I already have the Amazon Echo Show 8 2nd generation, which is a good device. I wanted a similar additional device and went with the 3rd generation. The upgrade was certainly noticeable. The 3rd generation has a brighter display and larger speakers with room adaption tech. Please note that the 3rd generation has eliminated the rear micro usb port, mostly used for an ethernet adapter, and increased the price a bit. But for me, the 3rd generation is the way to go.