9.4K items sold
174 followers
Contact

All items

Disney Frozen Light Up Wand, 9" Blip Toy Party Favor, Anna Elsa Girls Accessory

$9.99

Lego Friends Chocolate Box & Flower Set #30411 Girls Christmas Stocking Stuffer

$5.95Save up to 10% when you buy more

Imaginext Toy Story 4 Figures Forky & Woody Fisher Price Disney Pixar Set

$7.95

Marvel Iron Man Plush Avengers Endgame 8" Sitting Kuricha Bleacher Creatures NWT

$11.95

Captain Marvel Plush Goose 8" Kuricha Bleacher Creatures Sitting Plushie Cat

$11.95

Imaginext Toy Story 4 Gift Set w/ 8 Figures ~ Woody Forky Bo Peep Buzz Lightyear

$19.95

Marvel Captain America Plush 8" Sitting Kuricha Bleacher Creatures Avengers NWT

$11.95

Ron & Fez Big A.S.S. Night Of Fights Ticket WNEW 102.7 FM Talk Radio Promo NYC

$99.95

Trolls World Tour Sparkle Dome Surprise Figure w/ Globe Snow Powder & Glitter

$4.95Save up to 10% when you buy more

Disney Pixar Toy Story Kids LCD Wrist Watch ~ BATTERY NEEDED

$7.99

Star Wars Princess Leia Organa Figure VTG 1977 Kenner Hong Kong Original Cape

$74.95

Barbie Holiday Mini Figure w/ Candy Cane Stripe Dress 4" Doll Stocking Stuffer

$7.95Save up to 10% when you buy more

Funko My Little Pony MyMoji Vinyl Figure Lot of 3 Blind Bags Stocking Stuffer

$9.95

Mega Bloks Skylanders Swap Force Series 3 Battle Portal w/ Trigger Happy Figure

$9.99Save up to 15% when you buy more

My Little Pony Shutterfly Figure NIB 3" Mini MLP Brushable Doll Hasbro 2017

$9.95

Tonka Metal Diecast Bodies Vintage Police Cruiser Holiday Edition 2015

$7.95Save up to 10% when you buy more

SpongeBob Squarepants 8" Plush Patrick RARE 2020 Sponge On The Run Movie Toy

$14.95

Muppet Babies Schoolhouse Playset w/ Kermit The Frog Figure, Disney Junior Toy

$39.95

Captain Marvel Plush 8" Kuricha Bleacher Creatures Avengers Sitting Plushie NWT

$11.95

Disney Aladdin Princess Jasmine Figure (Green), Live Action Movie 4" Mini Doll

$4.99

Disney Frozen Neon Glow Band, Elsa Dress Up Crown, Girls Hair Accessory Tiara

$4.95

Disney Aladdin Genie Figure, Live Action Movie 4" Mini Doll

$4.99

Lego Mini Figure Santa Claus From City Christmas Advent Calendar Sealed Minifig

$7.95

SpongeBob Squarepants 9" Plush RARE 2020 Sponge On The Run Movie Toy Authentic

$14.95

Disney Junior Sofia The First Girls LCD Wrist Watch ~ BATTERY NEEDED

$7.99

Holiday Troll Doll Pencil Topper 1" PVC Mini Figure Green Hair Vintage 90s

$4.95

Lego Friends Pop Star Red Carpet Andrea Minifigure Set #30205

$5.95

Animal Planet Micro Kingdom Dino Quake Collectible Minatures Dinosaur Set (1A)

$49.95

Disney Frozen II Anna Fashion Doll 12" Hasbro Collectible Brand New In Box

$9.95

Maxx Action Helicopter Fire & Rescue Vehicle w/ Lights & Sound 5" Ages 5+ NEW

$12.95

Trolls World Tour Tiny Dancers Mini Figure & Glasses Blind Pack Stocking Stuffer

$1.95Save up to 10% when you buy more

Digimon Digivolving Imperialdramon 6" Figure Fighter Mode, Bandai 2001 RARE

$99.95

Hardcore Homecoming ECW Ticket & Program Extreme Wrestling Reunion WWE History

$150.00

Wood Pull Toy Wizard of Oz Yellow Brick Road 75th Anniversary Holiday Exclusive

$14.95

PJ Masks Collectible Mini Figure In Valentines Day Heart Container Blind Pack #2

$2.98

Lego Friends Stephanie's Hockey Practice Set #30405

$6.95

Disney Aladdin Princess Jasmine Figure (Pink), Live Action Movie 4" Mini Doll

$4.99

Dizzy Doodler Chatter Heads Motorized Pen Wiggles (Orange) VTG 90s Collectible

$49.95

True Legends Heroes Of Olympus Huge Set w/ War Ship Octopus Figures Weapons RARE

$175.00

Superman Vs Batman Epic Battle Action Figure w/ Hammer 6" DC Movie Mattel Toy

$9.95

Pattern Plush Merry Bear, Manhattan Toy High Quality Holiday Stuffed Animal 12"

$14.95

DC Justice League Batgirl Pop Up Plush 3.5" Figure, Batman Collectible

$2.95

Vince McMahon WWF Wrestling Action Figure, Vintage 90s Jakks Pacific WWE BCA

$9.95

Vintage Sifo Wood Puzzle "Dog Pal" 9x12 Complete w/ All 25 Pieces 60s 70s

$24.95

Transformers G1 Blitzwing Gyro Blaster Rifle Part 4 Original Gun 1985 VTG Weapon

$7.95

Transformers G1 Aerialbot Fireflight Factory Sealed Unpunched VTG 1986 Hasbro

$375.00

Marvel Avengers Hulk Clip On Square Plush, 6" Keychain Figure

$4.95

VTG Fisher Price S'getti Scatter Food Game RARE 90s Spaghetti Meatballs Toy NIB

$99.95

About us

All toys welcome at Misfit Collectibles! Discover nostalgic goodness from the 70s, 80s, 90s and beyond. We buy vintage toys including Transformers, Star Wars action figures, G.I. Joe ARAH, WWF, and other pop culture favorites. If you're in New Jersey or the surrounding area, bring your collection to us for cash! We can also come to you and dig those old unwanted toys out of your home.

This vintage toy shop is owned by a lifelong collector with 25+ years experience.

Order pick up available on select listings by appointment only in Rockaway, NJ.
Location: United StatesMember since: Jan 25, 1999Seller: misfit_collectibles
Top Rated SellerMisfit Collectibles is one of eBay's most reputable sellers. Consistently delivers outstanding customer service Learn more

Store policies

Returns
Shipping

Detailed seller ratings

Average for the last 12 months
Accurate description
5.0
Reasonable shipping cost
4.9
Shipping speed
5.0
Communication
5.0

Seller feedback (3,824)

  • k***u (162)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past month
    Verified purchase
    Thank you. Fast shipping and well packaged. Exactly as described!
  • 7***e (2)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    Packaged very nicely and securely. I appreciated the fast shipping and how the pony was in great condition. Recommend the seller!
  • e***r (1698)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    Item arrived very quickly and just as described! Very happy customer! Highly recommended seller!
  • i***l (222)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past month
    Verified purchase
    Item was extremely affordable and shipping was quick. I def. Will be purchasing from here again. Thanks for a great experience.
  • z***g (320)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    great looking conversation piece. Good seller fast delivery
  • g***a (93)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    Communication was great and answered all my questions. Shipping was fast and item was better than expected. One of my grail pieces I’ve being looking for MIB.