 |
While this is certainly interesting reading, and full of a variety of information regarding LA history and the murder of Elizabeth Short-- the Black Dahlia-- in 1947, I am not convinced the case has been solved. Steve Hodel, former LAPD homicide detective, is a very readable author, and does his best to sell the case that his father Dr. George Hodel was the Dahlia's killer. I have no doubt Steve Hodel firmly believes his conclusions and is very sincere in presenting the facts, but I cannot help but notice holes throughout, which are not explained fully, or in some instances, bearly recognized. An investigation should never be undertaken with 'Here is the suspect, how do the facts/evidence confirm his guilt?'. I was forced to question the author's techniques of 'investigation' first when reading his comments on the Croton watch found at the crime scene. Hodel concludes, 'apparently the company is no longer in business.' If it wasn't for the fact the local radio station here gives away a Croton watch every day, I would have accepted his word as gospel. How many other opinions, or pieces of unfinished research might there be? Unfortunately, too many suppositions, 'facts' and portions of them, are presented in such a way that can only lead to the author's desired conclusion, and unless one chooses investigates further, that conclusion is too easy to agree with it. Is it not accepted that a serial killer's crimes 'escalate' over time? While other murders are credited to George Hotel and Fred Sexton by the author, none of them show the horrific extremes of Elizabeth Short. Could there have been that much going on with the LAPD to prevent them bringing a killer to justice, if Dr. Hotel was known to them as the man? And to suggest Short could be tortured, murdered, bisected, drained of blood and then washed clean-- in the family home?-- lacks evidence and is speculative in the extreme. While it is very interesting to read, Steve Hotel's work raises more doubts than conclusions in my mind. It leaves more questions than answers. And why did I buy this book? Having seen it featured in a TV program, I was interested in examining those photos from Dr. Hotel's album, that first started Steve on his quest. Sadly, the images are poorly reproduced in his book, and in fact could be anyone. I've got family photo albums full of Elizabeth Short, if that's the case. And the timeline provided at the end of the book is also based on a great deal of supposition. I am certain many people will claim this as this ultimate solution to the Black Dahlia murder. Sorry, but I'm not one of them.Read full review
My husband and I agree that Steve Hodel's book, The Black Dahlia Avenger, is probably the best theory as to who actually killed Elizabeth Short so many years ago. As a former L.A. policeman and detective, he gives his version of what went on within the confines of the L.A. ploice force at the time, as well as in his own life, to lead him to his conclusion. I found the book to be a quick read and an interesting one, too. Although there are many other fascinating theories, I have to side with his.
Paperback in great shape, very compelling story!
Verified purchase: Yes | Condition: Pre-owned
Good copy for the money
Verified purchase: Yes | Condition: Pre-owned
This is a different take on the unsolved murder. It was a grusome discovery and has held the public attention for over 65 years. The writing is good and it keeps your attention.
Current slide {CURRENT_SLIDE} of {TOTAL_SLIDES}- Best Selling in Books
Current slide {CURRENT_SLIDE} of {TOTAL_SLIDES}- Save on Books
Current slide {CURRENT_SLIDE} of {TOTAL_SLIDES}- You may also like
