1958 TOPPS # 5 WILLIE MAYS GIANTS GD-VG SET BREAK 532461 (KYCARDS)

KIT YOUNG CARDS
(93123)
Seller's other items
Contact seller
US $194.00
as low as $33.67/mo with
Ungraded
Total PSA pop
5,817
PSA data
Breathe easy. Free returns.
Shipping:
US $4.95 USPS First Class®.
Located in: San Diego, California, United States
Delivery:
Estimated between Wed, Nov 26 and Tue, Dec 2 to 94104
Delivery time is estimated using our proprietary method which is based on the buyer's proximity to the item location, the shipping service selected, the seller's shipping history, and other factors. Delivery times may vary, especially during peak periods.
Returns:
30 days returns. Seller pays for return shipping.
Payments:
       .
*No Interest if paid in full in 6 months on $149+. See terms and apply now- for PayPal Credit, opens in a new window or tab
Earn up to 5x points when you use your eBay Mastercard®. Learn moreabout earning points with eBay Mastercard
Seller assumes all responsibility for this listing.
eBay item number:267257121072
Last updated on Aug 06, 2025 16:51:52 PDTView all revisionsView all revisions

Item specifics

Condition
Ungraded - Poor: Not in original packaging or professionally graded
Sport
BASEBALL
Set
TOPPS
Team
GIANTS
Graded
NO
Card Condition
Poor
Category

Item description from the seller

About this seller

KIT YOUNG CARDS

100% positive feedback•235K items sold

Joined Feb 1999
Usually responds within 24 hours
Since 1976 Kit Young has been America's #1 dealer buying and selling vintage sportscards, specializing in complete sets, stars, commons, high numbers etc. from 1950-79. Plus 1000's of pre-war cards. ...
See more
Visit storeContact

Detailed seller ratings

Average for the last 12 months
Accurate description
5.0
Reasonable shipping cost
4.9
Shipping speed
5.0
Communication
5.0

Popular categories from this store

See allcategories
BASEBALL OLDER AND PREWARBOWMAN BASEBALLTOPPS BASEBALLBOWMAN FOOTBALLTOPPS FOOTBALLTOPPS BASEBALL INSERTSREGIONAL BASEBALL ISSUESBASEBALL SETS AND LOTSPHILADELPHIA FOOTBALL

Seller feedback (160,048)

All ratingsselected
Positive
Neutral
Negative
  • r***b (390)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past month
    Verified purchase
    Have made multiple purchases from seller over the past months. I have never been disappointed. All transactions were handled well from the standpoint of packing and shipping and the cards purchased were always as described and were purchased at a reasonable market price.
    1957 TOPPS #347 HAL NARAGON INDIANS VG-EX SET BREAK 508391 (KYCARDS) (#235605399031)
  • k***k (257)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    accurate descriptions, quick shipping and delivery, when item arrived; there had been a mix-up in their inventory and the wrong item was shipped a couple of messages traded and a follow up phone call from seller resolved the issue easily. great communication from the guys at Kit Young Cards & excellent service as always will continue to purchase from seller. A+++
    1951 BOWMAN #285 JOHNNY LIPON TIGERS EX-MT SET BREAK 531369 (KYCARDS) (#267217510967)
  • s***s (2109)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    I couldn't be happier with this purchase! The 2015 TOPPS TRIBUTE #1 MIKE TROUT ANGELS card arrived exactly as described—absolutely stunning in person with vibrant colors and sharp edges. A true collector’s piece! The seller packaged it securely and shipped it quickly, with excellent communication throughout the process. Smooth transaction from start to finish. Highly recommended seller, and a must-have card for any Trout or Angels fan. A+!
    2015 TOPPS TRIBUTE # 1 MIKE TROUT ANGELS 438114 (KYCARDS) (#234688675637)
See all feedback

Product ratings and reviews

Learn more
5.0
11 product ratings
  • 11 users rated this 5 out of 5 stars
  • 0 users rated this 4 out of 5 stars
  • 0 users rated this 3 out of 5 stars
  • 0 users rated this 2 out of 5 stars
  • 0 users rated this 1 out of 5 stars

Would recommend

Good value

Good quality

Most relevant reviews

See all 11 reviews
  • by stlevi_55
    May 16, 2024Top favorable review

    Perfect card for the money. Great centering. This 1958 Topps Willie Mays seems to be in high demand. I wanted to get a PSA rated for my childhood favo

    Perfect card for the money. Great centering. This 1958 Topps Willie Mays seems to be in high demand. I wanted to get a PSA rated for my childhood favorite baseball player.

    Verified purchase: YesCondition: Pre-OwnedSold by: de49m

  • by vintage_legends
    Apr 22, 2024

    Fantastic item, well centered 58 Mays that looks much better than the assigned grade, got to think its way undergraded. Super fast delivery. I'll be

    Fantastic item, well centered 58 Mays that looks much better than the assigned grade, got to think its way undergraded. Super fast delivery. I'll be watching for other cards. Many thanks. A+A+A+

    Verified purchase: YesCondition: Pre-OwnedSold by: ni657862

  • by charlemaure_0
    Oct 25, 2024

    Great color

    Great Card. Thank you

    Verified purchase: YesCondition: Pre-OwnedSold by: battersbox

  • by blrog_7116
    Mar 25, 2025

    One of my favorite May's cards. Top shelf.

    Willie's charisma is unbeatable.

    Verified purchase: YesCondition: Pre-OwnedSold by: vintagescards

  • by jimmy-3679
    Jun 04, 2023

    Willie Mays

    Been looking for this ‘58 Mays for a long time at a price I could afford . This was it. Mays Cards run high on price.

    Verified purchase: YesSold by: kjinvestments

More to explore :