Skip to main content
eBay LogoeBay Logo

Shop by category

Advanced
  • Daily Deals
  • Gift Cards
  • Help & Contact
  • Sell More. Earn More. Shop More.
  • Sell
  • My eBayExpand My eBay
    • Summary
    • Recently Viewed
    • Bids/Offers
    • Watch List
    • Purchase History
    • Selling
    • Saved Searches
    • Saved Sellers
    • Messages
{"modules":["unloadOptimization","bandwidthDetection"],"unloadOptimization":{"browsers":{"Firefox":true,"Chrome":true}},"bandwidthDetection":{"url":"https://ir.ebaystatic.com/cr/v/c1/thirtysevens.jpg","maxViews":4,"imgSize":37,"expiry":300000,"timeout":250}}
{"delay":300}
  1. eBay
  2. eBay Stores
  3. vintagemagicthegathering
vintagemagicthegathering
vintagemagicthegathering

vintagemagicthegathering

1060followersvintagemagicllc(4085vintagemagicllc's feedback score is 4085) 99.5%vintagemagicllc has 99.5% Positive Feedback

Welcome to VintageMagic.com, LLC the world leader in vintage MTG rarities. Our eBay store offers the widest selection of artwork, sketches, artist proofs, altered & signed cards and graded & ungraded cards. Visit the Vintage Magic store @ www.vintagemagic.com for our complete inventory.

Side Refine Panel

  • Category

    • All
      • Alpha Edition
      • Altered Card(s)
      • Beta Edition
      • Booster Pack(s)
      • Commander (EDH)
      • Dual Lands
      • FOIL
      • Legacy
      • Legends
      • Mirage
      • Old School Magic
      • Power 9
      • Signed Card(s)
      • Singles :: Alpha Edition
      • Singles :: Antiquities
      • Singles :: Arabian Nights
      • Singles :: Beta Edition
      • Singles :: Graded :: BGS
      • Singles :: Graded :: PSA
      • Singles :: Legends
      • Singles :: Revised Edition
      • Singles :: Unlimited Edition
      • Singles | BGS 10 = PRISTINE
      • Singles | BGS 8.5 = NM/MINT+
      • Singles | BGS 9 = MINT
      • Singles | BGS 9.5 = GEM MINT
      • Summer Magic
      • The Dark
      • Weatherlight
      • Other

  • All

  • Auction

  • Buy It Now

  • Best Match
  • Time: ending soonest
  • Time: newly listed
  • Price + Shipping: lowest first
  • Price + Shipping: highest first
  • Distance: nearest first
List View

1-48 of 210 Results

  • Vintage Magic | MTG MINT Summer Magic Wheel of Fortune, BGS QUALITY, NO RESERVE

    Vintage Magic | MTG MINT Summer Magic Wheel of Fortune, BGS QUALITY, NO RESERVE

    $1,800.00
    32 bids
    $25.98 shipping
    Ending Today at 7:50PM PDT2h 17m
  • Vintage Magic | MTG MINT Summer Magic Wrath of God, BGS QUALITY, NO RESERVE!!!

    Vintage Magic | MTG MINT Summer Magic Wrath of God, BGS QUALITY, NO RESERVE!!!

    $710.00
    22 bids
    $25.98 shipping
    Ending Today at 7:42PM PDT2h 10m
  • Vintage Magic | 1x MTG Factory Sealed Ice Age Booster Pack | Necro/Snow/Brain???

    Vintage Magic | 1x MTG Factory Sealed Ice Age Booster Pack | Necro/Snow/Brain???

    $18.28
    $3.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
    7 watching
  • Vintage Magic | MTG MINT Summer Magic Blue Hurricane, BGS QUALITY, NO RESERVE!!!

    Vintage Magic | MTG MINT Summer Magic Blue Hurricane, BGS QUALITY, NO RESERVE!!!

    $2,771.00
    27 bids
    $29.98 shipping
    Ending Wednesday at 8:58PM PDT2d 3h
  • Vintage Magic | NM/MINT 4x MTG Unlimited Tropical Island, NO RESERVE!!!

    Vintage Magic | NM/MINT 4x MTG Unlimited Tropical Island, NO RESERVE!!!

    $940.00
    26 bids
    $29.99 shipping
    Ending Thursday at 1:14PM PDT2d 19h
  • Vintage Magic | MTG Beta Gaea's Liege | HP Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    Vintage Magic | MTG Beta Gaea's Liege | HP Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    $159.99
    $4.99 shipping
    or Best Offer
  • Vintage Magic | 4x ALTERED & SIGNED MTG Antiquities Urza's Mine by Anson

    Vintage Magic | 4x ALTERED & SIGNED MTG Antiquities Urza's Mine by Anson

    $179.98
    $9.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
  • Vintage Magic | 1 x MTG Signed Ice Age Brainstorm by Christopher Rush | NM/Mint

    Vintage Magic | 1 x MTG Signed Ice Age Brainstorm by Christopher Rush | NM/Mint

    $61.98
    $5.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
    8 watching
  • Vintage Magic | MTG Alpha Savannah Lions | NM/Mint Condition, RARE, BUYOUT!!!

