Skip to main content
eBay Logo

Shop by category

Advanced
    • Daily Deals
    • Brand Outlet
    • Help & Contact
    • Sell
    • WatchlistExpand Watch List
      Loading...
      Sign in to see your user information
    • My eBayExpand My eBay
      • Summary
      • Recently Viewed
      • Bids/Offers
      • Watchlist
      • Purchase History
      • Buy Again
      • Selling
      • Saved Searches
      • Saved Sellers
      • My Garage
      • Messages
      • Collection beta
      • The eBay vault
    • Expand Cart
      Loading...
      Something went wrong. View cart for details.
    {"delay":300}

    There seems to be a problem serving the request at this time

    breadcrumb

    • eBay
    • Toys & Hobbies
    • Stuffed Animals
    • First & Main

    First & Main Stuffed Animals

    Side Refine Panel

    Shop by Category

    • Stuffed Animals
    • First & Main
    • Handmade
    • Animal Alley
    • Applause
    • Aurora
    • Coca-Cola
    • Dakin
    • Dan Dee
    • Disney
    • Eden
    • FAO Schwarz
    • Fisher Price
    • Gund
    • Hansa
    • Jellycat
    • Kookeys
    • Limited Treasures
    • Melissa & Doug
    • Neopets
    • Pound Puppies
    • Princess Soft Toys
      • Puffkins
      • Russ
      • Steiff
      • Uglydolls
      • Warner Bros.
      • Webkinz & Lil'Kinz
      • Vintage
      • Mixed Lots
      • Other Stuffed Animals

    Best Selling

    See All- Best Selling
    • Jingles Pink Giraffe Rattle First & Main Soft Toy Baby Doll Stuffed Plush 2763
      Jingles Pink Giraffe Rattle First & Main Soft Toy Baby Doll Stuffed Plush 2763
      (1)Total Ratings 1
      $9.99 New
      $9.99 Used
    • First & Main Tender Teddy Brown Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Red Heart 8” 1615 FS
      First & Main Tender Teddy Brown Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Red Heart 8” 1615 FS
      (3)Total Ratings 3
      $12.99 New
      $12.00 Used
    • First & Main Scraggles Teddy Bear 11" Stuffed Animal Plush Toy With Tags
      First & Main Scraggles Teddy Bear 11" Stuffed Animal Plush Toy With Tags
      (1)Total Ratings 1
      $23.99 New
      $10.98 Used
    • All

    • Auction

    • Buy It Now

    • Best Match
    • Time: ending soonest
    • Time: newly listed
    • Price + Shipping: lowest first
    • Price + Shipping: highest first
    • Distance: nearest first
    • List View

    1,507 Results

      • 3-4 Years
      • Small (6-14 in)
      • Medium (14-24 in)
      • Unbranded
      • All Listings filter applied
    • First & Main Lion and the Lamb 10" Plush Peacemakers Stuffed Animal

      First & Main Lion and the Lamb 10" Plush Peacemakers Stuffed Animal

      $49.00
      $11.97 shipping
      SPONSORED
    • Plush Lankydoodle Dog First & Main White Tan Brown Puppy Lovey 10”

      Plush Lankydoodle Dog First & Main White Tan Brown Puppy Lovey 10”

      $24.99
      $6.00 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • 9 Inch Giraffe Plush with Baby Rattle - Baby Shower Gift - New - Free Shipping!

      9 Inch Giraffe Plush with Baby Rattle - Baby Shower Gift - New - Free Shipping!

      (1)1 product ratings - 9 Inch Giraffe Plush with Baby Rattle - Baby Shower Gift - New - Free Shipping!
      $19.74
      Free shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • First And Main Collectible Plush Teddy Bear No. 1895 Regis Length 16”

      First And Main Collectible Plush Teddy Bear No. 1895 Regis Length 16”

      $9.95
      $4.95 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • First & Main Sweets Huggum Rare White Teddy Bear 7" Stuffed Animal Plush

      First & Main Sweets Huggum Rare White Teddy Bear 7" Stuffed Animal Plush

      $8.95
      $4.95 shipping
    • First and Main Fantazoo Plush ELENA the ELEPHANT  7” Orange Sparkle Glitter Eyes

      First and Main Fantazoo Plush ELENA the ELEPHANT 7” Orange Sparkle Glitter Eyes

      $0.99
      0 bids
      $5.99 shipping
      Ending Wednesday at 8:00AM PDT1d 16h
    • First & Main Plush Scraggles White Teddy Bear w Red Bow Tie Holiday Bears #1554

      First & Main Plush Scraggles White Teddy Bear w Red Bow Tie Holiday Bears #1554

      $17.10
      $10.04 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • First & Main plush Bear White Scraggles 1864 gently used 8" sitting Cute

      First & Main plush Bear White Scraggles 1864 gently used 8" sitting Cute

      $7.14
      Was: $10.99
      $8.28 shipping
    • First & Main 20” Brown Moose Rare Vintage Plush Realistic Soft

