Skip to main content
BargainswithButtercup

BargainswithButtercup

1.9K items sold
152 followers
Contact

Auctions ending soon

See all

  • Vintage Brite Vinyl Lures Fishing Lure Display

    $6.990 bids15h 33m

  • Vintage Fred Arbogast Hula Popper Fishing Lure, Perch, 5/8 Oz

    $6.990 bids15h 33m

  • Vintage Fred Arbogast Hula Popper Fly Rod Fishing Lure, Leopard Frog

    $6.990 bids15h 34m

  • Vintage Paw Paw Jointed Lippy Joe Fishing Lure, Awesome Color💥, Approx 3” Long

    $9.991 bid2d 13h 19m

  • Fred Arbogast Pradco Jitterbug Fishing Lure, Red Stripe/Silver Star, 5/8 Oz 🇺🇸

    $26.346 bids2d 13h 49m

  • Vintage Barracuda Tackle Co Lon Dandy Slim Twin Cuda Fishing Lure, Yellow Stripe

    $9.990 bids2d 14h 19m

All items

Vintage Abu Ambassadeur Sweden 2500C Fishing Reel

$9.991 bid6d 13h 24m

Vintage Heddon 1953 Catalog

$9.990 bids5d 12h 43m

Vintage Abu Ambassadeur Sweden 2500C Fishing Reel

$9.991 bid6d 13h 19m

Lot of Mixed Jewelry, Earrings, Bracelets, Rings, Brooches, Belt, Etc, Over 5#s

$9.991 bid4d 10h 55m

Fred Arbogast Jitterbug Fishing Lure, 5/8 Oz, Orange/Black Dots

$7.991 bid6d 13h 34m

Fred Arbogast Jitterbug Fishing Lure, Brown Parrot #2 w/Red Gill Marks, 3/8 Oz

$9.991 bid3d 13h 10m

Vintage Unbranded Mouse Fishing Lure, Approximately 2” Long

$4.990 bids5d 12h 34m

Vintage Paw Paw Jointed Lippy Joe Fishing Lure, Awesome Color💥, Approx 3” Long

$9.991 bid2d 13h 19m

Vintage Heddon Dowagiac Baby Vamp Fishing Lure

$9.990 bids5d 12h 38m

Vintage Paw Paw Pikie (?) Minnow Fishing Lure, Rainbow

$9.990 bids6d 13h 29m

Fred Arbogast Jitterbug Clicker Fishing Lure, Brown Parrot, 5/8 Oz

$10.752 bids3d 13h 5m

Vintage Fred Arbogast Arbo-Gaster Lure, Orange Coachdog

$7.990 bids3d 13h 23m

Fred Arbogast Weedless Jitterbug Fishing Lure, Bass (Unique!), 5/8 Oz

$9.990 bids3d 13h 14m

Triple Gauge Kit, Aqua Engine Gauge (2), Oil Pressure Gauge, NOS

$19.99

Fred Arbogast Pradco Jitterbug Fishing Lure, Red Stripe/Silver Star, 5/8 Oz 🇺🇸

$26.346 bids2d 13h 49m

Fred Arbogast Jointed Jitterbug Fishing Lure, Bass, 3/8 Oz

$9.991 bid3d 13h 19m

Vintage South Bend Warrior Fishing Lures, Lot of 6

$13.504 bids5d 12h 28m

Fred Arbogast Weedless Jitterbug Fishing Lure, Crosley Appliances Pearl, 3/8 Oz

$9.991 bid3d 13h 17m

Vintage Fred Arbogast Jitterbug Fishing Lure, NOS, Brown Parrot, 1/8 Oz

$22.99

Vintage Carter-Dunks Fishing Lure, Black

$9.991 bid4d 14h 42m

Lot of Mixed Jewelry, Earrings, Bracelets, Necklaces, Brooches, Etc, Over 5#s

$9.990 bids4d 10h 59m

Vintage Worden’s Lures Flatfish Fishing Lures Display

$220.00

Vintage Fred Arbogast Bottom Bumper Fishing Lure, 5/8 Oz

$19.99

Vintage Fred Arbogast Hawaiian Wiggler Fishing Lure

$12.990 bids4d 14h 42m

Vintage Heddon Punkinseed Fishing Lure, Crappie with Gold Eyes

$20.504 bids3d 13h 32m

Vintage Weller Flipper Fish Fishing Lure, Approximately 3 1/2” Long

$12.99

Vintage Shakespeare Bass A Lure Fishing Lure, Approximately 3 3/4” Long

$49.99

Vintage Assortment of Baits, Lot of 9

$6.000 bids5d 15h 1m

Vintage Fred Arbogast Scooter Fishing Lure, Blue, Approx 2 1/4” Long, 5/8 Oz

$24.99

Vintage Weller Flipper Fish Fishing Lure, Approximately 3 1/2” Long

$12.99

Vintage Barracuda Tackle Co Lon Dandy Slim Twin Cuda Fishing Lure, Yellow Stripe

$9.990 bids2d 14h 19m

