Shop Jay Payton Trading Cards by Model
- 2009 Upper Deck - Jay Payton #39
- 2009 Topps Heritage - Jay Payton #232
- 2009 Topps - Jay Payton #189
- 2008 Upper Deck - Jay Payton #423
- 2008 Topps Heritage - Jay Payton #294
- 2008 Topps - Jay Payton #438
- 2007 Upper Deck First Edition - Jay Payton #130
- 2007 Upper Deck - Jay Payton #568
- 2007 Upper Deck - Jay Payton #184
- 2007 Topps Opening Day - Jay Payton #212
- 2007 Topps Heritage - Jay Payton #121
- 2007 Topps Allen & Ginter's - Jay Payton #25
- 2007 Topps - Jay Payton #31
- 2007 Fleer - Jay Payton #117
- 2006 Upper Deck Sweet Spot - Jay Payton #SW-JA
- 2006 Upper Deck Special F/X - Jay Payton #330
- 2006 Upper Deck - Jay Payton #330
- 2006 Topps Heritage - Jay Payton #296
- 2006 Topps - Jay Payton #466
- 2006 Fleer - Jay Payton #36
- 2005 Upper Deck First Pitch - Jay Payton #165
- 2005 Upper Deck - Jay Payton #165
- 2005 Topps Total - Jay Payton #328
- 2005 Topps Rookie Cup - Jay Payton #121
- 2005 Topps Heritage - Jay Payton #44
- 2005 Topps Cracker Jack - Jay Payton #99
- 2005 Topps - Jay Payton #616
- 2005 MLB Showdown Trading Deadline - Jay Payton #096
- 2005 Leaf - Jay Payton #164
- 2005 Donruss Team Heroes - Jay Payton #263
- 2005 Donruss Studio - Jay Payton #49
- 2005 Donruss Prime Patches - Jay Payton #MLM-4
- 2005 Donruss Diamond Kings - Jay Payton #186
- 2005 Donruss Champions - Jay Payton #34
- 2005 Donruss - Jay Payton #170
- 2004 Upper Deck Vintage - Jay Payton #122
- 2004 Upper Deck Etchings - Jay Payton #BE-JP
- 2004 Upper Deck - Jay Payton #258
- 2004 Topps Traded and Rookies - Jay Payton #T21
- 2004 Topps Total - Jay Payton #497
- 2004 Topps Opening Day - Jay Payton #12
- 2004 Topps Heritage - Jay Payton #136
- 2004 Topps Chrome Traded & Rookies - Jay Payton #T21
- 2004 Topps Chrome - Jay Payton #23
- 2004 Topps Bazooka - Jay Payton #166
- 2004 Topps - Jay Payton #23
- 2004 Playoff Prestige - Jay Payton #65
- 2004 Playoff Honors - Jay Payton #161
- 2004 Playoff Absolute Memorabilia - Jay Payton #165
- 2004 Leaf Second Edition - Jay Payton #128
- 2004 Leaf Limited - Jay Payton #57
- 2004 Leaf Certified Materials - Jay Payton #90
- 2004 Leaf Certified Cuts - Jay Payton #158
- 2004 Leaf - Jay Payton #128
- 2004 Fleer Ultra - Jay Payton #61
- 2004 Fleer Tradition - Jay Payton #277
- 2004 Fleer Platinum - Jay Payton #106
- 2004 Fleer Authentix - Jay Payton #43
- 2004 Donruss World Series - Jay Payton #WS-146
- 2004 Donruss Throwback Threads - Jay Payton #163
- 2004 Donruss Studio - Jay Payton #160
- 2004 Donruss Leather & Lumber - Jay Payton #122
- 2004 Donruss Classics - Jay Payton #98
- 2004 Donruss - Jay Payton #258
- 2003 Upper Deck Sweet Spot - Jay Payton #45
- 2003 Upper Deck Game Face - Jay Payton #40
- 2003 Upper Deck 40 Man - Jay Payton #752
- 2003 Upper Deck - Jay Payton #LS-JP
- 2003 Upper Deck - Jay Payton #500
- 2003 Topps Total - Jay Payton #602
- 2003 Topps Heritage - Jay Payton #397
- 2003 Topps Chrome - Jay Payton #305
- 2003 Topps 205 - Jay Payton #201
- 2003 Topps - Jay Payton #476
- 2003 SPx - Jay Payton #43
- 2003 Playoff Prestige - Jay Payton #116
- 2003 Leaf - Jay Payton #159
- 2003 Fleer Tradition - Jay Payton #174
- 2003 Fleer Hardball - Jay Payton #162
- 2003 Fleer Double Header - Jay Payton #164
- 2003 Donruss Studio - Jay Payton #120
- 2003 Donruss Elite - Jay Payton #104
- 2003 Donruss Diamond Kings - Jay Payton #98
- 2003 Donruss - Jay Payton #341
- 2002 Upper Deck Vintage - Jay Payton #223
- 2002 Upper Deck Victory - Jay Payton #401
- 2002 Upper Deck MVP - Jay Payton #238
- 2002 Upper Deck Diamond Connection - Jay Payton #387
