Featured categories
All items
Vintage 1980s UK-Exclusive Kenner Sea Friend Care Bears Plush 6"
$114.99
Vintage Kenner 1984 Care Bears 3.5" PVC Poseable Share Bear w/ Milkshake NIB
$89.99
4x Care Bears Halloween 2025 Plush
$120.00
NEW 2025 CARE BEARS COUSINS PLUSH KEYCHAIN 6" - BRAVE HEART LION
$19.95
13" Play Along Care Bears Glow-A-Lot Plush - Bedtime - Maverick (Grumpy Colored)
$49.99
Singapore-Exclusive 8" Swift Heart Rabbit Care Bears Cousins Plush
$24.99
Play Along 13" Take Care Interactive Care Bear in Box
$489.99
8" Y2K/2000s Care Bears Beanie - NWT - Shine Bright - Comfy Series
$19.99
13" Play Along Care Bears Glow-A-Lot Plush - Bedtime - Maverick (Grumpy Colored)
$49.99
Japanese-Exclusive 8" Gentle Heart Lamb Care Bears Cousins Plush NWT
$37.99
Super Impulse World's Smallest Care Bears Series 2 - Tenderheart
$15.00
3x Care Bears Light Up Halloween Block Figures
$31.99
6x Care Bears Sparkle/Glitter Fun Size 9" Plush
$100.00
5x 8" Y2K/2000s Care Bears Beanies Plush Lot of 5 - NWT
$59.99
13" Y2K/Play Along Care Bears Plush - Bedtime - NWT
$19.99
3x CARE BEARS X UNIVERSAL MONSTERS BOBBLEHEADS 2025
$26.99
Care Bears Spooky Sparkle Halloween Plush
$29.99
13" Play Along Care Bears Glow-A-Lot Plush - Bedtime - Maverick (Grumpy Colored)
$49.99
Care Bears Sweet Sky Journeys Series Confirmed Blind Box Figure - Good Luck
$9.49
2005 Care Bears Play Along Interactive TRUE HEART BEAR with DVD in BOX - Works!
$264.99
Care Bears Cheer as Pumpkin Halloween Plush
$27.95
Series 2 GraceGift Care Bears Forever Keychain Plush - Sealed Box - Set of 6
$150.00
Care Bears Sweet Sky Journeys Series Confirmed Blind Box Figure - Sweet Dreams
$9.49
8" 20th Anniversary Care Bears Beanie Plush - Easter - Gentle Heart Lamb - NWT*
$29.99
Care Bears Micro Plush - Lot Of 2 - SHARE BEAR & FRIEND BEAR
$16.99
3x 2025 MINISO Hooded Care Bears Plush - Harmony, Grumpy, & Cheer
$95.00
13" Y2K/Play Along Care Bears Plush - Love-A-Lot
$16.99
8" AiCaL Care Bears Plush - Oopsy - NWT [2]
$9.99
1x SEALED Care Bears Super Fuzzies Plush Blind Bags Confirmed TOGETHERNESS
$37.99
10" AiCaL Care Bears Tie Dye Plush - Share - NWT
$14.99
Care Bears Share as Skeleton Halloween Plush
$29.99
13" Y2K/Play Along Care Bears Plush - Hopeful Heart - Interactive Untested
$79.99
World's Smallest Care Bears Series 1 NIB - Share
$59.99
8" Y2K/Play Along Care Bears Plush - Hopeful Heart
$9.99
Vintage Care Bears Clock
$9.99
Japanese-Exclusive ~15" AiCaL-Style Take Care Care Bears Plush
$29.99
Care Bears X Universal Monsters Grumpy Frankenstein Greeter
$37.99
Care Bears Compact Mini Fridge for Snack & Drinks USB-Powered
$41.99
UK-Exclusive Clinton 12" Share Care Bears Plush
$24.99
Japanese Care Bears Bedtime Lot - Pencil Case, Coin Purse & Micro Keychain
$34.99
13" Fluffy and Floppy Care Bears - Sweet Dreams
$49.99
13" Y2K/Play Along Care Bears Cousin Plush - Loyal Heart Dog
$22.99
Japanese-Exclusive 8" Sparkle Heart Fuzzy Care Bears Plush NWT
$22.99
~10" Bedtime Care Bears Plush
$18.99
Kenner 1980s Vintage PVC Care Bears Poseable CloudKeeper with Broom Accessory
$19.99
4x Care Bears HugMees Squishmallows Plush + Display Box
$54.99
13" Y2K/2000s Care Bears - Hopeful Heart
$79.99
Vintage 1980s Kenner Champ Care Bears Plush 13"
$21.99