Featured categories
Featured items
Holiday Collection
All items
$9.99
$5.95
$7.95
$11.95
$11.95
$19.95
$11.95
$99.95
$4.95
$7.99
$74.95
$7.95
$9.95
$9.99
$9.95
$7.95
$14.95
$39.95
$11.95
$4.99
$4.95
$4.99
$7.95
$14.95
$7.99
$4.95
$5.95
$49.95
$9.95
$12.95
$1.95
$99.95
$150.00
$14.95
$2.98
$6.95
$4.99
$49.95
$175.00
$9.95
$14.95
$2.95
$9.95
$24.95
$7.95
$375.00
$4.95
$99.95
About us
All toys welcome at Misfit Collectibles! Discover nostalgic goodness from the 70s, 80s, 90s and beyond. We buy vintage toys including Transformers, Star Wars action figures, G.I. Joe ARAH, WWF, and other pop culture favorites. If you're in New Jersey or the surrounding area, bring your collection to us for cash! We can also come to you and dig those old unwanted toys out of your home.
This vintage toy shop is owned by a lifelong collector with 25+ years experience.
Order pick up available on select listings by appointment only in Rockaway, NJ.
This vintage toy shop is owned by a lifelong collector with 25+ years experience.
Order pick up available on select listings by appointment only in Rockaway, NJ.
Store policies
Returns
Shipping
Seller feedback (3,824)
- k***u (162)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseThank you. Fast shipping and well packaged. Exactly as described!
- 7***e (2)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchasePackaged very nicely and securely. I appreciated the fast shipping and how the pony was in great condition. Recommend the seller!
- e***r (1698)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseItem arrived very quickly and just as described! Very happy customer! Highly recommended seller!
- i***l (222)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseItem was extremely affordable and shipping was quick. I def. Will be purchasing from here again. Thanks for a great experience.
- z***g (320)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchasegreat looking conversation piece. Good seller fast delivery
- g***a (93)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseCommunication was great and answered all my questions. Shipping was fast and item was better than expected. One of my grail pieces I’ve being looking for MIB.