Shop Allie Reynolds Trading Cards by Model
- 2008 Upper Deck Yankee Stadium Legacy Stadium Box Set - Allie Reynolds #25
- 2008 Upper Deck Yankee Stadium Legacy Final Season Box Set - Allie Reynolds #25
- 2008 Upper Deck - Allie Reynolds #YSL2210
- 2008 Upper Deck - Allie Reynolds #YSL2208
- 2008 Upper Deck - Allie Reynolds #YSL2198
- 2008 Upper Deck - Allie Reynolds #YSL2038
- 2008 Upper Deck - Allie Reynolds #YSL1888
- 2007 SP Legendary Cuts - Allie Reynolds #51
- 2005 Upper Deck Classics - Allie Reynolds #3
- 2002 Topps Chrome - Allie Reynolds #52R-9
- 2002 Topps Archives - Allie Reynolds #77
- 2001 Topps Archives - Allie Reynolds #91
- 2001 Topps Archives - Allie Reynolds #105
- 2000 Upper Deck Yankee Legends - Allie Reynolds #43
- 1993 Action Packed - Allie Reynolds #135
- 1991 Topps Archives The Ultimate 1953 Set - Allie Reynolds #141
- 1989 Swell Baseball Greats - Allie Reynolds #101
- 1988 Pacific Baseball Legends - Allie Reynolds #41
- 1988 CCC 1949 Bowman Reprints - Allie Reynolds #114
- 1987 CCC 1948 Bowman Reprints - Allie Reynolds #14
- 1986 C.C.C. 1951 Bowman Reprints - Allie Reynolds #109
- 1983 Topps 1952 Reprint Series - Allie Reynolds #67
- 1983 TCMA 50 Years of New York Yankees All Stars - Allie Reynolds #35
- 1983 C.C.C. 1953 Bowman Color Reprints - Allie Reynolds #68
- 1982 TCMA Baseball's Greatest - Allie Reynolds #1982-13
- 1980 Fleer Laughlin World Series Team Logo Sticker Backs - Allie Reynolds #1950
- 1979 TCMA Baseball History Series the 1950's - Allie Reynolds #185
- 1978 Grand Slam - Allie Reynolds #94
- 1977-84 TCMA Renata Galasso - Allie Reynolds #33
- 1975 Sheraton Great Plains Greats - Allie Reynolds #5
- 1971 Fleer Laughlin World Series - Allie Reynolds #48
- 1961 Fleer Baseball Greats - Allie Reynolds #69
- 1955 Bowman - Allie Reynolds #201
- 1954 Bowman - Allie Reynolds #113
- 1953 Topps - Allie Reynolds #141
- 1953 Bowman Color - Allie Reynolds #68
- 1952 Topps - Allie Reynolds #67
- 1951 Topps - Allie Reynolds #6
- 1951 Bowman - Allie Reynolds #109
- 1951 Berk Ross Hit Parade of Champions - Allie Reynolds #3-3
- 1950 Bowman - Allie Reynolds #138
- 1949 Bowman - Allie Reynolds #114
- 1948 Bowman - Allie Reynolds #14