      First & Main 20” Brown Moose Rare Vintage Plush Realistic Soft

      $11.21
      Was: $14.95
      $7.95 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • First & Main Sherbert Baby Plush Stuffed Animal Bear Vintage 2001

      First & Main Sherbert Baby Plush Stuffed Animal Bear Vintage 2001

      $13.00
      $5.90 shipping
    • First and Main Dena Huggum White Soft Plush Teddy  Bear  5”

      First and Main Dena Huggum White Soft Plush Teddy Bear 5”

      $9.95
      Free shipping
      or Best Offer
    • First & Main 12" Plush Pot Belly Teddy Bear "Elliot" Floppy Stuffed Animal Brown

      First & Main 12" Plush Pot Belly Teddy Bear "Elliot" Floppy Stuffed Animal Brown

      $11.95
      $8.14 shipping
    • 🦄First & Main Inc. "Mac" Curly Brown & Tan Bear w/Stitch Patch Feet 10" Plush!

      🦄First & Main Inc. "Mac" Curly Brown & Tan Bear w/Stitch Patch Feet 10" Plush!

      $60.00
      $9.99 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • 4 Pack - First & Main Horse Equestrian Pony Soft Plush Farm Stuffed Animals 10"

      4 Pack - First & Main Horse Equestrian Pony Soft Plush Farm Stuffed Animals 10"

      $39.99
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • First and Main 10" Blackie Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Teddy Toy

      First and Main 10" Blackie Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Teddy Toy

      $11.00
      $5.65 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • First & Main "Dena" Teddy Bear Plush Stuffed Animal  No. 1786

      First & Main "Dena" Teddy Bear Plush Stuffed Animal No. 1786

      $11.90
      Was: $14.00
      $6.07 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • 9" First & Main Daphne the Dolphin Gal Pals Fantasea Sparkly Plush Panama Beach

      9" First & Main Daphne the Dolphin Gal Pals Fantasea Sparkly Plush Panama Beach

      $10.99
      Free shipping
      or Best Offer
    • First & Main Ted Jr Bear Plush White Red Bow 18" Stuffed Animal Toy Sparkle

      First & Main Ted Jr Bear Plush White Red Bow 18" Stuffed Animal Toy Sparkle

      $26.99
      Was: $29.99
      $10.95 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • First & Main “Scruffy” Teddy Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Soft Brown Tan Brand

      First & Main “Scruffy” Teddy Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Soft Brown Tan Brand

      $5.00
      $5.55 shipping
    • NWT First & Main Western Horse Rough Wrangler 16" Stuffed Weighted Plush Animal

      NWT First & Main Western Horse Rough Wrangler 16" Stuffed Weighted Plush Animal

      $5.55
      $5.50 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • First And Main Sleeping Calico Cat Plush Stuffed Animal 3593 Brown White Black

      First And Main Sleeping Calico Cat Plush Stuffed Animal 3593 Brown White Black

      $11.95
      $8.25 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • 🏝️ First and Main beige Scraggles Teddy Bear 10”

      🏝️ First and Main beige Scraggles Teddy Bear 10”

      $2.99
      $5.65 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • First and Main Plush Purple Pink Passion Hippo Stuffed animal beanie safari toy

      First and Main Plush Purple Pink Passion Hippo Stuffed animal beanie safari toy

      $4.99
      $5.05 shipping
    • First and Main Brown Bear Plush Animal 8 In Fuzzy Teddy Vintage Huggable Gift

      First and Main Brown Bear Plush Animal 8 In Fuzzy Teddy Vintage Huggable Gift

      $8.46
      Was: $15.39
      $5.70 shipping
    • First & Main Teddy Tidbit Plush Bear 10" W/ Bow

      First & Main Teddy Tidbit Plush Bear 10" W/ Bow

      $4.82
      $5.55 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • First Main Tadpole Frog Plush Rattle Thad Polz Sound 11" Soft Toy Cuddle 5274

      First Main Tadpole Frog Plush Rattle Thad Polz Sound 11" Soft Toy Cuddle 5274

      $20.00
      $6.95 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • First & Main Creme Puff Frog Polka Dots Green Plush Bean Bag Toy 16"

      First & Main Creme Puff Frog Polka Dots Green Plush Bean Bag Toy 16"

      $18.00
      Was: $20.00
      $5.00 shipping
    • First & Main Inc Stuffed Plush 2002 Halloween Fireman Lil Trick-or-Treater H5203

      First & Main Inc Stuffed Plush 2002 Halloween Fireman Lil Trick-or-Treater H5203

      $14.84
      $5.55 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Pair of First & Main "Sunny Bunny" Rabbit Plush Stuffed Animals Sunflower Outfit

      Pair of First & Main "Sunny Bunny" Rabbit Plush Stuffed Animals Sunflower Outfit

      $43.95
      $14.50 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • First & Main Gal Pals Forever Lily Leopard Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Green Blue