Vintage Fred Arbogast Jitterbug Fishing Lure, NOS, Black, 1/8 Oz

$14.99

Delphi Technologies Strut Arms, Lot of Two, Different Part #s

$35.00

Vintage Brite Vinyl Lures Fishing Lure Display

$6.990 bids15h 33m

Vintage Fred Arbogast Arbo-Gaster Lure, Silver Flash ?

$7.990 bids4d 15h 37m

Vintage Fred Arbogast Hula Dancer Fishing Lure, Black

$7.990 bids3d 17h 23m

Vintage Mann’s Bait Company 30 + Plus Fishing Lure, NOS

$9.990 bids3d 14h 10m

Vintage Makinen Fishing Lures, Lot of 7, Merry-Widow, Holi-Comet, Etc.

$125.00

Vintage Fred Arbogast Fishing Reel Bag

$49.99

Vintage Lunkerhunt Fishing Lures, Lot of 23, NOS

$50.00

Vintage Fred Arbogast Hula Popper Fishing Lure, Black, 5/8 Oz

$5.990 bids5d 15h 0m

Vintage Fred Arbogast Hula Popper Fishing Lure, Coachdog, 5/8 Oz

$5.990 bids5d 15h 2m

Vintage Ideal Assorted Sinker Tins with Some Contents, Lot of 8

$24.99

Vintage Hornet Lure Co. Hornet Sr. Fishing Lure, Pearl with Black Dots

$19.99

Vintage P & K (Pachner & Koller) Spinning Minnie Fishing Lure, Frog

$75.00

Vintage E.H. Peckinpaugh Taylor Frog Fly Rod Fishing Lure

$19.99

Hunter Wyoming Hunting Gut Hook Skinning Knife with Leather Sheath

$65.00

Vintage Racine Stamping Co “Easy” Scaler & Scraper and Unknown Scaler & Scraper

$19.99
Items Per Page
See All

About us

Location: United StatesMember since: Jul 27, 2014Seller: buttercupbargains60
Top Rated SellerBargainswithButtercup is one of eBay's most reputable sellers. Consistently delivers outstanding customer service Learn more

Feedback ratings

Last 12 months

Positive532- positive feedback in last 12 months
Neutral1- neutral feedback in last 12 months
Negative1- negative feedback in last 12 months

Detailed seller ratings

Average for the last 12 months

Accurate description
5.0
Reasonable shipping cost
4.9
Shipping speed
5.0
Communication
5.0

Seller feedback (1,002)

h***s (314)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Item arrived a day earlier than expected. Seller provided excellent handling/packing of the item. Seller answered questions promptly and professionally! Recommend this seller and would purchase from again.
k***5 (33)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Excellent AAA+ Seller! The item was BETTER than the pictures and description! Packaging was the absolute BEST! Shipping was extremely prompt! Will be a return buyer, no hesitation.
r***2 (414)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past year
Verified purchase
Item is nicer than pictures. Great customer service,communication, fast shipping and well packaged. Perfect, thank you for everything and the fair price.
u***7 (1008)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Smooth financial transaction; paid a fair price for these two very nice lures. They arrived quickly, were in very good condition. and securely packed. Very reliable seller.
k***l (984)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past month
Verified purchase
Great vintage item at a great price. Item shipped fast, it was packaged well and arrived on time… it will look great in my collection. Hope to do business again real soon. Thank you.
j***b (864)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past year
Verified purchase
Very fast shipping. Well packaged. Just as pictured. Very happy with purchase and seller
See all feedback