70K items sold
3.3K followers
Contact

All items

1990 US Mint Prestige Set With Silver Eisenhower Commemorative Dollar $1

$29.0016 bids2h 33m

Original U.S. Mint - Silver Eagle Tube -

$7.00Save up to 20% when you buy more

1972 S NGC GEM Proof Signed Charlie Duke Astronaut Silver Ike Dollar $1

$30.639 bids3h 39m

2 Oz Fine .999 Silver Bullet .308 Caliber

$80.00

1923 Germany Prussia Westfalen Notgeld 50 Million Mark Horse Coin Westphalia

$22.7212 bids3h 25m

1968 Sudan Proof Set 8 Coins

$16.009 bids2h 52m

925 Sterling Silver Skeleton Skull Beads 10mm Vertical 1 Pc.

$8.99

1660-1668 Solidus Copper Coin Jan II Casimir Vasa King of Poland 1 Pc From Lot

$4.99

1965 UK United Kingdom NGC Sample Churchill Crown

$12.508 bids3h 2m

1950 Somalia 1 Somalo

$2.253 bids2d 8h 2m

Ronald Reagan Presidential Inauguration Silver 1 oz Medal

$32.006 bids4h

Seleucid Demetrius II AR Tetradrachm Tyre mint 128/7 BC Eagle reverse

$330.00

Kentucky State .999 Silver Bar Federated Mint 1/2 Troy Oz Sealed Certified

$25.00

1967 Panama Silver Medio Balboa Half Balboa

$0.990 bids2d 7h 9m

Roman Imperial Nerva AR Denarius Rome 97 AD Fortuna rev. RIC 16

$154.00

5 oz Silver 12 Gauge Shotgun Shell Shaped Bar

$167.5010 bids4h 19m

Official US Mint Coin Die Cancelled Defaced 1994 Denver 1C With Blank, Cent, COA

$75.00

Roman Imperial Vespasian AR Denarius 69-70 AD "Judaea Capta" Rev.!

$385.00

2020 P Australia PCGS MS69 Double Pixiu 1 oz Silver Dollar $1

$31.5016 bids1d 6h 3m

Persia Achaemenid Kings AR Siglos 490-375 BC King w/ spear and bow

$110.00

1927 Italy Silver 5 Lire

$0.990 bids2d 7h 50m

2007 D Daniel Carr Prototype Presidential Dollar Concept Sample Set Of 4 Coins

$13.835 bids1d 2h 51m

2017 Baseball 1 oz .999 Silver Round

$37.006 bids1d 2h 58m

1962 Panama Silver Medio Balboa Half Balboa

$12.015 bids2d 7h 7m

1967 Panama Silver Balboa

$8.273 bids2d 7h 11m

Vintage Pokemon Combat Figures: Nidorino - Hasbro 2000, RARE, New

$75.00

1921 Colombia Silver 50 Centavos

$9.505 bids2d 7h 42m

Roman Imperial Nerva AR Denarius Rome 97 AD Libertas rev. RIC 19

$220.00

1875 Mexico Silver 50 Centavos With Hole

$7.507 bids2d 7h 36m

GSA BLACK BOXES MORGAN DOLLAR IN GOOD CONDITION GOOD HINGE OFF QUALITY BOX ONLY

$9.00

1881 O Morgan Dollar In AWESOME Collectible Wild West Tombstone, AZ Case

$32.0012 bids2d 23h 0m

1973 Franklin Mint 70mm Bronze Richard Nixon Presidential Inaugural Medal

$5.505 bids1d 7h 37m

2002 Canada Golden Jubilee Sterling Silver Brilliant Uncirculated Dollar $1

$3.253 bids1d 3h 22m

2008 PRC China Beijing Olympic Games Hoop Rolling Silver 1 oz Coin

$9.507 bids1d 5h 37m

Philip II of Macedon AR Tetradrachm 316-311 BC Amphipolis under Kassander

$495.00

2008 PRC China Beijing Olympic Games Beijing Opera Art Silver 1 oz Coin

$24.507 bids1d 5h 32m

1934 Panama Silver Medio Balboa Half Balboa

$11.017 bids2d 6h 59m

Lot Of 20 Different Mardi Gras Tokens In Sheets COLLECTION READY!

$10.00

2008 PRC China Beijing Olympic Games The Summer Palace Silver 1 oz Coin

$12.509 bids1d 5h 48m

Roman Imperial Hadrian AE Sestertius Rome 117-138 AD

$52.80

Ch. 4121 1902 $20 PB The Citizens National Bank of Kokomo, Indiana great name

$1,540.00

Thrace, Apollonia Pontica AR Hemiobol 540-530 BC Anchor & Incuse swastika

$82.50

SCARCE Northwest Territorial Mint Caliber .22LR 0.25 Oz 999 Silver Bullet

$55.00

1973 Panama Silver Balboa

$12.505 bids2d 7h 10m

1981 Lincoln Cent With Raised Masonic Counter Stamp

$9.99

2008 PRC China Beijing Olympic Games The Great Wall Silver 1 oz Coin

$9.507 bids1d 5h 47m

Lifetime Alexander the Great AR Tetradrachm Amphipolis 332-326 BC +Eye Appeal

$632.50

1972 Panama Silver Balboa

$6.503 bids2d 7h 13m

About us

Lost Dutchman Rare coins has been Indianapolis's premier full service coin shop since 1985!
Location: United StatesMember since: Jul 11, 2008Seller: indycoindealer
Top Rated SellerLost Dutchman Rare Coins is one of eBay's most reputable sellers. Consistently delivers outstanding customer service Learn more

Detailed seller ratings

Average for the last 12 months
Accurate description
5.0
Reasonable shipping cost
5.0
Shipping speed
5.0
Communication
5.0

Seller feedback (40,885)

  • a***r (182)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    Thank you! Nice Item! Accurate Description, Great Value. Secure Packaging, Fast Shipping, Great Communications. Smooth Transaction, Great eBayer! A+ Seller!
  • j***4 (65)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past month
    Verified purchase
    The coins I purchased were exactly as described and arrived safely packaged. The shipping turned into a disaster, but that was the fault of the post office not the seller. The seller was responsive when I reached out about the shipping. The post office eventually found the items and they arrived almost 2 weeks past the projected delivery. No issues with the seller though, and I would buy from them again.
    Reply from: indycoindealer- Feedback replied by seller indycoindealer.- Feedback replied by seller indycoindealer.
    Shew.... what a mess. I'm glad they arrived safely.
  • 3***9 (179)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    beautiful set of coins. As described and photographed. Very well packaged for shipping to prevent damage in transit. Value for these coins was very reasonable. Surprised I won the auction with my bid. Seems like everyone wants Vatican coins and bidding is usually an arm wrestle event. Believe this was a first time purchase from this seller, but seller did not disappoint. A++
  • a***_ (1715)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    Very well packaged. Note exactly as pictured. Thank you!!!!!!! Seller did not try to cheat on postage like most banknote sellers on eBay. A single price, like in a store, allowed me to make an intelligent buying decision.
  • s***s (3110)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    Great eBay seller. As described. Fast shipping. Great price. Very easy transaction. Packaged Well. Would recommend to anyone !!
  • l***i (409)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past month
    Verified purchase
    Fast shipping , well packaged , good value , as described . Trusted seller .