Skip to main content
eBay
 
New
rare beanie babies: New New
 

RARE & RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY BEANIE BOO~NIBBLES THE GUINEA PIG 6"~NEW! MWMT!

Time left:
$22.38
4 bids
Free shipping

Newly listedRare 1st Edition Ty Princess Diana Beanie Baby- No Space, No #

Time left:
$1,000.00
or Best Offer

Ultra Rare MWMT 1st Edition Ty Princess Diana Di Beanie Baby No Space No Number

Time left:
$15,000.00
or Best Offer
Free shipping

Lot of 10 Collectible Ty Beanie Babies with MINT tags - Rare and Retired bears!

Time left:
$8.99
1 bid

Ultra Rare MWMT 1st Edition Ty Princess Diana Beanie Baby No Space No Number PVC

Time left:
$149.99
Buy It Now
Free shipping

Ty Princess Diana Ultra Rare MWMT 1st Edition Di Beanie Baby No Space Number PVC

The item is listed as a Top Rated Plus item
Time left:
$55,001.00
or Best Offer
Free shipping

Lots of rare Beanie Babies

Time left:
$999.00
0 bids
$1,500.00
Buy It Now

Ultra RARE MWMT Ty PRINCESS Diana Di Beanie Baby 1st Edition NO SPACE NO NUMBER Charity item

Time left:
$22,000.00
Buy It Now
Free shipping

LOT of BEANIE BABIES Creatures from SEA Some Rare Hard to Find Goldie Included

The item is listed as a Top Rated Plus item
Time left:
$9.95
0 bids

TY BEANIE BABIES VALENTINO BEAR -RARE 1st EDITION PVC PELLETS MINT

Time left:
$19.99
Buy It Now
Free shipping

Ultra Rare MWMT 1st Edition Ty Princess Diana Beanie Baby No Space No Number

Time left:
$500,000.00
or Best Offer
Free shipping

LOT of BEANIE BABIES All Wild Animals Some Rare & Hard To Find - Grunt Included

The item is listed as a Top Rated Plus item
Time left:
$9.95
1 bid

NEW RARE TY BEANIE BABY PRINCESS DIANA "CHINA-1ST EDITION-NO SPACE! NO#!

The item is listed as a Top Rated Plus item
One-day shipping available
 Time left:
$325.00
or Best Offer
Free shipping

Newly listedRARE AND RETIRED Ty CURLY BEANIE BABY ONE DOZEN WITH ERRORS

Time left:
$25.99
or Best Offer

LOT of BEANIE BABIES All Barn, Hooved, Horns & Unicorns Some Rare Hard to Find

The item is listed as a Top Rated Plus item
Time left:
$9.95
1 bid

TY Princess Diana Beanie Baby Rare 1st Ed PE Collectible Quality MWMT

Time left:
$12.50
Buy It Now

LOT of BEANIE BABIES All Feline Some Rare Hard to Find Plus Canadian ZIP!! CATS

The item is listed as a Top Rated Plus item
Time left:
$10.45
3 bids

Ultra Rare MWMT 1st Edition Ty Princess Diana Di Beanie Baby No Space No Number

Time left:
$2,500.00
Buy It Now
Free shipping

Extremely RARE Ty Princess Diana Beanie Baby 1997 RETIRED 1ST EDITION

Time left:
$87,000.00
or Best Offer
Free shipping

LOT of BEANIE BABIES All Zodiac and Birthday Beanies Some Rare & Hard to Find!

The item is listed as a Top Rated Plus item
Time left:
$9.95
0 bids

Newly listedTy Beanie Boo 8" CARROTS White rabbit Mint/Mint tag * RARE * Retired

The item is listed as a Top Rated Plus item
Time left:
$22.99
Buy It Now
Free shipping

RARE & RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY~PATTI THE PURPLE PLATYPUS 9"~MINT WITH MINT TAGS!

Time left:
$5.48
or Best Offer
Free shipping

LOT of BEANIE BABIES All Reptiles Dinosaurs & Dragons Some Rare & Hard to Find!

