Skip to main content
eBay

ORIGINAL BEANIE BABY
2d 11h 28m left
$0.99
1 bid
TY BEANIE BABY ORIGINAL NWT MYSTIC UNICORN RARE RETIRED MINT 1994!
28d 3h 45m left
$149.99
Buy It Now
or Best Offer
Retired Ty Beanie Baby Mystic White Unicorn Yarn Mane Iridescent Horn
The item is listed as a Top Rated Plus item
23d 5h 37m left
$3.95
Buy It Now
or Best Offer
Mystic (iridescent horn with coarse mane) the Unicorn Ty Beanie Baby MWMT!
3d 4h 9m left
$1.04
2 bids
Free Shipping
Mystic the Unicorn Beanie Baby RARE Numbered #200
3d 2h 18m left
$349.98
Buy It Now
or Best Offer
Mystic the unicorn, 1994 beanie babies
3d 5h 57m left
$2.00
0 bids
Retired TY MYSTIC the UNICORN BEANIE BUDDY - MINT
7d 14h 2m left
$9.95
Buy It Now
NWT BEANIE BABY
4d 4h 5m left
$4.99
Buy It Now
Ty Beanie Babies 2 Mystic Unicorns
4d 13h 23m left
$5.99
0 bids
$9.99
Buy It Now
Free Shipping
TY Beanie Babies - 4007 - MYSTIC - White Unicorn with an Iridescent Horn
The item is listed as a Top Rated Plus item
17d 12h 52m left
$9.99
Buy It Now
or Best Offer
Free Shipping
mystic beanie baby
42m left
$0.50
0 bids
TY Beanie Baby - MYSTIC the Unicorn (tan horn & yarn mane) (8 inch) - MWMT's
The item is listed as a Top Rated Plus item
13d 8h 1m left
$5.89
Buy It Now
Free Shipping
Ty MYSTIC the White Unicorn Beanie Baby ~ MINT ~ RETIRED
The item is listed as a Top Rated Plus item
20d 5h 8m left
$3.40
Buy It Now
TY Retired Original Beanie Baby Mystic
4h 34m left
$2.00
0 bids
TY beanie baby MYSTIC UNICORN Authentic MINT With TAGS VINTAGE
The item is listed as a Top Rated Plus item
29d 6h 27m left
$3.13
Buy It Now
Mystic the Unicorn Ty Beanie Baby 8
1d 21h 47m left
$3.50
0 bids
$5.00
Buy It Now
Mystic the Unicorn! RARE Numbered #003! You won't find a numbered, more rare!!
7d 10h 34m left
$350.00
Buy It Now
or Best Offer
Free Shipping
2 Ty Beanie Baby Opposites Attract Collection Mystic & The End Black & White
The item is listed as a Top Rated Plus item
27d 7h 3m left
$16.99
Buy It Now
Mystic Original Beanie Baby
6d 4h 8m left
$10.00
0 bids
$30.00
Buy It Now
Beanie baby - Mystic - retired - with Tush Tag
The item is listed as a Top Rated Plus item
26d 1h 12m left
$0.99
Buy It Now
Ty Beanie Babies Mystic The Unicorn Coarse Mane Shiny Horn GUC 90s
6d 4h 40m left
$0.99
0 bids
RARE & RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY~MYSTIC THE WHITE UNICORN(TAN HORN&YARN MANE) NEW!
14d 6h 37m left
$5.19
Buy It Now
or Best Offer
Free Shipping
Mystic Beanie Baby PVC 1994 Unicorn
20d 0h 43m left
$200.00
Buy It Now
or Best Offer
Rare Mystic Beanie Baby with Gold Horn
6d 6h 41m left
$0.99
0 bids
$45.00
Buy It Now
1993 - Original - Ty Beanie -
The item is listed as a Top Rated Plus item
22d 6h 26m left
$7.19
Buy It Now
or Best Offer
Mystic beanie baby
6d 7h 18m left
$0.99
0 bids
TY Beanie Baby with Tag Mystic the Unicorn
The item is listed as a Top Rated Plus item
4d 16h 37m left
$7.75
Buy It Now
Mystic the Unicorn Ty Original Beanie Baby w/Tag 1994 Retired
The item is listed as a Top Rated Plus item
10d 4h 15m left
$18.95
Buy It Now
or Best Offer
Free Shipping
Retired Mystic Beanie Baby. Selling 3 versions.
6d 8h 52m left
$10.50
0 bids
$20.50
Buy It Now
RARE&RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY~MYSTIC THE UNICORN 8
24d 13h 48m left
$5.45
Buy It Now
or Best Offer
Free Shipping

Browse all Retired Original Ty Beanie Babies