    Vintage Magic | MTG Alpha Savannah Lions | NM/Mint Condition, RARE, BUYOUT!!!

    $2,499.99
    $29.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
    10 watching
  • Vintage Magic | MTG Arabian Nights Erhnam Djinn | Near MINT OLD SCHOOL/COMMANDER

    Vintage Magic | MTG Arabian Nights Erhnam Djinn | Near MINT OLD SCHOOL/COMMANDER

    $299.99
    $12.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
  • Vintage Magic | MTG MINT PSA 9 Alpha Psychic Venom | OLD SCHOOL!!!

    Vintage Magic | MTG MINT PSA 9 Alpha Psychic Venom | OLD SCHOOL!!!

    $199.99
    $14.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
  • Vintage Magic | MTG Weatherlight Lotus Vale, NM/Mint Condition, RARE!!!

    Vintage Magic | MTG Weatherlight Lotus Vale, NM/Mint Condition, RARE!!!

    $49.99
    $4.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
    13 watching
  • Vintage Magic | Factory Sealed Arabian Nights Booster Box | Juzam/Bazaar/Library

    Vintage Magic | Factory Sealed Arabian Nights Booster Box | Juzam/Bazaar/Library

    $299,999.88
    or Best Offer
    FAST 'N FREE
    418 watching
  • Vintage Magic | MTG Alpha Drain Power | LP Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    Vintage Magic | MTG Alpha Drain Power | LP Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    $459.99
    $15.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
  • Vintage Magic | MTG Alpha Wheel of Fortune | HP Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    Vintage Magic | MTG Alpha Wheel of Fortune | HP Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    $3,299.99
    $29.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
  • Vintage Magic | MTG Beta Northern Paladin | HP Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    Vintage Magic | MTG Beta Northern Paladin | HP Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    $159.99
    $4.99 shipping
    or Best Offer
  • Vintage Magic | MTG Alpha COMPLETE BASIC LAND SET [10x Cards], OLD SCHOOL!!!

    Vintage Magic | MTG Alpha COMPLETE BASIC LAND SET [10x Cards], OLD SCHOOL!!!

    $639.99
    $14.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
    12 watching
  • Vintage Magic | MTG Legends Land Tax, NM+ Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    Vintage Magic | MTG Legends Land Tax, NM+ Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    $89.99
    $9.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
  • Vintage Magic | MTG Alpha Fireball | NM/MINT Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    Vintage Magic | MTG Alpha Fireball | NM/MINT Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    $199.99
    $9.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
  • Vintage Magic | MTG Unlimited Armageddon | NM/MINT Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    Vintage Magic | MTG Unlimited Armageddon | NM/MINT Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    $199.99
    $9.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
  • Vintage Magic | MTG Nemesis FOIL Daze | NM/MINT, Legacy, Commander, PIMP!!!

    Vintage Magic | MTG Nemesis FOIL Daze | NM/MINT, Legacy, Commander, PIMP!!!

    $99.98
    $9.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
  • Vintage Magic | MTG Beta Clone | HP Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    Vintage Magic | MTG Beta Clone | HP Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    $59.99
    $4.99 shipping
    or Best Offer
  • Vintage Magic | MTG Legends Rasputin Dreamweaver, NM/Mint+ Condition, COMMANDER

    Vintage Magic | MTG Legends Rasputin Dreamweaver, NM/Mint+ Condition, COMMANDER

    $149.99
    $11.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
  • Vintage Magic | MTG 3rd Edition/Revised Booster Pack | Sea/Island/Tundra/Bayou??

    Vintage Magic | MTG 3rd Edition/Revised Booster Pack | Sea/Island/Tundra/Bayou??

    $299.99
    $9.98 shipping
    16 watching
  • Vintage Magic | MTG Alpha Channel | NM/MINT+ Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    Vintage Magic | MTG Alpha Channel | NM/MINT+ Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    $299.99
    $14.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
  • Vintage Magic | MTG Arabian Nights City of Brass | LP Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    Vintage Magic | MTG Arabian Nights City of Brass | LP Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    $349.99
    $13.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
  • Vintage Magic | MTG Alpha Disintegrate | MINT Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    Vintage Magic | MTG Alpha Disintegrate | MINT Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    $129.99
    $9.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
  • Vintage Magic | MTG Beta Icy Manipulator | HP Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    Vintage Magic | MTG Beta Icy Manipulator | HP Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    $275.99
    $12.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
  • Vintage Magic | MTG Unlimited Goblin King | NM/MINT Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    Vintage Magic | MTG Unlimited Goblin King | NM/MINT Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    $89.99
    $9.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
  • Vintage Magic | MTG Legends Thunder Spirit | NM/Mint Condition | RESERVE LIST!!!

    Vintage Magic | MTG Legends Thunder Spirit | NM/Mint Condition | RESERVE LIST!!!