- 2002 Upper Deck 40 Man - Jay Payton #826
- 2002 Topps Traded - Jay Payton #T89
- 2002 Topps Total - Jay Payton #419
- 2002 Topps Heritage - Jay Payton #256
- 2002 Topps Chrome Traded & Rookies - Jay Payton #T89
- 2002 Topps Chrome - Jay Payton #378
- 2002 Topps - Jay Payton #378
- 2002 SP Authentic - Jay Payton #181
- 2002 Fleer Ultra - Jay Payton #189
- 2002 Fleer Triple Crown - Jay Payton #156
- 2002 Fleer Tradition Update - Jay Payton #U269
- 2002 Fleer Tradition - Jay Payton #371
- 2002 Fleer Premium - Jay Payton #149
- 2002 Fleer Platinum - Jay Payton #75
- 2002 Fleer - Jay Payton #111
- 2001 Upper Deck Vintage - Jay Payton #381
- 2001 Upper Deck Vintage - Jay Payton #277
- 2001 Upper Deck Victory - Jay Payton #443
- 2001 Upper Deck MVP - Jay Payton #264
- 2001 Upper Deck Evolution - Jay Payton #77
- 2001 Upper Deck - Jay Payton #417
- 2001 Topps Stars - Jay Payton #126
- 2001 Topps Opening Day - Jay Payton #92
- 2001 Topps Heritage - Jay Payton #312
- 2001 Topps Gold Label - Jay Payton #45
- 2001 Topps Gallery - Jay Payton #90
- 2001 Topps Finest - Jay Payton #FM6
- 2001 Topps Finest - Jay Payton #FA-JP
- 2001 Topps Chrome - Jay Payton #229
- 2001 SPx - Jay Payton #74
- 2001 Playoff Absolute Memorabilia - Jay Payton #135
- 2001 Pacific Private Stock - Jay Payton #118
- 2001 Pacific - Jay Payton #275
- 2001 MLB Showdown - Jay Payton #282
- 2001 Fleer Triple Crown - Jay Payton #53
- 2001 Fleer Tradition - Jay Payton #215
- 2001 Fleer Platinum - Jay Payton #215
- 2001 Fleer Futures - Jay Payton #101
- 2001 Fleer Focus - Jay Payton #7BI
- 2001 Fleer Focus - Jay Payton #187
- 2001 Donruss Elite - Jay Payton #135
- 2001 Donruss - Jay Payton #135
- 2001 Bowman Heritage - Jay Payton #321
- 2001 Bowman Chrome - Jay Payton #45
- 2001 Bowman - Jay Payton #61
- 2000 Upper Deck Subway Series - Jay Payton #NY23
- 2000 Ultimate Victory - Jay Payton #75
- 2000 Topps New York City Subway Series - Jay Payton #2
- 2000 Pacific Private Stock - Jay Payton #93
- 2000 Pacific Crown Royale - Jay Payton #91
- 1999 Skybox Thunder - Jay Payton #229
- 1999 Just Minors - Jay Payton #220
- 1999 Fleer Tradition - Jay Payton #253W
- 1999 Fleer Tradition - Jay Payton #253
- 1998 Fleer Tradition Update - Jay Payton #U20
- 1998 Donruss Elite - Jay Payton #109
- 1997-98 Score Board Autographed Collection - Jay Payton #12
- 1997 Upper Deck Collector's Choice - Jay Payton #475
- 1997 Topps - Jay Payton #342
- 1997 Select - Jay Payton #137
- 1997 Score Board Talkn' Sports - Jay Payton #41
- 1997 Score Board Players Club - Jay Payton #48
- 1997 Bowman - Jay Payton #CA61
- 1997 Bowman - Jay Payton #151
- 1996 Topps Chrome - Jay Payton #141
- 1996 Topps - Jay Payton #350
- 1996 Score Board All Sport PPF - Jay Payton #161
- 1996 Fleer Excel - Jay Payton #191
- 1996 Clear Assets - Jay Payton #55
- 1996 Classic Visions Signings - Jay Payton #87
- 1996 Bowman's Best - Jay Payton #111
- 1996 Bowman - Jay Payton #241
- 1996 Assets - Jay Payton #33
- 1995 Upper Deck Minor League Top Prospect - Jay Payton #195
- 1995 Topps - Jay Payton #443
- 1995 SP Top Prospects - Jay Payton #95
- 1995 SP Top Prospects - Jay Payton #9
- 1995 Classic 5 Sport Signings - Jay Payton #S65
- 1995 Classic 5 Sport - Jay Payton #105
- 1995 Bowman's Best - Jay Payton #62
- 1995 Bowman - Jay Payton #240
- 1995 Best - Jay Payton #84
- 1995 Best - Jay Payton #107
- 1994-95 Fleer Excel - Jay Payton #235
- 1994 Topps Stadium Club Draft Picks - Jay Payton #17
- 1994 Signature Rookies Draft Picks - Jay Payton #28
- 1994 Fleer ProCards Minor League - Jay Payton #3536