Vintage Sea Wees TropiGals Pearl Baby Scale Gully African American Kenner 1982
$99.99
Newly Listed
See all
Vintage G1 My Little Pony March Daffodil Birthflower Hasbro MLP Rare HTF MO
$19.99
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Pretty Beat UK Euro Purple Hair Hasbro MLP Rare HTF
$34.99
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Stickles Baby Cotton Candy on Card MOC Hasbro Rare
$59.99
Vintage Popples Football Popple Touch Down Plush Sports 12" Mattel 1986
$17.99
Vintage Popples Puffling Popple Plush Purple Odor Mattel 1985 1986
$12.99
All items
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Stickles Baby Cotton Candy on Card MOC Hasbro Rare
$59.99
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Fakie Coloring Kiddies Baby Mold TLC MLP Rare HTF
$14.99
Vintage Holly Hobbie Doll Lot 15" & 8" Dolls Cloth Rag Knickerbocker 1970s
$22.4925% off
Vintage Popples Puffling Popple Plush Purple Odor Mattel 1985 1986
$12.99
Vintage Rainbow Brite Starlite Plush Horse Tags Emotions Hallmark Mattel 1983
$249.99
Vintage Sea Wees TropiGals Pearl Baby Scale Gully African American Kenner 1982
$99.99
Vintage Marchon Fantasy Fillies Cirra Missing Wings Horse Pegasus Empire 1992
$14.99
Vintage Strawberry Shortcake Mini Peach Blush Melonie Belle Fan PVC Figure Rare
$71.9910% off
Disney The Jungle Book Bagheera Plush 12" Black Panther with Tags Toy Factory
$14.9925% off
Vintage Mattel Little Pretty Kitty Cherry Belle Show Off G1 My Little Pony Cat
$148.4910% off
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Pretty Beat UK Euro Purple Hair Hasbro MLP Rare HTF
$34.99
Littlest Pet Shop Lot 45 Palace Pets Shopkins Hatchimals Mini Girl Toy Figures
$14.9925% off
Vintage G1 My Little Pony So Soft Angel with Comb Hasbro MLP Rare HTF SS
$79.99
Vintage Big Bad Wolf Felt Plush 9" Three Little Pigs Dream Pets Baps Germany
$37.4925% off
Vintage G1 My Little Pony CF Blue Belle Concave Feet Hasbro MLP Rare HTF
$7.4925% off
Vintage Commonwealth Unicorn Plush Pink Small 10" Laying Lying Down
$13.4925% off
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Princess Royal Pink EXC Excellent Hasbro MLP Rare HTF
$18.7425% off
Vintage Strawberry Shortcake Deluxe Mini Mint Tulip Marsh Mallard PVC Figure SSC
$11.2425% off
Vintage Scooby Doo Plush 16" Large with Collar Knickerbocker 1976 Hanna Barbera
$18.7425% off
Vintage Strawberry Shortcake Mini Cafe Ole Dancing with Burrito PVC Figure Rare
$37.4925% off
Vintage Kenner Hugga Bunch Cloth Rag Doll Hand Sewn Impkins 1984 Peter Pan
$14.9925% off
Rainbow High Doll Lot of 2 Dolls Amaya Raine Violet Willow 10" MGA
$14.9925% off
Zelfs Super Catsby Large Figure 4" Cat Moose Toys Troll Doll Glow in the Dark
$11.2425% off
Vintage Hasbro Puppy Surprise Dress Up Pups Bride Sleeping Bag 1992 Rare HTF
$29.99
Vintage Grateful Dead Bear Beanbag Plush Franklin with Tags 7" Liquid Blue
$14.9925% off
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Baby Buggy Playset Incomplete Hasbro MLP Rare HTF
$7.4925% off
Vintage Mattel Magic Nursery Doll Black African American AA with Sleeper 1989
$14.9925% off
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Braided Beauty Brush N Grow Hasbro Rare HTF BNG
$7.4925% off
G1 Style My Little Pony HQG1C Genie Plush 9" Custom Unicorn Hasbro MLP Rare HTF
$13.4925% off
Vintage G1 My Little Pony Moondancer Complete with Comb & Ribbon Hasbro MLP
$24.99
Vintage Mattel Magic Nursery Doll Black African American Brown Hair Dress 1989
$37.4925% off
Vintage Hasbro Puppy Surprise in My Pocket Lot Husky Baby Kennel 1993 1991
$14.99
Vintage Mattel Little Pretty Kitty Purple Paws Glitter N Grow My Little Pony Cat
$18.7425% off
Vintage Mattel Little Pretty Kitty Zizi Purple Bee G1 My Little Pony Cat
$14.9925% off
Zelfs Snowphie Figure White Tiger Moose Toys Troll Doll Medium 2.5" Rare HTF
$37.4925% off
Vintage Mattel Magic Nursery Doll Black African American Sleeper Diaper 1989
$14.9925% off
Zelfs Spellinda Figure w/ Accessory Moose Toys Troll Doll Zelicious Medium 2.5"
$11.2425% off
G3 My Little Pony Triple Treat I Hasbro MLP Rare HTF
$7.4925% off
Vintage The Muppet Show Animal Corgi Car Figure Diecast Broken Drumstick
$4.4925% off
Vintage Mattel Little Pretty Kitty Baby Bibsy 1989 G1 My Little Pony Cat
$11.2425% off
Vintage Strawberry Shortcake Mini Raspberry Tart & Rhubarb Seesaw PVC Figure SSC
$7.4925% off
Vintage Mattel Aladdin Doll 12" Barbie Sized 1992 Disney with Outfit
$11.2425% off
Vintage Kenner Hugga Bunch Cloth Rag Doll Hand Sewn Bubbles 1984 Peter Pan
$14.9925% off
G3 My Little Pony Baby Sparkleberry Swirl Hasbro MLP Rare HTF
$11.2425% off
Vintage Kenner Hugga Bunch Cloth Rag Doll Hand Sewn Huggins 1984 Peter Pan
$14.9925% off
Vintage Mattel Magic Nursery Doll Dress Outfit Only Floral Flowers Clothes 1989
$7.4925% off
Vintage Strawberry Shortcake Mini Almond Tea with Lantern PVC Figure SSC Kenner
$11.2425% off
Vintage Galoob Pound Puppies Purebreds Lot Mom & 3 Babies Cocker Spaniel 1996
$22.4925% off
About us
My Little Ponies for sale & other vintage 1980's toys, games, and plush. G1 G2 G3 My Little Pony toys for sale. Buy Strawberry Shortcake, Care Bears, Cabbage Patch Kids, & lots more of your favorite toys from your childhood here!
Seller feedback (4,396)
- u***i (35)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseGreat seller with good communication, fast shipping, and my toy arrived safely in smart packaging that was easy to open and recycle. Everything looked just as described. Thank you!
- n***r (50)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseShipping was reasonable and packaging was great, wrapped in packing paper and a bubble lined post bag, Sunlight arrived in fantastic condition as described! Great value! Thank you! Appreciate the thank you sticker!
- i***8 (584)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseShipped item out the next day, and arrived safely today. As described. Honest and friendly seller, good communication. Thanks! 😁
- t***d (52)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseThe hat was in great condition when it arrived and packaged well. Arrived on time. A bit expensive, but I wanted to complete my pony. Seller was friendly.
- 8***8 (126)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseGreat seller. Quick delivery, well packed, exactly S described… A+
- 1***m (576)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseGreat seller! Item as described, packed safely and shipped quickly.