Reviews
With spellbinding storytelling and historical basis, [Katy Simpson Smith] draws readers into the literary sea with this debut novel…she knows her history well but also knows human nature, exposing it in another time in a way we can feel as truth., Smith has written something wondrous and rare in her coruscating debut novel…In quiet, powerful language, The Story of Land and Sea takes us to a South that has been forgotten, blotted out by the stain of war, and breathes life into early history., Smith's narrative flawlessly blends the beauty and idealism of American independence with the hypocrisy and devastation that lay beneath it…Smith's evocation of the humanity of both slave-owner and slave never falters, leading readers to a troubling and heartrending conclusion., A pristine and powerful book…[Smith's] voice is a poet's and her vision is as expansive as the ocean, as the history in its depths. In her gorgeous and heart-rending first novel, she lays bare the hearts of parent and child, slave and master, and, most impressively, her readers., Smith lyrically but firmly draws us still back in time to reveal the lives that surround her character…Transporting, tragic, both tranquil and turbulent, Smith captures life in any time period—but especially this era of newfound freedoms—with grace and powerful prose., Morally resolute, emotionally nuanced, painstaking researched, and gorgeously expressed, Smith's debut marks her as a historical novelist to look out for., Hypnotic…Smith employs a style of impressively measured, atmospheric understatement in her unabashedly stark descriptions, and we thrill to watch her characters row stoically into a darkening future., THE STORY OF LAND AND SEA is a striking debut novel that reads like poetry and will linger like mythology, as Simpson's language and metaphors weave threads of magic through each sentence., Smith lyrically but firmly draws us still back in time to reveal the lives that surround her character…Transporting, tragic, both tranquil and turbulent, Smith captures life in any time period--but especially this era of newfound freedoms--with grace and powerful prose., With her preternaturally mature debut, Smith makes a persuasive bid to join the ranks of Hilary Mantel and Marilynne Robinson-people who have informed visions of history and the writing gifts to make them sing… Spartan, lyrical prose chimes in tune with austere times, wringing beauty from hard-bitten straits., THE STORY OF LAND AND SEA is a memorable debut, rich with small, sharp moments of observation and understanding…A deeply introspective novel…Smith weaves intricate patterns of motive and action that result in heartbreaking moral ambiguity., The grandiosity of this first novel's title belies the wise and poignant understatement of the narrative's language and form...Smith's style is compressed yet contemplative, intensely lyrical in its descriptions of the 18th-century Southern cultural landscape., For all her mastery of the willful moral ambiguity that lies in the hearts of her characters, Smith is equally adept at describing small but heartbreaking moments in relationships...It's not only among the most assured debut novels in recent memory, it heralds the birth of a major new talent., Often, a book with sensational advance press doesn't live up to the hype. Not so with Smith's remarkable debut novel…Masterfully told with the assurance and grace of a mature artist, this novel marks the debut of an authentic, exciting new voice among American writers., Smith's soulful language of loss is almost biblical, and the descriptions of her characters' sorrows are poetic and moving., The arresting prose, vividly original characters, and narrative drive with which Smith tells this story of desperate familial love on a long-ago coast provided this reader with several hours of pure pleasure and a rare glimpse of grace in a fictional world., Smith has a real gift for describing both hope and despair, which is one of the hardest things for an author to do well. She's also gifted at drawing realistic, three-dimensional characters, particularly Tabitha and her grandfather…Smith is absolutely a writer to watch., A marvel. With prose as meticulous as brushstrokes, I can think of no other debut filled with such wonder, grace, and beauty…a tremendous achievement, a masterful exploration of parenthood and faith…An heir apparent to Michael Ondaatje and Marilynne Robinson, Katy Simpson Smith has written a book for all of us., Smith lyrically but firmly draws us still back in time to reveal the lives that surround her character…Transporting, tragic, both tranquil and turbulent, Smith captures life in any time period-but especially this era of newfound freedoms-with grace and powerful prose., With lucid prose, historical and cultural accuracy, and a set of complex yet relatable characters, this debut novel from Jackson native Katy Simpson Smith has been one of the best I've read this year…Like water, this story, its characters, and its words are fluid and powerful., Smith's spare prose and storytelling style is resonant of oral history or folk tales, and the early chapters focusing on John and his daughter Tabitha, and her desire for the sea, call to mind Sena Jeter Naslund's AHAB'S WIFE., Smith hasn't merely evoked late-18th century American lives on shore and at sea-she's invented them afresh…She doesn't peddle the cozy illusion that, after all, these were people just like us; while reading THE STORY OF LAND AND SEA, we become just like them., Smith renders a beautifully woven epic tale of three generations of a family struggling to survive slavery, war and yellow fever in the late 1700s in Beaufort, N.C., Haunting…The Story of Land and Sea's finely wrought language blends startling details of the everyday with a dreamy, aphoristic quality. The effect is to root the novel in its historical moment but to reach toward the universal in its exploration of love and grief.
