leading Firemen Gossage / Fingers autographed Card Dual PSA 9/10 RARE

$350.00

1980 Topps #140 Autographed Goose Gossage Card. NM+ HOF

$19.50

Autographed 1989 Topps #647 Randy Johnson Dual PSA Graded 7/9 Rookie card

$150.00

1950 "Sport" Magazine signed by Tommy Henrich. 6x WS Champ. Yankees Legend

$99.99

1981 Sports Illustrated Magazine signed by Dave Winfield. HOF 2001. No label

$199.99

2010 Sports Illustrated Magazine signed by David Price. CY Young. No label

$99.99

Jeff Kent Signed Los Angeles Dodgers Jersey. HOF.

$350.00

1985 Topps #23 Autographed Bret Saberhagen Rookie Card. Dual PSA 7/10. POP 5

$65.00

Autographed Larry Jansen business card. NM

$15.00

1975 "Sport" Magazine signed by Billy Martin.

$299.99

1987 Topps #170 Bo Jackson autographed card Dual PSA Graded 9/9. RARE! POP 32

$275.00

1994 HOF Induction Carlton & Rizzuto signed program JSA

$85.00

Autographed 1983 Topps #83 Ryne Sandberg Dual PSA Graded 8/10 Rookie card.

$250.00

1953 "Sport" Magazine signed by Robin Roberts. HOF 76. JSA

$99.99

Autographed 2001 Fleer GOTG Lou Brock Dual PSA Graded 10/10 card. POP 2

$250.00

1952 "Sport" Magazine signed by Gil McDougald. 1951 AL ROY. 5x WS Champ

$99.99

Warren Spahn Signed Living Legends Ron Lewis 8x10 with JSA

$50.00

Yankee Magazine VOL.18 NO2 signed by Joe Girardi. No Label. Jeter Poster Inside

$99.99

Robin Roberts Signed & Inscribed "5/28/56" 1956 Time Magazine Reprint 11x14 PSA

$40.00

Travis d'Arnaud Game Used Game Winning Home Run Signed Rays Home Jersey

$599.00

2021 Topps Project70® Card 468 - 1999 Wade Boggs Dual PSA Graded 10/8. POP 2

$100.00

May 26th, 1990 "Mike Schmidt Night" program signed by Mike Schmidt. HOF 1995

$99.99

1953 "Inside Baseball" Magazine signed by Robin Roberts. HOF 1976

$49.99

1990 Pacific Legends #20 Larry Doby Autographed Card Dual PSA 7/10. HOF. POP 1

$200.00

2005 Upper Deck USA Baseball #69 Jon Jay Rookie card

$1.00

Johnny Damon Signed & Inscribed Game Model Bat

$199.00

1981 Fleer Vending Box 500 count opened & sorted through. All commons

$8.00
Items Per Page
See All

About us

Cooperstown Legends features PSA graded Baseball Cards, primarily of Hall of Fame or star players. These cards are either single grade cards, grading just the card, or dual grade cards, grading both the card and an autograph on the card.

Buy with confidence knowing the grade of the card you are buying, and if signed, knowing that any signature is authentic, and knowing the quality of that signature.
Location: United StatesMember since: Jan 12, 2009Seller: cooperstownlegends
Top Rated SellerCooperstown Legends is one of eBay's most reputable sellers. Consistently delivers outstanding customer service Learn more

Feedback ratings

Last 12 months

Positive509- positive feedback in last 12 months
Neutral1- neutral feedback in last 12 months
Negative0- negative feedback in last 12 months

Detailed seller ratings

Average for the last 12 months

Accurate description
5.0
Reasonable shipping cost
4.6
Shipping speed
4.9
Communication
5.0

Seller feedback (1,381)

t***_ (1322)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past month
Verified purchase
Received, item as described, packaged well, would purchase from again. Thanks so much!
i***e (15854)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
what a great seller! Nice price! super card! Yaz is unreal! Thanks! Super packing!!! Secure shipment!
f***k (882)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past year
Verified purchase
Excellent product. Exact as described. Fast shipping. Great communication. Highly recommend this seller.
r***k (703)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Amazing seller, combined shipping without me even asking, fast shipping, packed very well, highly recommend!
r***k (703)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Amazing seller, combined shipping without me even asking, fast shipping, packed very well, highly recommend!
3***r (32)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Good seller ! Well packed with fast delivery!
See all feedback