Retired Original Beanie Babies
Shop by category
574,471 results
Sort: Best Match
$2,000.00or Best Offer$9.06 shipping- $13.80or Best Offer$6.86 shipping
- $22.00or Best Offer$8.00 shipping
- $25.00$6.50 shipping
- $24.89or Best OfferFree shipping742 sold
- $18.99Free shipping31 sold
- $6.00$5.37 shipping
- $7.00$5.37 shipping
- $18.00or Best Offer$9.25 shipping27 sold
- $9.95Free shipping14 watching
- $9.89Free shippingOnly 2 left
- $299.95or Best Offer$12.80 shipping
- $21.99or Best Offer$6.18 shipping
- $20.00Free shipping
- $32.80or Buy It Now$14.90 shipping0 bids6d 23h
- $15.00or Best Offer$5.29 shipping19 sold
- $9.89Free shipping15 watching
- $13.50or Buy It Now$11.55 shipping0 bids6d 23h
- $14.89or Best OfferFree shippingOnly 1 left!
- $15.89or Best OfferFree shipping15 watching
- $6.99$5.99 shipping
- $9.90or Best Offer$6.99 shipping62 sold
- $12.80or Buy It Now$11.55 shipping0 bids6d 23h
- $15.50or Buy It Now$11.55 shipping0 bids6d 23h
- $29.90or Buy It Now$31.40 shipping0 bids6d 23h
- $9.89Free shipping32 watching
- $15.00$8.00 shipping
- $20.00or Best Offer$9.74 shipping
- $550.00or Best OfferFree shipping
- $200.00or Best Offer$21.28 shipping0 bids6d 21h
- $16.25or Buy It Now$14.90 shipping0 bids6d 23h
- $75.00or Best Offer$6.00 shipping
- $7.89or Best OfferFree shipping34 watching
- $21.95Free shippingEst. delivery Wed, Nov 516 sold
- $9.89Free shipping91 watching
- $9.89Free shipping24 watching
- $49.99or Best OfferFree shipping0 bids6d 23h
- $500.00or Best Offer$21.95 shipping
- $9.89Free shipping56 sold
- $10.89Free shipping34 watching
- $7.00$5.37 shipping
- $9.89Free shipping53 watching
- $7.95Free shipping
- $14.89Free shipping26 watching
- $5.80or Buy It Now$8.80 shipping0 bids6d 23h
- $9.89Free shipping49 watching
- $15.00or Best Offer$5.37 shipping
- $9.89Free shipping71 sold
- $9.89or Best OfferFree shipping41 sold
- $13.95Free shipping4 watching
- $12.89or Best OfferFree shipping51 watching
- $16.50or Buy It Now$11.55 shipping0 bids6d 23h
- $8.00Free shipping118 watching
- $19.80or Buy It Now$10.45 shipping0 bids6d 23h
- $8.50Free shipping
- $8.90or Best Offer$6.99 shipping14 sold
- $14.50or Best Offer$5.00 shipping
- $3.00$10.50 shipping3 watching
Best selling
Top rated
- 100% agree - Would recommend$6.17 New$2.00 Used
- 100% agree - Would recommend$6.99 New$4.00 Used
- 100% agree - Would recommend$13.99 New$10.50 Used
Review highlights
Recommended by our customersYou'll be glad you got this
By rmom01
I had one of the originals years ago but my entire collection was stolen. I'm glad to find the older ty products. see all reviews
Verified PurchaseWonderful Gift to Myself to Others Young at Heart.
By betterworldwithoutbullies
One of the cutest one I have purchased so far and will be a good gift to let a child to learn what otter likes to eat. P... see all reviews
Verified PurchaseFavorite Toy
By anast.fourn
I love ❤️ beanie babies so much fun and the beanie baby Batty was my favorite toy so well made and will never get broken... see all reviews
Verified PurchaseGreat dachshund beanie baby. It’s for m...
By elizjim_4756
Great dachshund beanie baby. It’s for my son-in-law who loves his dachshund. see all reviews
Verified PurchaseErin, Ty beanie baby bear, very adorable, and got him at a good price, but very cute !!
By jirie38
I love Erin the beanie baby, he has Canadian tush tags, he's an older bear but very adorable, and with him having the Ca... see all reviews
Verified PurchaseLovely Claude Beanie Baby
By kumquat770
Was wonderful to find this beautiful Claude the crab beanie on eBay . Lovely colors and a perfect hang tag also added to... see all reviews
Verified Purchase
