This paint can holder only works with Rust-oleum Marking Paint, which is a temporary product.
It will not accept the vast majority of other Rust-oleum paint cans, about 95% of what you see on HomeDepot's shelf.
Nor does it work with any other brand.
That can be determined if you have the paint can holder in your hand, while you can see the different construction of the Marking Paint cans.
But for internet purchases you can't see the product until it arrives at your house. Then it's too much hassle to request a refund.
And I didn't want to donate this surprise to someone else, so rather than donate it, I threw it in the recycle.
It is plastic, after all.