Kurt Andersen's thesis is that American exceptionalism is rooted in gullibility. He traces the origins of this trait back some 500 years to the Virginia "gold rush" which produced no gold and the search for a non-existent northwest passage waterway to Asia. Subsequently, wave after wave of immigrants arrived on American shores in search of instant wealth or a pathway to paradise. Andersen suggests that the descendants of those dreamers are therefore genetically predisposed to chase fantasies. Andersen is especially hard on Protestants, so if you are one, I would suggest not reading this book. It's true that religious revivalism and fanaticism are more prevalent in modern America than in present-day European countries. Nevertheless, reviewing European history, we will find the Eighty Years War, fueled in part by sectarian differences, and the decades-long religious strife in Northern Ireland. The Civil War notwithstanding, at least it can be said that America has managed to avoid similar conflagrations caused by religion. My own Anabaptist ancestors came to what would later become the United States in the late 1600s to avoid being burned at the stake for heresy by the Roman Catholic Church in Europe. So there is plenty of blame to go around on both sides of the Atlantic when it comes to crimes committed in the name of religion. Having said everything above, I would have to agree that Americans do tend to be more prone than citizens of other advanced countries to being swayed by the power of suggestion through advertising. But this may be true simply because of the sheer pervasiveness of advertising in everyday American life, especially in radio and television, which were historically financed 100% through advertising instead of through public funding as in other countries. Thus, it was in the United States where advertising was elevated to a science (refer to the classic book "Hidden Persuaders" for details). Truth be told, advertising WORKS. If there is one American trait that is the hallmark of Fantasyland, I'd say it's narcissism. Many Americans tend to think of themselves as "rugged individuals" who can survive, nay prosper, very nicely thank you without any help from anyone, especially the government, whom they see as the problem and not the solution. Of course this is a delusion, which quickly vanishes when these people get old and sick, or when a natural disaster like a flood or a hurricane disrupts their otherwise trouble-free lives. But as long as that delusion persists, people who are infected by it believe they can solve any and all problems they may encounter by their own efforts alone or through the power of prayer or positive thinking. I have a number of friends who are absolutely convinced they can alter the probabilities of winning money from slot machines and materialize parking spaces through the power of their own minds (refer to the book "The Secret"). To me, believing in having supernatural powers such as these is the very epitome of narcissism, which produces all sorts of fantasies.Read full review
Verified purchase: No
Andersen has NAILED THE STATE OF AMERICA TODAY. I'm 73 and remember the psychoses of molested children, and the horrible things it did to innocent people - jailed due to nonsensical "authorities" and how hysteria took over our legal system, only to be reversed years later after destroying the lives of so many people. Kurt has verified my KNOWLEDGE, not BELIEF, that way too many adults do NOT THINK anymore - DO NOT do any sort of research or questioning of what they hear around them. I grew up learning about the world by playing in it, learning how the world works at the grassroots level - meaning digging in the ground playing in the fields, SEEING how things work and taking things apart and using my BRAIN in a REALITY-FOCUSED way. My father would tell me when i did something incorrectly/wrong, he would admonish me to THINK - not react - but THINK before I did things that went wrong. I grew up oriented toward the physical world thru my play, then studied physics in college, which verified for me the rules of the universe - PHYSICAL rules which determine what happens to me physically, such as getting HURT when I did stupid, dangerous things. I learned CONSEQUENCES of my own behavior, that were not caused by other people's opinions or behavior. ANOTHER VERIFICATION I had of how the real world works, meaning how other people thought and worked, was growing up as a Presbyterian - but not a real believer in it - just family circumstances - in UTAH, a thorougly MORMON environment, where i learrned PREJUDICE firsthand. I and noon-Mormon friends were ignored, excluded, and proselytized endlessly by "friends" who believed the nonsensical Mormon "cleaned-up" history of their "church", and believed without analyzing or thinking critically about what they were fed by the "church". I learned the FACT that ALL religions are theatres full of scapegoats/excuses for everything bad/good that happens to anyone who participates in their ceremonies without THINKING and REASONING. I learned how amazing it is what people will believe if they run into a situation where they don't have enough information to come to a rational conclusion about what has or is happening. They will believe what others BELIEVE, but don't analyze what they profess to believe via reasoningRead full review
Verified purchase: Yes | Condition: New
Gift for my son. He said it's a great book,everyone should read it. A lot of work went into this book and author did a fantastic job. Highly recommend.
Verified purchase: Yes | Condition: Pre-owned
You might not agree with all that's in this book, but a must read for those that want to have a look at how we got where we are. Well written by an intelligent author.
Verified purchase: Yes | Condition: New
Andersen tells it like it is without whitewashing the craziness that compels someone to pull up stakes and travel to a new land based on dreams of implementing their vision of what society should be, often based on radical religious ideas, or just seeking their fortune based on rumors and gossip. The writing is entertaining as much as it is informative, but if you've inherited any of those new religions invented in America, you might need a thick skin as Andersen calls out all the foolishness not sparing the religious.
Verified purchase: Yes | Condition: New
Current slide {CURRENT_SLIDE} of {TOTAL_SLIDES}- Best Selling in Books
Current slide {CURRENT_SLIDE} of {TOTAL_SLIDES}- Save on Books