Skip to main content
eBay Logo

Shop by category

Advanced
    • Daily Deals
    • Brand Outlet
    • Help & Contact
    • Sell
    • WatchlistExpand Watch List
      Loading...
      Sign in to see your user information
    • My eBayExpand My eBay
      • Summary
      • Recently Viewed
      • Bids/Offers
      • Watchlist
      • Purchase History
      • Buy Again
      • Selling
      • Saved Searches
      • Saved Sellers
      • My Garage
      • Messages
      • Collection beta
      • The eBay vault
    • Expand Cart
      Loading...
      Something went wrong. View cart for details.
    {"delay":300}

    There seems to be a problem serving the request at this time

    breadcrumb

    • eBay
    • hallmark cookie cutters

    hallmark cookie cutters

    Side Refine Panel

    • All

    • Auction

    • Buy It Now

    • Best Match
    • Time: ending soonest
    • Time: newly listed
    • Price + Shipping: lowest first
    • Price + Shipping: highest first
    • Distance: nearest first
    • List View

    4,101 Results

    • 1977 Hallmark NEW  Disney Dumbo Elephant Popping Fresh Boy Cookie Cutters

      1977 Hallmark NEW Disney Dumbo Elephant Popping Fresh Boy Cookie Cutters

      $4.99
      $4.99 shipping
    • Hallmark 2017 Cookie Cutter Summer Keepsake Ornament

      Hallmark 2017 Cookie Cutter Summer Keepsake Ornament

      $2.99
      0 bids
      $5.95 shipping
      Ending Saturday at 6:29PM PDT1d 22h
    • Vintage Cookie Cutters Hallmark, Tupperware Assorted Holiday Lot Halloween, etc

      Vintage Cookie Cutters Hallmark, Tupperware Assorted Holiday Lot Halloween, etc

      $14.50
      $5.60 shipping
    • Hallmark Party Set of 3 COOKIE SHAPERS Cutters Holiday Christmas Trees Plastic

      Hallmark Party Set of 3 COOKIE SHAPERS Cutters Holiday Christmas Trees Plastic

      $12.95
      $4.90 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Hallmark 2017 Cookie Cutter Vacation Keepsake Ornament

      Hallmark 2017 Cookie Cutter Vacation Keepsake Ornament

      $2.99
      0 bids
      $5.95 shipping
      Ending Saturday at 6:31PM PDT1d 22h
    • VTG Hallmark  Acorn Cookie Cutter Mold 1975 2.75x3.5x.25” Yellow Gold

      VTG Hallmark Acorn Cookie Cutter Mold 1975 2.75x3.5x.25” Yellow Gold

      $2.99
      $3.85 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Vintage Hallmark  "Dracula" Cookie Cutter.

      Vintage Hallmark "Dracula" Cookie Cutter.

      $6.29
      $1.25 shipping
    • Hallmark 2017 Happy Easter, Cookie Cutter Mouse Keepsake Ornament

      Hallmark 2017 Happy Easter, Cookie Cutter Mouse Keepsake Ornament

      $2.99
      0 bids
      $5.95 shipping
      Ending Saturday at 6:28PM PDT1d 22h
    • Hallmark Disney Vintage Cookie Cutter - Winnie the Pooh in package NOS

      Hallmark Disney Vintage Cookie Cutter - Winnie the Pooh in package NOS

      $6.00
      $5.05 shipping
    • Vintage 1978 Hallmark Scooby Doo Pink Panther Cookie Cutter Hanna-Barbera

      Vintage 1978 Hallmark Scooby Doo Pink Panther Cookie Cutter Hanna-Barbera

      $6.95
      $4.84 shipping
    • NIP Hallmark Pink and Red Love Valentine Cookie Cutter

      NIP Hallmark Pink and Red Love Valentine Cookie Cutter

      $12.99
      $4.00 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Hallmark 2017 Be Mine, Cookie Cutter Mouse Keepsake Ornament

      Hallmark 2017 Be Mine, Cookie Cutter Mouse Keepsake Ornament

      $2.99
      0 bids
      $5.95 shipping
      Ending Saturday at 6:33PM PDT1d 23h
    • VTG Hallmark Raggedy Ann & Andy Cookie Cutters Home Baking Fun

      VTG Hallmark Raggedy Ann & Andy Cookie Cutters Home Baking Fun

      $10.00
    • Vintage Hallmark Cookie Cutters Large Lot Of 23

      Vintage Hallmark Cookie Cutters Large Lot Of 23

      $29.95
      $7.95 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • NEW Hallmark Vintage Valentines Cupids Arrow Heart Plastic Cookie Cutters Set 4

      NEW Hallmark Vintage Valentines Cupids Arrow Heart Plastic Cookie Cutters Set 4

      $7.90
      $5.60 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Vintage Lot of 21  Plastic Cookie Cutters ~ Hallmark ~ Hutzler ~ Hong Kong

      Vintage Lot of 21 Plastic Cookie Cutters ~ Hallmark ~ Hutzler ~ Hong Kong

      $10.00
      0 bids
      $9.85 shipping
      Ending Jun 15 at 8:11AM PDT6d 12h
    • Six Hallmark  "Green Clover" Cookie Cutters.

      Six Hallmark "Green Clover" Cookie Cutters.

      $14.95
      Free shipping
    • Hallmark VTG Plastic Cookie Cutter - Disney's Smiling Mickey Mouse Face

      Hallmark VTG Plastic Cookie Cutter - Disney's Smiling Mickey Mouse Face

      $10.79
      Was: $11.99
    • Hallmark Cookie Cutter

      Hallmark Cookie Cutter

      $5.30 to $11.30
      $3.95 shipping
    • Hallmark Vintage Plastic Cookie Cutter - Squirrel with Acorn Nut Autumn Nature

      Hallmark Vintage Plastic Cookie Cutter - Squirrel with Acorn Nut Autumn Nature

      $9.95
      Free shipping
      Only 1 left!
    • VTG Hallmark Turkey Thanksgiving Cookie Cutter Mold Orange Plastic 1986

      VTG Hallmark Turkey Thanksgiving Cookie Cutter Mold Orange Plastic 1986

      $2.99
      $3.90 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Hallmark 2015 Cookie Cutter Christmas 4th Series Ornament NIB

      Hallmark 2015 Cookie Cutter Christmas 4th Series Ornament NIB

      $21.99
      0 bids
      $4.09 shipping
      Ending Jun 13 at 5:49PM PDT4d 22h
    • 22 Vintage Hallmark Cookie Cutters Lot 1980s Christmas

      22 Vintage Hallmark Cookie Cutters Lot 1980s Christmas

      $20.00
      Free shipping
    • hallmark cookie cutter 2019

      hallmark cookie cutter 2019

      $21.50
      $5.60 shipping
    • Vintage Hallmark Peanuts Christmas Cookie Cutters Snoopy Charlie Brown USA MADE

      Vintage Hallmark Peanuts Christmas Cookie Cutters Snoopy Charlie Brown USA MADE

      $20.00
      $9.90 shipping

    Results Pagination - Page 1

    1. 1
    2. 2
    3. 3
    4. 4
    5. 5
    6. 6
    7. 7
    8. 8
    9. 9
    10. 10

    Additional site navigation

    • About eBay
    • Announcements
    • Community
    • Security Center
    • Seller Center
    • Policies
    • Affiliates
    • Help & Contact
    • Site Map
    Copyright © 1995-2023 eBay Inc. All Rights Reserved. Accessibility, User Agreement, Privacy, Payments Terms of Use, Cookies, Your Privacy Choices and AdChoice