Reviews
"[M]asterly . . . Gellately's latest work has a good claim to be the best single-volume account of the darkest period in Russian history." -The Economist "[A] refreshingly frank analysis. Not for [Gellately] is the revisionist notion that the US was as much to blame for the cold war as the Soviet Union . . . a powerful work of synthesis." -Robert Service, New Statesman "[M]asterful . . . [T]his book should become a go-to read on how the Cold War developed." -Jacob Sherman, Library Journal "[I]mpeccably researched and cogently argued . . . Gellately's intimate knowledge of the sources across Eastern European and of Russian archives compels us to accept his conclusions . . . The blame for the barren cul-de-sac down which global history strayed for nearly half a century has never been better diagnosed: It was Stalin's curse." -Andrew Roberts, The Wall Street Journal "Florida State University's Gellately ( Lenin, Stalin and Hitler ) adds to his distinguished body of work on 20th-century totalitarianism with this analysis of Stalin's conduct in international relations between 1939 and 1953 . . . Interweaving scholarship and the testimonies of those who suffered under Stalin's rule, Gellately's history is political and personal." - Publishers Weekly "Gellately here indicts Stalin as the primary instigator of the Cold War, marshaling evidence from Communist archives that undermines the revisionist case for Western responsibility for starting the confrontation . . . Gellately's fine contribution to Cold War studies will engage readers with its inside-the-Kremlin detail." -Gilbert Taylor, Booklist "[An] outstanding work . . . A prominent historian of Nazi Germany and Soviet Russia, Gellately offers a panoramic view of Stalin's political, diplomatic and psychological manoeuvres that allowed the USSR to achieve superpower status. The author has an encyclopedic knowledge of his subject and provides a compelling narrative of deception, brutality, foolishness and betrayed idealism." -Vladimir Tismaneanu, Times Higher Education "[M]asterful . . . historian Robert Gellately takes us back to square one. Whodunit? Stalin." -Katie Engelhart, Mclean's, "[M]asterly . . . Gellately's latest work has a good claim to be the best single-volume account of the darkest period in Russian history." --The Economist "[A] refreshingly frank analysis. Not for [Gellately] is the revisionist notion that the US was as much to blame for the cold war as the Soviet Union . . . a powerful work of synthesis." --Robert Service, New Statesman "[M]asterful . . . [T]his book should become a go-to read on how the Cold War developed." --Jacob Sherman, Library Journal "[I]mpeccably researched and cogently argued . . . Gellately's intimate knowledge of the sources across Eastern European and of Russian archives compels us to accept his conclusions . . . The blame for the barren cul-de-sac down which global history strayed for nearly half a century has never been better diagnosed: It was Stalin's curse." --Andrew Roberts, The Wall Street Journal "Florida State University's Gellately ( Lenin, Stalin and Hitler ) adds to his distinguished body of work on 20th-century totalitarianism with this analysis of Stalin's conduct in international relations between 1939 and 1953 . . . Interweaving scholarship and the testimonies of those who suffered under Stalin's rule, Gellately's history is political and personal." -- Publishers Weekly "[I]mpressive . . . This is a meticulously researched and well written study that makes extensive use of archival and other primary sources. In addition to the large amount of eye-opening information assembled the strength of the book is bolstered by a bracing critical approach." --Paul Hollander, Liberty and Law "Meticulously documented. One gets the feeling that Gellately is the sort of historian whose sleep would be disturbed by any suspicion that he might have made an error . . . Gellately's exhaustively researched and elegantly written book is a superb contribution to the scholarship of a time and place that remains a cautionary tale for the free world. --Rosemary Michaud, Charlestown Post and Courier "Gellately here indicts Stalin as the primary instigator of the Cold War, marshaling evidence from Communist archives that undermines the revisionist case for Western responsibility for starting the confrontation . . . Gellately's fine contribution to Cold War studies will engage readers with its inside-the-Kremlin detail." --Gilbert Taylor, Booklist "[E]ngaging . . . [Gellately is] an acute observer, so the book should reach a wide audience of interested readers. When confronting controversial questions he invariably demonstrates sound judgment and a willingness to allow for multiple interpretations . . . Gellately may be the first historian studying the Soviet side of the Cold War who has made such broad use of on-line archival sources, plus the rich document collections published on the Soviet Union and the Cold War since the turn of the century." --Norman M. Naimark, International Affairs (UK) "[An] outstanding work . . . A prominent historian of Nazi