Reviews
Professor Hanioglu's study, based on meticulous research of primary sources, deals with the social setting and intellectual sources that shaped the ideas that have directed Ataturk's actions and policies. The book not only helps demythologize Ataturk, it also provides a most valuable contribution to a better understanding of the state he founded. . . . Ataturk is indispensable reading for anyone who wishes to understand Turkey's politics. ---Sahin Alpay, Today's Zaman, A significant achievement, and indispensable for anyone seeking to understand the roots of modern Turkey., M. Sükrü Hanioglu's latest book, Atatürk: An Intellectual Biography , is probably the best book on Atatürk's legacy and his historic role. . . . Hanioglu managed to combine both impartiality and immediate access to Turkish sources to produce a classic. ---Herkül Millas, Today's Zaman, M. Sükrü Hanioglu probes the bold and pragmatic mind of Atatürk in his new book. . . . Hanioglu provides us with a fresh way to look at Atatürk., This work provides the essential intellectual framework to understand Atatürk and the enormity of his accomplishments., Professor Sükrü Hanioglu . . . combines elegance and meticulousness in Atatürk . ---Andrew Mango, Literary Review, "HanioÄŸlu does a stellar job highlighting the scientific trends Atatrk used to validate his Turkish national ideal. . . . Highly recommended." -- Library Journal, Hanioglu does a stellar job highlighting the scientific trends Atatürk used to validate his Turkish national ideal. . . . Highly recommended., "This is the best book on Mustafa Kemal Atatürk ever written. Hanioglu deals with virtually every single aspect of Atatürk's biography without drowning in the partisan battles surrounding it. I am certain that this powerful book will become a classic." --Cemil Aydin, author of The Politics of Anti-Westernism in Asia, "Atatrk does not lack for biographers, most of whose books are adulatory, but none has so thoroughly brought to life the ideological climate that molded the man as has HanioÄŸlu. And few have presented Atatrk with such objectivity." -- Foreign Affairs, "This book is aimed less at historians of the Ottoman Empire or of Turkey than at a wider public. It is a fine work of synthesis, fully accessible to non-specialists, which takes account of the complexity of the transitional period between the Ottoman Empire and the Republic of Turkey. Hanioglu's line of argument is perfectly clear and his account is easy to follow." --Cllia Delbarre, booksandideas.net, "Hanioglu does a stellar job highlighting the scientific trends Atatrk used to validate his Turkish national ideal. . . . Highly recommended." -- Library Journal, "Teachers of Turkish history in particular will be very grateful for this concise and accessible study of one of the most enduring national leaders of the twentieth century. . . . Hanio'lu's approach to Atatrk is helpful and refreshing." --Gavin D. Brockett, Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies, "[T]his intellectual biography is a significant achievement, and indispensable for anyone seeking to understand the roots of modern Turkey." -- Times Higher Education, "In this timely and brilliantly articulated book, Hanioglu reaffirms the need for an intimate understanding of historical context in biographical research. . . . This rich and exhaustively researched study is indispensible for academics and students of Turkish and Middle Eastern studies alike. It is the definitive biography of Atatrk and an instant classic in the field." --Douglas H. Garrison, Digest of Middle East Studies, "Professor Skr Hanioglu . . . combines elegance and meticulousness in Atatrk ." --Andrew Mango, Literary Review, Teachers of Turkish history in particular will be very grateful for this concise and accessible study of one of the most enduring national leaders of the twentieth century. . . . Hanioglu's approach to Atatürk is helpful and refreshing. ---Gavin D. Brockett, Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies, This book has the potential to inspire a new period of much needed assessment of Atatürk's thought, work and legacy. ---Rifat Kandiyoti, Political Quarterly, "Hanioglu has prepared a concise, compelling biography of the founder of modern Turkey, Mustafa Kemal Atatrk. He examines the political and intellectual movements that influenced Atatrk from his early school years until his death in 1938, along with the implementation of their ideas, which led to the development of the Republic of Turkey. . . . This work provides the essential intellectual framework to understand Ataturk and the enormity of his accomplishments." -- Choice, "One cannot understand what is happening in Turkey nowadays without taking an in-depth look at the life of the founder of the Republic of Turkey, Mustafa Kemal Atatrk. In this revised paperback edition of Atatrk: An Intellectual Biography , Skr Hanioglu attempts to demystify Atatrk and reassess his historical role and the impact of his legacy on modern Turkey." --Lisa Kaaki, Arab News, One cannot understand what is happening in Turkey nowadays without taking an in-depth look at the life of the founder of the Republic of Turkey, Mustafa Kemal Atatürk. In this revised paperback edition of Atatürk: An Intellectual Biography , Sükrü Hanioglu attempts to demystify Atatürk and reassess his historical role and the impact of his legacy on modern Turkey. ---Lisa Kaaki, Arab News, Professor Hanioglu has developed a well-informed and in-depth theoretical account, perhaps the most successful so far, of the ideological elements that shaped the ideas and mindset of Mustafa Kemal (later Atatürk). Although readers may be tempted to pass over yet another Atatürk biography, I would urge them to read this one. . . . [T]he present study will undoubtedly become an indispensable tool to historians of modern Turkey. It will be widely consulted by anyone seeking to understand not only the historical roots of modern Turkey, but also the present conditions in that society. Professor Hanioglu's essential biography places Atatürk firmly within his historical and intellectual contexts, offering to the public a solid, well-written and comprehensive study. ---Nikos