    $259.99
    $9.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
    Only 1 left!
  • Vintage Magic | BGS 9.5 MTG Unlimited Bayou, QUAD, RESERVE LIST!!!

    Vintage Magic | BGS 9.5 MTG Unlimited Bayou, QUAD, RESERVE LIST!!!

    $1,999.99
    $24.99 shipping
    or Best Offer
  • Vintage Magic | MTG Beta Hypnotic Specter | HP Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    Vintage Magic | MTG Beta Hypnotic Specter | HP Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    $260.99
    $13.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
  • Vintage Magic | MTG Unlimited Copy Artifact, EX/MINT Condition, RESERVE LIST!!!

    Vintage Magic | MTG Unlimited Copy Artifact, EX/MINT Condition, RESERVE LIST!!!

    $199.98
    $9.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
  • Vintage Magic | MTG Alpha Demonic Attorney | NM/MINT Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    Vintage Magic | MTG Alpha Demonic Attorney | NM/MINT Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    $699.99
    $19.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
  • Vintage Magic | MTG 1993 Alpha Starter Deck Rule Book from Starter Deck!!!

    Vintage Magic | MTG 1993 Alpha Starter Deck Rule Book from Starter Deck!!!

    $298.88
    $9.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
    14 watching
  • Vintage Magic | MTG Arabian Nights Khabal Ghoul | Moderately Played RESERVE LIST

    Vintage Magic | MTG Arabian Nights Khabal Ghoul | Moderately Played RESERVE LIST

    $79.98
    $9.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
  • Vintage Magic | MTG Beta Ice Storm | MP Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    Vintage Magic | MTG Beta Ice Storm | MP Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    $125.99
    $9.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
  • Vintage Magic | MTG Color Painted Alpha Altered Revised Plateau by Tucker - PIMP

    Vintage Magic | MTG Color Painted Alpha Altered Revised Plateau by Tucker - PIMP

    $459.99
    $14.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
    Only 1 left!
  • Vintage Magic | MTG Beta Animate Dead, NEAR MINT Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    Vintage Magic | MTG Beta Animate Dead, NEAR MINT Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    $299.99
    $15.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
  • Vintage Magic | Signed MTG Beta Pirate Ship, LIGHTLY INKED, RARE SIGNATURE!!!

    Vintage Magic | Signed MTG Beta Pirate Ship, LIGHTLY INKED, RARE SIGNATURE!!!

    $349.99
    $15.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
  • FACTORY SEALED Pokemon Unlimited Neo Revelation Booster Pack, BGS/PSA/HOLOFOIL?

    FACTORY SEALED Pokemon Unlimited Neo Revelation Booster Pack, BGS/PSA/HOLOFOIL?

    $119.98
    $9.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
  • Vintage Magic | MTG Alpha Shivan Dragon | NM/MINT Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    Vintage Magic | MTG Alpha Shivan Dragon | NM/MINT Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    $9,999.99
    $49.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
    18 watching
  • Vintage Magic | MTG Legends Willow Satyr, NM/MINT+ Condition, RESERVE LIST!!!

    Vintage Magic | MTG Legends Willow Satyr, NM/MINT+ Condition, RESERVE LIST!!!

    $149.99
    $9.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
  • Vintage Magic | MTG Alpha Serra Angel | HP Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    Vintage Magic | MTG Alpha Serra Angel | HP Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    $699.99
    $19.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
    11 watching
  • Vintage Magic | MTG Alpha Lightning Bolt | EX/MINT Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    Vintage Magic | MTG Alpha Lightning Bolt | EX/MINT Condition, OLD SCHOOL!!!

    $599.99
    $14.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
  • Vintage Magic | MTG PRISTINE BGS 10 3rd Edition/Revised Taiga

    Vintage Magic | MTG PRISTINE BGS 10 3rd Edition/Revised Taiga

    $1,999.99
    $24.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
    14 watching
  • Vintage Magic | MTG Legends Pack | Vale/Moat/Eureka/Mana/Abyss/Chains/Void/Plane

    Vintage Magic | MTG Legends Pack | Vale/Moat/Eureka/Mana/Abyss/Chains/Void/Plane

    $699.99
    $19.98 shipping
    or Best Offer
    Only 1 left!
  • Vintage Magic | 1993 SIGNED MTG Antiquities Tawnos Coffin | MINT, RESERVE LIST!!

    Vintage Magic | 1993 SIGNED MTG Antiquities Tawnos Coffin | MINT, RESERVE LIST!!

    $299.99
    $10.98 shipping
    or Best Offer

Results Pagination - Page 1

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Additional site navigation

  • About eBay
  • Announcements
  • Community
  • Security Center
  • Resolution Center
  • Seller Center
  • Policies
  • Affiliates
  • Help & Contact
  • Site Map
Copyright © 1995-2019 eBay Inc. All Rights Reserved. Accessibility, User Agreement, Privacy, Cookies and AdChoiceNorton Secured - powered by Verisign