448 items sold
74 followers
Contact

All items

Vintage Skipper Doll Blonde #0950 with Box Swimsuit Barbie’s Sister 1963 Japan

$79.95

Vintage 70s Holly Hobbie Valentine Cards Envelopes AGC American Greetings (11)

$29.95

Barbie Stardoll Fallen Angel Doll Style 1 2011 Red Black Hair Dress Near Complet

$69.95

Littlest Pet Shop Fanciest Pet Pairs #639 Dachshund And #640 Corgi Authentic LPS

$99.95

Barbie Expressions of India Wedding Fantasy Doll Special Edition Mattel Complete

$99.95

Vintage Stationary Folder Set Red Hearts 15 Letter Sheets 15 Envelopes SEALED

$19.95

Lot Of 14 Vintage Fisher Price Sweet Streets People Figures Dolls

$44.95

Mary Meyer Putty Puppy Dog Lovey Security Blanket Plush

$6.95

My Little Pony Nightmare Night Collection Derpy Hooves Mini Figure Missing Bag

$29.95

Build A Bear Workshop Minions Tim Bob’s Teddy Bear Plush Accessory Mini Toy

$24.95

Vintage Hasbro My Little Pony Firefly G1 Stampos Rubber Stamp

$24.95

My Little Pony G4 Cutie Mark Magic Sweetie Drops Bon Bon 2010 Hasbro

$34.95

Vintage Barbie Deluxe Victorian Dream House Fireplace Screen Replacement

$18.95

Woolrich Women's Sz Medium Ruby Stripe Southwestern Aztec Boho Long Coat Wool M

$54.95

Barbie Stardoll Pretty N Love 2 Blonde Original Outfit Excellent Condition Rare

$59.95

Eloise Doll 8" Vinyl Poseable Kay Thompson Book Character Vintage 1999 Yottoy

$19.95

Hasbro 1996 Gi Joe Classic Collection Arctic Mountaineer Mission Gear NIP

$14.95

Fisher Price Loving Family Home Holidays Dollhouse Christmas Gifts Presents

$12.95

JELLYCAT London Cream Beige FUDDLEWUDDLE LAMB 9” Sitting Soft Beanie Plush

$24.95

Lane Bryant Cacique Unlined Full Coverage Bold Lace NWOT 46K Nude Beige

$24.95

Barbie Happy Family Pregnant Midge & Baby Brown Hair Eyes RARE Pink Dress

$149.95

Royal Haeger Pottery Glossy Blue Green Teal Swan 20" Tall Vintage Statue USA

$99.95

Rainbow High Fantastic Fashion Poppy Rowan Brand New In Box Orange Butterflies

$114.95

Disney Parks Happy Halloween 2020 Countdown Calendar Micky Minnie Candy Corn

$49.95

Vintage Fisher Price Fun With Food Baby’s Mealtime Set Plate Dish Replacement

$7.95

Bratz Shania Style It 10" Doll VERY RARE HTF Excellent Condition Complete

$79.95

Baby First TV Color Crew Pair Talking Crayon Plush Yellow Green Video Of Working

$44.95

1997 Hasbro Kenner GI Joe Classic Collection General George S. Patton 12" NIB

$44.95

My Little Pony Series 3 Pinkie Pie #F57 Promo Foil Trading Card

$39.95

Hallmark Disney WORKS Mickey’s Wireless Band MINNIE PLAYS PIANO Christmas VIDEO!

$89.95

Vintage 1993 Fisher Price Puffalump Cow Plush Stuffed Animal 11" Black White

$149.95

Barbie Princess Charm School Delancy Doll 2010 Mattel Nearly Complete RARE

$34.95

Lalaloopsy Goldie Luxe PEACOCK Pet Animal Bird Toys Gold 2012 Pink 3.5 Plastic

$9.95

American Girl Isabelle’s Pet White Cat Tutu Stuffed Animal Kitten Plush 6" 2013

$18.95

Vintage Teeny Tiny Tumbles Surprise 3 Mini Dolls Toy Biz 1996

$19.95

My Little Pony G1 Secret Surprise Secret Beauty MLP

$45.00

My Little Pony G1 Vintage Baby Brightbow Pegasus 1984

$19.95

Glow In The Dark Poopsie Cutie Tooties Series 1 CT-118 Shadow Figure

$12.95

My Little Pony Pajama Party Gummy Snap Pet Alligator Pinkie Pie Rainbow Rocks

$12.95

Hallmark Rhonda Reindeer Bean Bag Burger King Christmas Rodney & Friends 1987

$12.95

Vintage My Little Pony Precious Pocket Ponies Bubblefish 1991 G1 RARE

$19.95

Disney Pixar Cars 2 ERIC ROADALES Deluxe NitroAde Piston Cup 2015

$12.95

Vintage Windsport Windsox FRANKENSTEIN Windsock Halloween Decoration

$89.99

Bratz Play Sportz Yasmin Fashionably Fit Fashion Doll NIB RARE

$48.99

My Little Pony SKYWISHES Sky Wishes Cutie Mark Magic Brushable G4 MLP

$29.95

Disney Store Animators Collection Plush TICK TOCK Baby Croc 6" Peter Pan

$12.95

Tyco 1993 Puppy Puppy Puppies Grey White and Black Puppy RARE VHTF

$49.95

Torrid Red Faux Suede Rhinestone Bow Block Heel Size 8.5 Wide Width New In Box

$45.00

About us

Welcome to my tiny shop of horrors! Just kidding, welcome to my tiny shop of nostalgic fabulousness! Finding the treasures we all treasured as kids and wish to love again as adult sized kids and putting them back in your clutches.

If there is something you’re looking for that’s similar to other things in my shop, please let me know! I have much more to add and just might have something you’re looking for. Always happy to combine shipping and answer any questions you might have, just shoot me a message!
Location: United StatesMember since: Feb 26, 2009Seller: jennyferjo
Top Rated SellerNite Owl Nostalgia is one of eBay's most reputable sellers. Consistently delivers outstanding customer service Learn more

Detailed seller ratings

Average for the last 12 months
Accurate description
5.0
Reasonable shipping cost
4.8
Shipping speed
5.0
Communication
5.0

Seller feedback (148)

  • b***s (46)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    The pony looks gorgeous, just as described and shown in photos! It was shipped fast, in a very good packaging! A good price for such a good-looking pony🌼 I can highly recommend buying from this seller😊🌸
  • 7***6 (59)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    I purchased a 2.5" MLP Spike figure from this seller for a good price. There was a mixup with my order but upon reaching out to the seller I was pleasantly surprised by their professionalism and they were quick to fix the issue! Great communication and fast shipping. A pleasant buying experience!
  • r***a (627)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    Great seller! Well packed and described, with fast shipping!
  • 8***n (60)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    Brand new as described- reasonably priced - shipping time was good and fairly priced. Great buying experience overall. Thanks!
  • o***d (41)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past year
    Verified purchase
    love this purchasing experience. The seller is excellent, they mailed out my purchase quickly and it arrived in the condition advertised. So glad to have this shoe in my collection.
  • a***a (6)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past month
    Verified purchase
    She's been absolutely perfectly packaged and shipped quickly. She's beautiful and just ad described! So happy to add her to my herd