 |
"Give me Liberty" was definitely an intriguing text that offers a unique perspective on American history, beginning with the traveling of the pilgrims to the reconstruction period. The text offers insight on all of the major documents and events that shaped the country, while also giving recognition to the individuals who helped form and lead the country. The text also keeps a theme of liberty and freedom-what each one meant to the groups experiencing it, and why each term has changed meanings over the years. The only criticism is that the text, like many other history books, fails to fully grasp and deeply discuss the American Indians and their own settelement of the country. It also doesn't thoroughly admit the hardships and troubles the natives faced, and offer a criticism of Andrew Jackson's failure to treat them humanely. The author definitely has bias in discussing men like Thomas Jefferson and Abe Lincoln-he tries to accuse the men of being bluntly racist and hateful against the blacks. He should admit that the cultural mindset of the 18th and 19th Centuries was vastly different than our mindset today, and that Jefferson, for example, definitely cared for his slaves and believed they could play a part in the country. The author could be too liberal or bias in his discussions, but nonetheless, he witfully proves his points. This is a history text worth reading because it does indeed offer valid insight. The text even gives stories, phrases from published speeches and writings, and interesting pictures to help guide the reader. It does not do a very good job of reviewing each chapter at the end of each chapter, but does offer definitions of terms and ideas, along with full historic documents such as The Declaration of Independence, Gettysburg Address, etc. Although the author (Eric Foner) cares about his work, it seems that he does judge our Nation's leaders a little too carelessly. If this were a presidential history course or political science course, that would be one thing. However, using this book for a history course, there should only be facts and legitimate stories, not critiques. The book is, however, very good in summarizing themes-making the readers think deeply about the ideas of 'liberty' and 'freedom'. It quite possibly is a valid book for 21st Century history students, because it is compelling and rigorous.Read full review
This history book is intended for college level students. It does not really give the reader any new information about America's past then any other grade school book. This 2nd edition, volume 1 is accompanied by Voices of Freedom, a smaller book that helps you better understand the history of America. If you buy the Give me Liberty, you should also consider Voices of Freedom. This book is a must-have for any History major.
Bought the book for US History class - was a good book ...
Current slide {CURRENT_SLIDE} of {TOTAL_SLIDES}- Best Selling in Textbooks
Current slide {CURRENT_SLIDE} of {TOTAL_SLIDES}- Save on Textbooks
Current slide {CURRENT_SLIDE} of {TOTAL_SLIDES}- You may also like
