Featured categories
Best Sellers
All items

Please Return to Tiffany Silver Heart Tag Toggle Necklace in Silver AUTHENTIC
$699.00

Tiffany Match Stick Pendant Charm in Rose Gold and Blue Enamel Fire and Ice
$599.00

15.5” Please Return To Tiffany & Co Sterling Silver Oval Tag Choker Necklace
$399.00

8” Tiffany & Co Mens Unisex Venetian Box Link Bracelet in Sterling Silver
$289.00

32" Tiffany & Co Sterling Silver Men's Unisex Snake Chain Necklace
$149.00

Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Toggle Necklace 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 Inch New Version
$699.00 to $775.00

Tiffany Gold Ampersand & Sign in 18K Yellow Gold
$399.00

Medium-Large 8" Tiffany & Co Blank Heart Tag Charm Bracelet in Sterling Silver
$249.00

Tiffany & Co Belt Buckle Sterling Silver Coin Edge Groove Mens Unisex
$545.00

NEW Tiffany & Co Black Leather Mens Belt Size 38 Calf Skin
$195.00

Tiffany & Co NEW Empty Blue Box Suede Pouch Gift Bag Polishing Cloth Packaging
$9.99 to $59.00

Size 6.5 Return to Tiffany New York Ring in Sterling Silver Authentic FREE Ship
$349.00

Customized Return to Tiffany Heart Tag New York Necklace 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 Inch
$599.00 to $799.00

Tiffany Jump Ring Oval Clasping Link Spring Charm or Pendant Holder
$99.00

Tiffany & Co 18" Silver Round Link Rolo Chain Necklace Mens Unisex
$495.00

Tiffany & Co 24" Mens Unisex Silver Large Round 11mm Link Rolo Chain Necklace
$649.00

Size 4.5 Tiffany & Co 1837 Makers ID Signet Ring in Sterling Silver
$350.00

7.5" Return To Tiffany Oval Tag Charm Bracelet Medium Size in Silver
$349.00

Tiffany & Co Return To Tiffany Heart Tag Toggle Necklace in Sterling Silver 16.5
$699.00

18" Please Return to Tiffany Lovestruck Heart Tag Arrow Toggle Necklace
$299.00

Tiffany Blue Enamel Oval Clasping Link Jump Ring Charm Bracelet Length Extender
$149.95

Tiffany Gold Fascination Ball Charm or Pendant in Yellow Gold and Silver
$199.00

Jumbo Extra Large Please Return to Tiffany & Co Heart Tag Pendant or Charm
$399.00

Please Return to Tiffany Extra Large Heart Tag Pendant or Charm 1.2"
$219.00

18" Return To Tiffany & Co Circle Round Tag Necklace in Sterling Silver
$549.99

Size 9.5 Tiffany & Co 1837 Ring Concave in Sterling Silver
$245.00

Tiffany Silver Letter M Alphabet Initial Round Circle Notes Charm Pendant
$169.99

Tiffany Airplane Plane Pendant or Charm in Sterling Silver Italy FREE Shipping
$498.00

Size 10 Tiffany & Co Somerset Mesh Dome Weave Mens Unisex Ring in Silver
$299.00

8.5" Tiffany and Co Large Venetian Box Link Bracelet Mens Unisex Sterling Silver
$289.00

Medium 7.5” Please Return to Tiffany Round Tag Circle Charm Bracelet AUTHENTIC
$299.00

18" RARE Tiffany & Co Oval Link Chain Necklace in Sterling Silver AUTHENTIC
$249.00

Tiffany & Co Black Lizard Skin Leather Mens Belt Size 46
$265.00

Tiffany & Co Blue Enamel Heart Tag Charm or Pendant in Sterling Silver
$259.00

Tiffany Silver Letter S Alphabet Initial Round Circle Notes Charm Pendant
$129.00

18" Tiffany 3mm Large Link Chain Necklace in Sterling Silver
$269.00

LARGE 0.50" Return to Tiffany & Co Heart Tag Stud Earrings
$469.00

Size 11 Tiffany & Co Midnight Black Coin Edge Titanium and Silver Ring
$475.00

Tiffany & Co Bracelet Classic Rolo Chain Link in Sterling Silver
$189.00

7.5” Tiffany & Co Venetian Box Link Bracelet in Sterling Silver
$249.00

Size 11 Tiffany & Co Metropolis Ring Mens Band Unisex in Sterling Silver
$599.00

8 inch Tiffany & Co Blank Heart Tag Charm Bracelet in Sterling Silver
$249.00

7" SMALL Please Return to Tiffany & Co Heart Tag Charm Bracelet in Silver
$349.00

24" Tiffany & Co Chain Necklace Mens Unisex 3mm Large Link in Sterling Silver
$349.00

6.5" Small Please Return to Tiffany & Co Silver Heart Tag Charm Bracelet
$349.00

16.5" Please Return to Tiffany & Co Heart Tag Toggle Necklace Newest Version
$699.00

15.5" Please Return To Tiffany New York Oval Tag Choker Necklace in Silver
$399.00

1 Vintage Return to Tiffany Heart or Oval Tag Pendant Charm in Sterling Silver
$74.99
About us
Here at The Silver Trove we sell pre-loved Tiffany & Co jewelry. We scour the internet, estate sales, antique stores, auction houses and anywhere else we might find pre-loved Tiffany jewelry. After determining each piece to be authentic with our extensive knowledge of fine jewelry, we will clean & polish every piece before listing it here for our customers. We love our job and are confident you will love any piece you buy from us.
Seller feedback (10,951)
- r***e (1401)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseAs described. Prompt communication. I paid for overnight priority express shipping and yet it took three days. But the seller did ship it via priority express, so I can't fault them for it.
- s***f (219)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseI was skeptical to purchase my dream jewelry piece from eBay. New pieces from Tiffany’s are quite expensive but I needed a necklace to match my bracelet that I purchased a decade ago which Tiffany no longer makes. I took a chance with this seller and I’m so glad I did! The piece arrived in excellent condition and the links I had added to it for longer length look well placed. The seller was patient with my many questions. I recommend them highly. Thank you. A+ sellers!
- 1***f (1115)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseExactly as described, great communication, well packaged, and quick shipping. I highly recommend this seller.
- a***i (3876)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseVery classy Tiffany in Fire & Ice series pendant, excellent condition as described, super fast shipping, well packaged, modestly priced . Superior customer service from the Silver Trove.
- e***x (3)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseArrived late, which in fairness was USPS. However when it arrived both ends of the box were open/untaped and the contents were completely exposed/ accessible! The contents almost slid completely out of the box when removed from my mailbox. Items were in a pouch, in a single sheet of tissue paper. No inner box, bubble wrap, tape, nor any real protection. Amazed they weren't stolen or lost in transit. Mildly disappointing for a $1300 purchase. Jewelry quality seems great though (will update later)
- b***b (51)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseShipping was quick. Packaging was beautiful. Product is as described. The value was perfect. Communication was on point. Would definitely buy again. A+