Shop Mike Matheny Trading Cards by Model
- 2016 Topps Heritage - Mike Matheny #276
- 2015 Topps Heritage - Mike Matheny #76
- 2014 Topps Heritage - Mike Matheny #126
- 2014 Topps Archives - Mike Matheny #MM
- 2013 Topps Heritage - Mike Matheny #413
- 2006 Topps Heritage - Mike Matheny #235
- 2006 Topps Chrome - Mike Matheny #262
- 2006 Topps Allen & Ginter's - Mike Matheny #85
- 2006 Topps - Mike Matheny #252
- 2005 Upper Deck - Mike Matheny #401
- 2005 Topps Updates & Highlights - Mike Matheny #UH5
- 2005 Topps Total - Mike Matheny #13
- 2005 Topps Heritage - Mike Matheny #433
- 2005 Topps Cracker Jack - Mike Matheny #228
- 2005 Topps Chrome Update & Highlights - Mike Matheny #UH5
- 2005 Topps Chrome - Mike Matheny #124
- 2005 Topps - Mike Matheny #705
- 2005 Topps - Mike Matheny #124
- 2005 Fleer Tradition - Mike Matheny #57
- 2005 Donruss - Mike Matheny #340
- 2005 Bowman Heritage - Mike Matheny #90
- 2004 Topps Total - Mike Matheny #68
- 2004 Topps - Mike Matheny #706
- 2004 Topps - Mike Matheny #6
- 2004 Fleer Tradition - Mike Matheny #147
- 2004 Donruss - Mike Matheny #345
- 2003 Upper Deck - Mike Matheny #405
- 2003 Topps Total - Mike Matheny #329
- 2003 Topps - Mike Matheny #89
- 2002 Upper Deck Victory - Mike Matheny #291
- 2002 Upper Deck 40 Man - Mike Matheny #575
- 2002 Topps Total - Mike Matheny #166
- 2002 Topps Opening Day - Mike Matheny #32
- 2002 Topps Heritage - Mike Matheny #72
- 2002 Topps Chrome - Mike Matheny #4
- 2002 Topps - Mike Matheny #4
- 2001 Upper Deck MVP - Mike Matheny #190
- 2001 Upper Deck Gold Glove - Mike Matheny #53
- 2001 Topps Chrome - Mike Matheny #56
- 2001 Topps - Mike Matheny #74
- 2001 Pacific - Mike Matheny #354
- 2001 MLB Showdown - Mike Matheny #408
- 2001 Bowman Heritage - Mike Matheny #203
- 1999 Pacific - Mike Matheny #238
- 1999 Fleer Tradition - Mike Matheny #510
- 1998 Upper Deck Collector's Choice - Mike Matheny #406
- 1998 Upper Deck - Mike Matheny #408
- 1998 Topps Stadium Club - Mike Matheny #97
- 1998 Pacific Online - Mike Matheny #405
- 1998 Pacific Invincible - Mike Matheny #59
- 1997 Upper Deck Collector's Choice - Mike Matheny #372
- 1997 Topps - Mike Matheny #485
- 1997 Pacific Crown Collection - Mike Matheny #123
- 1997 Fleer Ultra - Mike Matheny #G78
- 1997 Fleer Ultra - Mike Matheny #78
- 1997 Fleer - Mike Matheny #133
- 1996 Topps Stadium Club - Mike Matheny #446
- 1996 Fleer Ultra - Mike Matheny #366
- 1996 Fleer - Mike Matheny #152
- 1996 Flair - Mike Matheny #102
- 1996 Donruss - Mike Matheny #541
- 1995 Pinnacle - Mike Matheny #144
- 1994 Sportflics 2000 Rookie & Traded - Mike Matheny #127
- 1994 Score Select - Mike Matheny #204
- 1994 Fleer Ultra - Mike Matheny #375
- 1994 Bowman - Mike Matheny #673
- 1993-94 Fleer Excel - Mike Matheny #83
- 1992 Classic Best Minor League - Mike Matheny #393