Christofis, New Middle Eastern Studies, By setting [Ataturk's] remarkable achievements within their historical context, Mr Hanioglu has not only done him a service, he has also provided the reader a better understanding of the contradictions of the fascinating country that is modern Turkey. ---Kanika Datta, Business Standard, "Teachers of Turkish history in particular will be very grateful for this concise and accessible study of one of the most enduring national leaders of the twentieth century. . . . HanioÄŸlu's approach to Atatrk is helpful and refreshing." --Gavin D. Brockett, Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies, Hanioglu examines the development of his political philosophy in the context of historical events, allowing for better comparison between Ataturk's accomplishments and other statesmen of his time. Because of the care the author shows in establishing the international context, this book will be of interest to any student of political ideologies and the emergence of nation-states between the wars. ---Christianne Gates, History, "Cutting through years of writings filled with admiration for this charismatic leader and a popular sentiment close to hero worship, Hanio'lu performs a skillful analysis, focusing on the ideas and intellectual movements that shaped the statesman, rather than recounting Atatrk's personal life. . . . Hanioglu does a stellar job highlighting the scientific trends Atatrk used to validate his Turkish national ideal." -- Library Journal, "Learned and deeply insightful, this elegantly written book offers a unique perspective on the founder of modern Turkey. Hanioglu's exploration of the evolving ideas of Atatürk, their provenance and context, and their impact on the policies of the Turkish Republic is a singular contribution to understanding Atatürk and his legacy. It is also a brilliant intellectual and cultural history of his age, and a veritable model of how the intertwined paths of politics and the history of ideas can be explored through the medium of biography." --Muhammad Qasim Zaman, author of The Ulama in Contemporary Islam, Hanioglu's compelling book offers something that most Atatürk literature, particularly in Turkish, has yet to offer. It demythologizes the legendary soldier and politician by illustrating the social, intellectual, and political settings that influenced his ideals and which, in turn, led to the nation state of Turkey. . . . Atatürk: An Intellectual Biography will be a valuable source for amateur and professional students of both Turkish and Middle Eastern studies and for anyone who might wish to understand the deep political polarization between today's secular Turks who cling to Atatürk's dream and more religiously conservative-minded Turks who are retreating from the path on which he set the nation. ---Burak Bekdil, Middle East Quarterly, "Professor Hanioglu has developed a well-informed and in-depth theoretical account, perhaps the most successful so far, of the ideological elements that shaped the ideas and mindset of Mustafa Kemal (later Atatrk). Although readers may be tempted to pass over yet another Atatrk biography, I would urge them to read this one. . . . [T]he present study will undoubtedly become an indispensable tool to historians of modern Turkey. It will be widely consulted by anyone seeking to understand not only the historical roots of modern Turkey, but also the present conditions in that society. Professor Hanioglu's essential biography places Atatrk firmly within his historical and intellectual contexts, offering to the public a solid, well-written and comprehensive study." --Nikos Christofis, New Middle Eastern Studies, Atatürk does not lack for biographers, most of whose books are adulatory, but none has so thoroughly brought to life the ideological climate that molded the man as has Hanioglu. And few have presented Atatürk with such objectivity., This book breaks new ground in seeking to determine what Ataturk's reforms actually meant for their creator instead of trying to fit together his policies into a coherent doctrine called Ataturkism, as others have done. It is an important addition to the literature on the republic that Ataturk sought to define, and was determined to create. ---Clement Dodd, Journal of Islamic Studies, This book is aimed less at historians of the Ottoman Empire or of Turkey than at a wider public. It is a fine work of synthesis, fully accessible to non-specialists, which takes account of the complexity of the transitional period between the Ottoman Empire and the Republic of Turkey. Hanioglu's line of argument is perfectly clear and his account is easy to follow. ---Clélia Delbarre, booksandideas.net, "M. Skr Hanioglu probes the bold and pragmatic mind of Atatrk in his new book. . . . Hanioglu provides us with a fresh way to look at Atatrk." -- Saudi Gazette, "Teachers of Turkish history in particular will be very grateful for this concise and accessible study of one of the most enduring national leaders of the twentieth century. . . . Hanioglu's approach to Atatrk is helpful and refreshing." --Gavin D. Brockett, Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies, "M. Skr Hanioglu's latest book, Atatrk: An Intellectual Biography , is probably the best book on Atatrk's legacy and his historic role. . . . Hanioglu managed to combine both impartiality and immediate access to Turkish sources to produce a classic." --Herkl Millas, Today's Zaman, "Hanioglu has produced a work that is both accessible and intellectually stimulating. It is safe to say that there are few scholars alive today who are able to provide the rich historical perspective on Atatürk's life that Hanioglu provides here." --Benjamin C. Fortna, author of Imperial Classroom: Islam, the State, and Education in the Late Ottoman Empire, "This book has the potential to inspire a new period of much needed assessment of Atatrk's thought, work and legacy." --Rifat Kandiyoti, Political Quarterly, "Atatrk does not lack for biographers, most of whose books are adulatory, but none has so thoroughly brought to life the ideological climate that molded the man as has Hanioglu. And few have presented Atatrk with such objectivity." -- Foreign Affairs
