Shop Mel Stottlemyre Trading Cards by Card
- 2014 Topps - Mel Stottlemyre #TM-MST
- 2010 TRISTAR Obak - Mel Stottlemyre #51
- 2004 Upper Deck Yankees Classics - Mel Stottlemyre #AU-46
- 2004 Upper Deck Yankees Classics - Mel Stottlemyre #46
- 2003 Upper Deck Yankees Signature Series - Mel Stottlemyre #PN-MS
- 2003 Upper Deck Yankees Signature Series - Mel Stottlemyre #58
- 2003 Upper Deck Sweet Spot Classic - Mel Stottlemyre #135
- 2000 Upper Deck Yankee Legends - Mel Stottlemyre #47
- 2000 Fleer Greats of the Game - Mel Stottlemyre #51
- 1991 Topps - Mel Stottlemyre #58
- 1991 Score 100 Hottest Rookies - Mel Stottlemyre #23
- 1990-91 Topps Major League Debut 1990 - Mel Stottlemyre #150
- 1990 Topps TV Team Sets - Mel Stottlemyre #6
- 1990 ProCards AAA Future Stars - Mel Stottlemyre #601
- 1990 Leaf - Mel Stottlemyre #310
- 1990 Kahn's New York Mets - Mel Stottlemyre #30
- 1990 Baseball Wit - Mel Stottlemyre #15
- 1989 Kahn's New York Mets - Mel Stottlemyre #30
- 1988 Pacific Baseball Legends - Mel Stottlemyre #22
- 1983 TCMA 50 Years of New York Yankees All Stars - Mel Stottlemyre #46
- 1975 Topps Mini - Mel Stottlemyre #183
- 1975 Topps - Mel Stottlemyre #183
- 1975 O-Pee-Chee - Mel Stottlemyre #183
- 1974 Topps - Mel Stottlemyre #44
- 1973 Topps - Mel Stottlemyre #520
- 1973 O-Pee-Chee - Mel Stottlemyre #520
- 1972 Topps - Mel Stottlemyre #492
- 1972 Topps - Mel Stottlemyre #325
- 1972 O-Pee-Chee - Mel Stottlemyre #492
- 1972 O-Pee-Chee - Mel Stottlemyre #325
- 1972 Kellogg's 3-D Super Stars - Mel Stottlemyre #50
- 1971 Topps Super - Mel Stottlemyre #10
- 1971 Topps - Mel Stottlemyre #615
- 1971 Kellogg's 3-D Super Stars - Mel Stottlemyre #40
- 1970 Topps Super - Mel Stottlemyre #27
- 1970 Topps - Mel Stottlemyre #100
- 1970 Kellogg's 3-D Super Stars - Mel Stottlemyre #5
- 1969 Topps - Mel Stottlemyre #470
- 1968 Topps - Mel Stottlemyre #120
- 1968 O-Pee-Chee - Mel Stottlemyre #120
- 1968 Milton Bradley Win-A-Card Game - Mel Stottlemyre #120
- 1967 Topps Venezuelan - Mel Stottlemyre #242
- 1967 Topps - Mel Stottlemyre #225
- 1966 Topps - Mel Stottlemyre #350
- 1965 Topps - Mel Stottlemyre #550
- 1965 Topps - Mel Stottlemyre #133