      First & Main Gal Pals Forever Lily Leopard Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Green Blue

      $35.00
      $5.65 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • VERY RARE! First & Main Helena Hippo Ballerina Plush with Tags 

      VERY RARE! First & Main Helena Hippo Ballerina Plush with Tags 

      $20.00
      $10.65 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • First & Main Foxy Lady Plush Fox With Glasses Boa Sequined Dress Valentines Day

      First & Main Foxy Lady Plush Fox With Glasses Boa Sequined Dress Valentines Day

      $21.84
      Was: $27.30
      $10.55 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • First & Main Tiny Teddy Bear VTG Style Beanie Bean Bag Plush Stuffed Animal Toy

      First & Main Tiny Teddy Bear VTG Style Beanie Bean Bag Plush Stuffed Animal Toy

      $7.73
      $5.00 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • First and Main Sullivan #6223 10" Monkey Plush Stuffed Animal

      First and Main Sullivan #6223 10" Monkey Plush Stuffed Animal

      $4.80
      Was: $12.00
      $8.00 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • First And Main Brown Tender Teddy Bear

      First And Main Brown Tender Teddy Bear

      $15.00
      $8.00 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • First and Main Lil Elliott Teddy Bear Cream Colored Fur Bean Pellet Bottom 6”

      First and Main Lil Elliott Teddy Bear Cream Colored Fur Bean Pellet Bottom 6”

      $11.90
      $5.05 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • First & Main Michaels St Jude plush bear, Has Tag

      First & Main Michaels St Jude plush bear, Has Tag

      $16.50
      $10.65 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • First & Main Teddy Bear MAXWELL Brown Plaid Bow Stuffed Animal 8" Inch

      First & Main Teddy Bear MAXWELL Brown Plaid Bow Stuffed Animal 8" Inch

      $12.00
      $6.65 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • First And Main Teddy Bear Purple Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 6 Inch

      First And Main Teddy Bear Purple Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 6 Inch

      $8.24
      Was: $14.99
      $5.25 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • First & Main #1924 Scraggles Tan Fluffy Teddy Bear Plush  Animal Blue Ribbon 10”

      First & Main #1924 Scraggles Tan Fluffy Teddy Bear Plush Animal Blue Ribbon 10”

      $10.00
      $5.55 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • First & Main Plush Orange Teddy Bear 6"

      First & Main Plush Orange Teddy Bear 6"

      $0.99
      0 bids
      $4.99 shipping
      Ending Tuesday at 8:30AM PDT17h
    • Tender Teddy Bear Plush Heart First and Main large 20 inch stuffed animal

      Tender Teddy Bear Plush Heart First and Main large 20 inch stuffed animal

      $12.99
      Was: $19.99
      $13.97 shipping
    • 2 First & Main Jellybean Bunnies orange pink stuffed plush bunny rabbit Easter

      2 First & Main Jellybean Bunnies orange pink stuffed plush bunny rabbit Easter

      $12.95
      $6.45 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • First & Main Brown Teddy Bear Ted Jr. Red Bow Stuffed Animal Toy Soft Silky 14"

      First & Main Brown Teddy Bear Ted Jr. Red Bow Stuffed Animal Toy Soft Silky 14"

      $12.00
      $8.00 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • First & Main Scraggles the Teddy Bear Brown 10" Stuffed Animal Plush Item 1874

      First & Main Scraggles the Teddy Bear Brown 10" Stuffed Animal Plush Item 1874

      $11.99
      $6.00 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Under the Sea Friends Narwhal Stuffed Animal First and Main Blue Grey Plush

      Under the Sea Friends Narwhal Stuffed Animal First and Main Blue Grey Plush

      $9.00
      Was: $10.00
      $5.65 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • First & Main Ducklin Plush Yellow With Rainbow Bow Stuffed Animal 13" FLAWs

      First & Main Ducklin Plush Yellow With Rainbow Bow Stuffed Animal 13" FLAWs

      $12.00
      $5.55 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • FIRST & MAIN Inc 12" Bunny Rabbit BRAND NEW W/TAG Menagerie Toys Easter Huggums

      FIRST & MAIN Inc 12" Bunny Rabbit BRAND NEW W/TAG Menagerie Toys Easter Huggums

      $5.55
      0 bids
      $4.50 shipping
      Ending Today at 6:33PM PDT3h 3m
      or Best Offer

    Results Pagination - Page 1

    1. 1
    2. 2
    3. 3
    4. 4
    5. 5
    6. 6
    7. 7
    8. 8
    9. 9
    10. 10

    Additional site navigation

    • About eBay
    • Announcements
    • Community
    • Security Center
    • Seller Center
    • Policies
    • Affiliates
    • Help & Contact
    • Site Map
    Copyright © 1995-2023 eBay Inc. All Rights Reserved. Accessibility, User Agreement, Privacy, Payments Terms of Use, Cookies, Your Privacy Choices and AdChoice