10K items sold
819 followers
Contact

All items

Unsearched Lincoln WHEAT CENTS BAG of 500 Truly Never Searched 1909-1958 Pennies

$63.95

1957 Topps #95 PSA AUTHENTIC ALTERED Card is trimmed but nicely done YANKEES

$29.003 bids5d 23h 40m

WALTHAM Rare Wandering Seconds Vintage White Gold Filled Mens Watch Circa 1933!

$29.0015 bids5d 22h 47m

1974 Topps #252 Dave Parker ROOKIE PSA 8 PITTSBURGH PIRATES

$56.009 bids5d 23h 40m

1956 Topps #164 Harmon Killebrew PSA 6 Beauty! WASHINGTON NATIONALS

$20.395 bids5d 23h 40m

1974 Topps #130 Reggie Jackson PSA 8OC OAKLAND ATHLETICS

$9.990 bids5d 23h 40m

ROLEX 18K Gold Jubliee Watch Bracelet Genuine Authentic Ref. 6311 20mm Datejust

$5,900.00

1908 Indian Head Cent NGC Graded Coin AU55 BN #2229

$45.99

1974 Topps #80 Tom Seaver PSA 9 Mint O/C NEW YORK METS

$9.990 bids5d 23h 40m

1974 Topps #20 Nolan Ryan PSA 7 CALIFORNIA ANGELS

$18.493 bids5d 23h 40m

1912 Barber Half Dollar PCGS Graded Coin Solid grade and attractive VF20 #6524

$155.00

1971 Topps #264 Joe Morgan PSA 7 HOUSTON ASTROS A BEAUTY!

$28.886 bids5d 23h 40m

1859 Indian Head Cent PCGS Graded XF 45 Great Looking Coin #2052

$159.99

1974 #1 Hank Aaron ALL-Time HR Ldr PSA 8 beautiful card could easily be 8.5

$102.505 bids5d 23h 40m

2015 Canada Bald Eagle 4c Fractional Set 1.85oz .99 Fine Silver With COA

$109.00

1973 Topps #174 Rich Gossage ROOKIE PSA 8 CHICAGO WHITE SOX

$14.503 bids5d 23h 40m

1858 Liberty Seated Quarter PCGS Coin Genuine Cleaned XF Details 5445

$92.00

1973 Topps #615 Mike Schmidt ROOKIE PSA 3 With Ron Cey

$51.005 bids5d 23h 40m

1934 Washington Quarter MS66 PCGS Graded Coin MS 66 TONED 5793

$225.00

1952-D Roosevelt Dime PCGS Graded Coin MS64 #5101

$15.99

1924-S Standing Liberty Quarter PCGS Graded Coin VF 25 #5750

$125.00

2024 Trump Assassination Attempt 999 1oz Silver Coin MAGA

$41.95

1965 Topps #350 Mickey Mantle SGC 50 / VG-EX NEW YORKYANKEES

$62.0010 bids5d 23h 40m

1963 Franklin Half Dollar PCGS Graded Coin MS63 WHITE 6684

$25.00

GIRARD PERREGAUX Gyromatic Vintage 30mm Mens Automatic Dress Watch Gold Filled

$150.0022 bids5d 22h 42m

1963-D Roosevelt Dime PCGS Graded Coin MS64 #5127

$14.99

1872 3C Liberty Head Three Cent Nickel Coin NGC VF-Details WHIZZED 3738

$43.00

1971 Topps #630 Roberto Clemente PSA 2 NO CREASES and CENTERED PIRATES

$32.054 bids5d 23h 40m

1888 1C Indian Cent NGC Graded XF 45 BN Nice Original Coin 2166

$48.00

1958 Topps #320 Whitey Ford SGC 86 / 7.5 NEW YORKYANKEES

$27.008 bids5d 23h 40m

1973 Topps #1 PSA 7 ALL TIME HR Ldrs PSA 7 Babe Ruth Hank Aaron Willie Mays

$55.0015 bids5d 23h 40m

1907 Indian Cent NGC Graded Coin AU58 BN #2226

$49.00

1900-O Barber Half Dollar PCGS Graded Coin F12 Attractive looking coin #6487

$160.00

1901-S Barber Half Dollar PCGS Graded Coin G04 Another low mintage piece #6491

$74.00

1919-S Walking Liberty Half Dollar PCGS Graded Coin VG08 #6579

$79.95

LONGINES Vintage Mens Gold Filled Tank Watch Caliber 9LT Circa 1954 No Reserve!

$113.0019 bids5d 22h 45m

1950-D Franklin Half Dollar PCGS Graded Coin MS63 #6657

$65.99

1853 3 Cent Silver XF40 PCGS Silver Coin Nice 3667 XF40 Original

$145.00

1835 25C Capped Bust Quarter PCGS Genuine FINE Details Enviro Dam Coin 5354

$99.00

1912-S Liberty Head V Nickel PCGS Graded G06 Key Date Coin 3875

$149.00

1937 Lincoln Cent PCGS Graded Coin PROOF PR64 RB #3337

$159.99

1938-D Walking Liberty Half Dollar PCGS Graded Coin VF35 #6605

$149.95

1900-O Morgan Dollar PCGS Graded Coin VF30 #7266

$69.99

1919 S Walking Liberty VG10 PCGS Graded Half Dollar San Francisco Coin 6579

$85.00

1869 Two Cent Piece XF40 PCGS Graded Coin 3603

$134.00

1944 S Washington Quarter MS66 CAC Sticker PCGS Graded Coin Toned 5826

$89.00

1956 FRANKLIN Half Dollar PCGS PR66 PROOF 66 TYPE 1 White Coin 6686

$198.00

BUFFALO NICKELS BAG OF 500 PARTIAL DATE Bulk Lot Indian Head Coins 1913-1938

$209.95Save up to 6% when you buy more

About us

Since 1989, American Rare Coin with over 200 years of numismatic experience on staff is one of the largest coin and precious metals dealers in the Midwest. We sell competitively priced PCGS and NGC Certified coins, all forms of gold and silver bullion, silver dollars, currency, and U.S. Proof/Mint.
Location: United StatesMember since: Oct 22, 2001Seller: americanrarecoinstore

Detailed seller ratings

Average for the last 12 months
Accurate description
5.0
Reasonable shipping cost
4.9
Shipping speed
5.0
Communication
5.0

Seller feedback (6,110)

  • 1***n (567)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past month
    Verified purchase
    Beautiful 2020-W PCGS PR70DCAM arrived securely packaged & with delivered with speed. Sold by: American Rare Coin and Collectibles – I can truly say you are a FIVE STAR ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ eBay Coin Dealer. Shipping Excellent! Well packaged, as described High Quality, Excellent condition, great value and the appearance like perfect! I hope to do business with you again! Thank you, Scott
  • r***o (108)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    This is an excellent seller! Everything was right with this perfect transaction. My coin was shipped immediately, and arrived well packaged. It is exactly as it was described, and I received the coin the same coin as was in the photos. I couldn’t be happier! A+ *****
  • m***5 (354)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past month
    Verified purchase
    Amazing value and unsearchable as described. Would buy from this seller again 100%. Great packing and appearance of coins , amazing lot of dates! Thank you!
  • t***i (242)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past month
    Verified purchase
    Absolutely perfect coin Thank you for shipping so fast! Packing was perfect.exactly as described. Great value!
  • c***o (561)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past month
    Verified purchase
    Great coin just as described. Packaged well and shipped fast. Great Seller
  • r***j (367)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    Received coin as pictured and described, well packaged, fast shipping. A+ seller