The item is listed as a Top Rated Plus item
Time left:
$9.95
0 bids

RARE Ty VALENTINO Beanie Baby 1993 Mint

The item is listed as a Top Rated Plus item
Time left:
$1,000.00
or Best Offer
Free shipping

Newly listed TY Princess Diana Beanie Baby *ULTRA RARE* 1st Edition Pellets! MINT Number #472

# 472 RED STAMP IN TAG **MINT**MWMT PRINCESS DI
Time left:
$125.00
0 bids
Free shipping

Newly listedTYGER the Yorkshire Terrier Yorkie Dog Ty Beanie Baby ~ MINT ~ RARE RETIRED

The item is listed as a Top Rated Plus item
Time left:
$49.90
Buy It Now

Ty Beanie Babies Misspelled RARE Valentino Bear 1993 100%Benefit Tornado Victims Charity item

Time left:
$10,000.00
or Best Offer
Free shipping

Rare Beanie Baby"Mystic The Unicorn" With Birthdate Error On Tag! Official Ty

Time left:
$0.99
1 bid

RARE & RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY~CHRISTMAS 1997 HOLIDAY TEDDY BEAR 8"~NEW! MWMT!

Time left:
$4.59
or Best Offer
Free shipping

Ty Beanie Baby "Peace The Bear" With Major Error! Off Center Hangtag! Rare!!

Time left:
$0.99
1 bid

RARE AND RETIRED PRINCESS BEANIE BABY ERROR '' BLIZZARD " TUSH TAG

Time left:
$99.99
or Best Offer

Tiny the Chihuahua RARE Dog TY Beanie Baby. COMBINE SHIPPING!

Time left:
$3.99
Buy It Now

Huge Lot of 20 Retired T.Y. Beanie Baby Teddy Bears. Great Collection! Rare!

Time left:
$26.00
9 bids
Free shipping

Ultra RARE& Retired Limited 1st Edition Princess Diana & Valentino Beanie Babies

Time left:
$14,499.99
or Best Offer
Free shipping

LOT OF 5 RARE & RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY~CONGO THE BLACK GORILLA MONKEY 5.5"~NEW!

Time left:
$5.99
or Best Offer

Cute Beanie Baby Lot Of 5 Rare Kittens/Cats

Includes 3 Teenie Beanie Baby Kittens! Meow!
 Time left:
$0.99
0 bids
$11.99
Buy It Now

RARE & RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY~CLASSY THE BLUE BEAR 8" (THE PEOPLE'S BEANIE) NEW!

Time left:
$4.35
or Best Offer
Free shipping

"Mystic" Beanie Babies *RARE*

Time left:
$3.29
0 bids

RARE & RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY~MEL THE KOALA BEAR 8"~NEW! MINT WITH MINT TAGS!

Time left:
$3.94
or Best Offer
Free shipping

Newly listedTy SNOOPY ~Camp Snoopy Exclusive Promo Tag~ Beanie Baby ~ MINT ~ RARE RETIRED

The item is listed as a Top Rated Plus item
Time left:
$29.90
Buy It Now

"Lurkey" Beanie Babies *RARE*

Time left:
$3.29
0 bids

*RARE* Pinky Poo the Poodle Pinky's TY Beanie Baby. COMBINE SHIPPING! ~MINT~

Time left:
$4.99
or Best Offer

RARE & RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY~PEANUT THE LIGHT BLUE ELEPHANT 9"~NEW! MWMT!

Time left:
$4.48
or Best Offer
Free shipping

"GiGi" Beanie Babies *RARE*

Time left:
$3.29
0 bids

Authenticated Rare GLORY the BEAR (ODDITY w/ NO FLAG) - TY BEANIE BABY

Time left:
$120.00
or Best Offer

Ty Beanie Babies Princess Diana PE Pellets - No Space, No Line, No Number RARE

Time left:
$7.99
0 bids
$19.99
Buy It Now

Newly listedTy Beanie Baby Princess Diana 1997 Made in China P.E. Pellets RARE!!!

Time left:
$995.00
or Best Offer
Free shipping

Ty Princess Di Beanie Baby Bear Collectors Quality MWMT Rare 1st ed PE Pellets

Time left:
$12.99
Buy It Now

Ty Beanie Babies with PVC Pellets/Pink Stamp/Rare/Retired Lot Of 60

Time left:
$45.00
0 bids

Ty Beanie Baby white dog Bichon CARGO 6" Mint/mint tag RETIRED * RARE

The item is listed as a Top Rated Plus item
Time left:
$18.99
Buy It Now
Free shipping
Top Rated Plus
  • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
  • Returns, money back
  • Ships in a business day with tracking
Thank you for helping us improve!
It looks like you included personal information in your comments.
  • Please make sure you remove email addresses, user IDS, item numbers, and other personal information from your comments.
  • If you ask a question using this form, we won't be able to respond. Please contact customer support if you need help.
Items per page: 
1 2 3 4 5