Germany and Soviet Russia, Gellately offers a panoramic view of Stalin's political, diplomatic and psychological manoeuvres that allowed the USSR to achieve superpower status. The author has an encyclopedic knowledge of his subject and provides a compelling narrative of deception, brutality, foolishness and betrayed idealism." --Vladimir Tismaneanu, Times Higher Education "[M]asterful . . . historian Robert Gellately takes us back to square one. Whodunit? Stalin." --Katie Engelhart, Mclean's, "Florida State University's Gellately ( Lenin, Stalin and Hitler ) adds to his distinguished body of work on 20th-century totalitarianism with this analysis of Stalin's conduct in international relations between 1939 and 1953 . . . Interweaving scholarship and the testimonies of those who suffered under Stalin's rule, Gellately's history is political and personal." - Publishers Weekly "Gellately here indicts Stalin as the primary instigator of the Cold War, marshaling evidence from Communist archives that undermines the revisionist case for Western responsibility for starting the confrontation . . . Gellately's fine contribution to Cold War studies will engage readers with its inside-the-Kremlin detail." -Gilbert Taylor, Booklist, "[M]asterly . . . Gellately's latest work has a good claim to be the best single-volume account of the darkest period in Russian history." -The Economist "[M]asterful . . . [T]his book should become a go-to read on how the Cold War developed." -Jacob Sherman, Library Journal "[I]mpeccably researched and cogently argued . . . Gellately's intimate knowledge of the sources across Eastern European and of Russian archives compels us to accept his conclusions . . . The blame for the barren cul-de-sac down which global history strayed for nearly half a century has never been better diagnosed: It was Stalin's curse." -Andrew Roberts, The Wall Street Journal "Florida State University's Gellately ( Lenin, Stalin and Hitler ) adds to his distinguished body of work on 20th-century totalitarianism with this analysis of Stalin's conduct in international relations between 1939 and 1953 . . . Interweaving scholarship and the testimonies of those who suffered under Stalin's rule, Gellately's history is political and personal." - Publishers Weekly "Gellately here indicts Stalin as the primary instigator of the Cold War, marshaling evidence from Communist archives that undermines the revisionist case for Western responsibility for starting the confrontation . . . Gellately's fine contribution to Cold War studies will engage readers with its inside-the-Kremlin detail." -Gilbert Taylor, Booklist "[An] outstanding work . . . A prominent historian of Nazi Germany and Soviet Russia, Gellately offers a panoramic view of Stalin's political, diplomatic and psychological manoeuvres that allowed the USSR to achieve superpower status. The author has an encyclopedic knowledge of his subject and provides a compelling narrative of deception, brutality, foolishness and betrayed idealism." -Vladimir Tismaneanu, Times Higher Education "[M]asterful . . . [T]his book should become a go-to read on how the Cold War developed." -Jacob Sherman, Library Journal, "Florida State University's Gellately ( Lenin, Stalin and Hitler ) adds to his distinguished body of work on 20th-century totalitarianism with this analysis of Stalin's conduct in international relations between 1939 and 1953…Interweaving scholarship and the testimonies of those who suffered under Stalin's rule, Gellately's history is political and personal." - Publishers Weekly, "[I]mpeccably researched and cogently argued . . . Gellately's intimate knowledge of the sources across Eastern European and of Russian archives compels us to accept his conclusions . . . The blame for the barren cul-de-sac down which global history strayed for nearly half a century has never been better diagnosed: It was Stalin's curse." -Andrew Roberts, The Wall Street Journal "Florida State University's Gellately ( Lenin, Stalin and Hitler ) adds to his distinguished body of work on 20th-century totalitarianism with this analysis of Stalin's conduct in international relations between 1939 and 1953 . . . Interweaving scholarship and the testimonies of those who suffered under Stalin's rule, Gellately's history is political and personal." - Publishers Weekly "Gellately here indicts Stalin as the primary instigator of the Cold War, marshaling evidence from Communist archives that undermines the revisionist case for Western responsibility for starting the confrontation . . . Gellately's fine contribution to Cold War studies will engage readers with its inside-the-Kremlin detail." -Gilbert Taylor, Booklist "[An] outstanding work . . . A prominent historian of Nazi Germany and Soviet Russia, Gellately offers a panoramic view of Stalin's political, diplomatic and psychological manoeuvres that allowed the USSR to achieve superpower status. The author has an encyclopedic knowledge of his subject and provides a compelling narrative of deception, brutality, foolishness and betrayed idealism." -Vladimir Tismaneanu, Times Higher Education
